Cross Culture Examination of Perceived Overqualification, Psychological Well-Being and Job Search: The Moderating Role of Proactive Behavior
Alaa Amin Abdalla,Imran Saeed,Jawad Khan,Alaa Abdalla
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s441168
IF: 3.974
2024-02-15
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Alaa Amin Abdalla, 1 Imran Saeed, 2 Jawad Khan 3 1 Academic Programs for Military Colleges, Abu Dhabi University, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates; 2 IBMS, The University of Agriculture, Peshawar, Pakistan; 3 College of Management, Shenzhen University, Shenzhen, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Imran Saeed, Email Purpose: This study delves into the intricate interplay between perceived overqualification, job search behavior, psychological well-being, and proactive behavior, within two distinct and diverse work settings. Methods: Drawing upon the Person-Job Fit theory, we investigated these dynamics in two unique samples: Sample 1 encompassed corporate sector employees in the United Arab Emirates (N=409), while Sample 2 comprised IT sector workers in Pakistan (N=337). Hayes PROCESS macro were used to examine the proposed hypotheses and AMOS (Version 28) were conducted to examine model fitness. Results: In Study 1, we established a positive association between perceived overqualification and job search behavior among employees in the UAE corporate sector. Notably, this relationship was mediated by psychological well-being, suggesting that the impact of perceived overqualification on job search behavior is, in part, channeled through its effects on individuals' psychological well-being. Study 2 showed that proactive behavior exhibited a moderating effect on the negative link between perceived overqualification and psychological well-being. Specifically, employees displaying higher levels of proactive behavior demonstrated a less adverse influence of perceived overqualification on psychological well-being. Importantly, this adaptive effect of proactive behavior was found to indirectly influence job search behavior. Discussion: The findings highlight the nature of perceived overqualification in the workplace and its varying impact on employee behavior and well-being across different cultural and work settings. The mediation by psychological well-being and moderation by proactive behavior in these relationships underscores the importance of individual responses to perceived job fit issues. These insights are crucial for understanding employee behavior in diverse work environments and can inform practices for managing perceived overqualification. Keywords: perceived overqualification, psychological well-being, job search behavior, proactive behavior, P-J fit theory Employee overqualification refers to a scenario in the workforce where an employee possesses qualifications like skills, education, and experience that surpass the requirements set for a particular job. 1 This mismatch between an employee's credentials and the demands of the job has become more prevalent globally. 2 For instance, approximately 43% of college graduates in the United States were employed in positions that did not necessitate their obtained degrees. 3 The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) statistics reveal even higher instances of this phenomenon in developing economies like Cyprus, Peru, Romania, and Turkey (OECD, 2019). As an illustration, in Turkey, around 29% of the workforce is believed to be overqualified for their current positions, and an additional 36% are engaged in jobs that significantly differ from their formal educational backgrounds. This situation can result in a person-job misfit, as individuals may have to settle for jobs that they perceive as beneath their skills or expectations due to limited opportunities. 4 In recent years, the field of management research has increasingly focused on the concept of perceived overqualification (POQ) and its impact on employee attitudes and behaviors. 5 Numerous studies have been conducted, revealing that the feeling of being overqualified for a job has significant implications for employees. These studies have demonstrated that perceiving oneself as overqualified is associated with negative outcomes, including negative job attitudes, 6 reduced well-being, 7 heightened career stress, 8 and a higher likelihood of leaving one's current job. 1 However, a noteworthy trend has emerged in the previous research, indicating that overqualified individuals might actually have positive effects on organizations when certain conditions are met. Despite this potential value that overqualified employees could bring to an organization, the prevailing understanding is that their effectiveness and career prospects often overlooked. Going beyond the simple dichotomy of positive and negative outcomes linked to overqualification, researchers have shifted their focus towards understanding how perceived overqualification influences employee -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary