The Emerging Importance of Sleep Regularity on Cardiovascular Health and Cognitive Impairment in Older Adults: A Review of the Literature
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/nss.s452033
2024-05-29
Nature and Science of Sleep
Abstract:Shuo Qin, Michael WL Chee Centre for Sleep and Cognition, National University of Singapore, Singapore Correspondence: Michael WL Chee, Centre for Sleep and Cognition, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Email The regularity of sleep/wake patterns across multiple days is emerging as an important determinant of health. However, the association between sleep regularity and health outcomes in the aging population is not well understood. The current systematic review identified 22 publications that examined the relationship between sleep regularity and selected health outcomes: cardiovascular risk, cognitive impairment, and mortality. All studies were published after 2010, reflecting a growing research interest in daily sleep regularity. Low sleep regularity was consistently associated with higher cardiovascular risk and elevated risk of all-cause mortality. Results on cognitive impairment are mixed, with inconsistency likely attributed to small sample sizes and differences in sleep regularity assessment. Overall, regularity in sleep carries important information about health and should be included in future studies that collect daily sleep measures. Gaps in literature and methodological shortcomings are discussed. Keywords: sleep regularity, Aging, cardiovascular health, cognitive impairment, mortality It is widely acknowledged that advancing age brings about changes in both the duration and quality of sleep. 1 These age-related differences are systematically related to cardiovascular health, 2 cognitive abilities, 3 dementia, 4 and all-cause mortality. 5 Most existing literature on sleep and health outcomes has largely focused on single-night assessment of sleep duration and efficiency. However, no two nights of sleep are the same, and the day-to-day variations in sleep metrics can carry additional information about a person's health compared to average measures. The day-to-day variation in sleep/wake patterns sleep metrics (ie duration and bedtime) over an observation period has been reported across a wide age range. 6 This variation, also known as sleep regularity, has been linked to health-relevant factors such as mental well-being and physical illness. 7–9 Sleep regularity can be quantified as the intra-individual standard deviations of sleep metrics across days (duration, bedtime and fragmentation) or as similarity in sleep/wake patterns across 24 hours (sleep regularity index). 10 Wrist actigraphy and other wearable devices have made it feasible to objectively assess daily sleep regularity at scale and over periods of weeks and longer, offering a richer understanding of sleep's relationship with health. A comprehensive review 11 by Bei et al in 2016 identified 53 publications examining the correlates of sleep regularity across the lifespan. The review found that low sleep regularity, despite imperfect assessments, was associated with adverse health outcomes. Although most studies in the Bei et al, review appear not to be explicitly designed to evaluate sleep regularity, over a third (19) of the studies included older adults over the age of 50, indicating a substantial interest in examining the relationship between sleep and health outcomes in this age group. The current review will specifically focus on sleep regularity in older adults over the age of 50. The declines in both physical and cognitive health that come with aging, leading to premature mortality, impose substantial costs on both healthcare and public service systems. Various measures of sleep have been examined as potential biomarkers in aging. 12,13 In the 2016 review by Bei et al, cardiovascular risk and cognitive impairment/dementia were the two most studied outcomes in older adults. The current review would explicitly focus on these two health outcomes with the most evidence and the ultimate health outcome (premature mortality). Recent large-scale epidemiological studies, integrating actigraphy for objective sleep measurement, have paved the way for more in-depth investigations into how sleep regularity interacts with important health outcomes. Datasets like MrOS, 14 SOF, 14 MESA, 15 and UK Biobank 16–18 combine multi-night actigraphy-measured sleep with assessments of cardiovascular risk factors, cognitive impairment, and dementia. Some of these datasets, such as UK Biobank, tracked mortality. 16,18 Consequently, there has been a notable increase in publications since the 2016 review focusing on sleep regularity and its implications for health in the aging population. Considering this emerging research topic, the primary objective of this review is to systematically compile existing evidence regarding the importance of sleep regularity on cardiovascular health, cognitive i -Abstract Truncated-
neurosciences,clinical neurology