Abstract:Many scholars have recently maintained that it is difficult if not impossible to postulate the definite parting of the ways between Judaism and Christianity in antiquity. It is argued in this paper that recent criticisms against the ‘parting of the ways’‐model resemble criticisms levelled against the classical identity theory formulated by Erik H. Erikson. His identity theory emphasises the sense of personal sameness and historical continuity. In recent decades, however, it has become common to question whether the notion of unified and consistent self does justice to diverse social realities in which individuals construct their sense of who they are. Furthermore, the developmental stage model claims to be universal and culturally neutral while, as a matter of fact, it is implicitly moralistic and value‐laden. In case of the ‘parting of the ways’‐model it has become clear that the model does not match the evidence showing an intense interaction between various Jewish and Christian communities during the first centuries CE. In addition, it has been claimed that the model is not an unbiased historical account but serves Christian theological interests. Comparing the ‘parting of the ways’‐theory with the Eriksonian identity theory highlights the problems inherent in both theories. It is suggested that psychological and social‐psychological theories arguing for the flexible and dynamic nature of identity construction are best suited to describe the emergence of early Christian identity in relation to Jews and Judaism.

Fifty Years Since “Identity: Youth and Crisis”: A Renewed Look at Erikson’s Writings on Identity

Erikson and the Relational Context of Identity: Strengthening Connections With Attachment Theory

The Enduring Usefulness of Erikson’s Concept of the Identity Crisis in the 21st Century: An Analysis of Student Mental Health Concerns

Identity and Community: Erikson Reconsidered

Intergenerational, Unconscious, and Embodied: Three Underdeveloped Aspects of Erikson’s Theory of Identity

Who Am I, Who Are We? Erikson and a Transactional Approach to Identity Research

Erik H. Erikson’s identity theory and the formation of early Christianity

Erik H. Erikson and the deep context of ministry

Erik Erikson and his problematic identity

Revisiting Erik Erikson’s Legacy on Culture, Race, and Ethnicity

Subjectivity, complexity and the social world Erikson's identity concept and contemporary relational theories

Erik Erikson’s Place in Relational Psychoanalysis: Discussion of “Some Thoughts on Trust and Betrayal”

Erik H. Erikson’s Young Man Luther: A Classic Revisited, Again

Understanding identity integration: Theoretical, methodological, and applied issues

Identity Research and the Psychosocial Formation of One's Sense of Spiritual Self: Implications for Religious Educators and Christian Institutions of Higher Education

Human Development and Pastoral Care in a Postmodern Age: Donald Capps, Erik H. Erikson, and Beyond

Does Identity Precede Intimacy? Testing Erikson’s Theory on Romantic Development in Emerging Adults of the 21st Century

Untapped richness in Erik H. Erikson's rootstock

Eriksonian personality research and its implications for psychotherapy

Identity, Intimacy, and Generativity in Adolescence and Young Adulthood: A Test of the Psychosocial Model

Dynamics of Identity Development in Adolescence: A Decade in Review