Abstract:For better decisions in social interactions, humans often must understand the thinking of others and predict their actions. Since such predictions are uncertain, multiple predictions may be necessary for better decision-making. However, the neural processes and computations underlying such social decision-making remain unclear. We investigated this issue by developing a behavioral paradigm and performing functional magnetic resonance imaging and computational modeling. In our task, female and male participants were required to predict others' choices in order to make their own value-based decisions, as the outcome depended on others' choices. Results showed, to make choices, the participants mostly relied on a value difference (primary) generated from the case where others would make a likely choice, but sometimes they additionally used another value difference (secondary) from the opposite case where others make an unlikely choice. We found that the activations in the posterior cingulate cortex (PCC) correlated with the primary difference while the activations in the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (rdlPFC) correlated with the secondary difference. Analysis of neural coupling and temporal dynamics suggested a three-step processing network, beginning with the left amygdala signals for predictions of others' choices. Modulated by these signals, the PCC and rdlPFC reflect the respective value differences for self-decisions. Finally, the medial prefrontal cortex integrated these decision signals for a final decision. Our findings elucidate the neural process of constructing value-based decisions by predicting others and illuminate their key variables with social modulations, providing insight into the differential functional roles of these brain regions in this process.Significance Statement In daily life, to adjust our decisions, we constantly predict others' choices, but the inherent uncertainty means we face multiple scenarios for different choices by others. Using computational modeling-based fMRI, we identified a network in three-stage computations for such decision-making. Amygdala signals represent predictions of others' choices. These signals then interact with the posterior cingulate cortex and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, representing the decision variables for the prediction of others' likely and unlikely choices, respectively. Finally, these signals modulate the medial prefrontal cortex, influencing our final choices. These pivotal variables and their corresponding brain signals play a fundamental role in a broad range of social cognitive processes. Our findings shed light on underlying mechanisms for complex social interactions in human behavior.

Bayesian Inference of Other Minds Explains Human Choices in Group Decision Making

Theory of Minds: Understanding Behavior in Groups Through Inverse Planning

Bayesian Heuristics for Group Decisions

Human collective intelligence as distributed Bayesian inference

A Bayesian theory of mind approach to modeling cooperation and communication

Bayesian decision making in human collectives with binary choices

Decision-Making with Predictions of Others' Likely and Unlikely Choices in the Human Brain

Can we infer player behavior tendencies from a player's decision-making data? Integrating Theory of Mind to Player Modeling

Collective Intelligence in Human-AI Teams: A Bayesian Theory of Mind Approach

Mind in the Machine: Perceived Minds Induce Decision Change

A Brain-inspired Theory of Collective Mind Model for Efficient Social Cooperation

Satisficing Mentalizing: Bayesian Models of Theory of Mind Reasoning in Scenarios with Different Uncertainties

Decision-Making in a Social Multi-Armed Bandit Task: Behavior, Electrophysiology and Pupillometry

Neural Mechanisms of Social Learning and Decision-Making

Unveiling the latent dynamics in social cognition with multi-agent inverse reinforcement learning

Modeling Theory of Mind in Multi-Agent Games Using Adaptive Feedback Control

Egocentric Tendencies in Theory of Mind Reasoning: An Empirical and Computational Analysis

Bayesian Inference of Social Norms as Shared Constraints on Behavior

Collective behavior from surprise minimization

Evolution of a theory of mind

A calculus of probability or belief? Neural underpinnings of social decision-making in a card game