Comparison of Pharmacological Treatments for Agitated Delirium in the Last Days of Life
Natsuki Kawashima,Naosuke Yokomichi,Tatsuya Morita,Ritsuko Yabuki,Takayuki Hisanaga,Kengo Imai,Yumi Hirose,Miho Shimokawa,Satoru Miwa,Toshihiro Yamauchi,Soichiro Okamoto,Eriko Satomi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2024.02.008
IF: 5.576
2024-02-01
Journal of Pain and Symptom Management
Abstract:CONTEXT: Antipsychotics are often used in managing symptoms of terminal delirium, but evidence is limited.OBJECTIVES: To explore the comparative effectiveness of haloperidol with as-needed benzodiazepines (HPD) vs. chlorpromazine (CPZ) vs. levomepromazine (LPZ) for agitated delirium in the last days.METHODS: A prospective observational study was conducted in two palliative care units in Japan. Adult cancer patients who developed agitated delirium with a modified Richmond Agitation-Sedation Scale (RASS-PAL) of one or more were included; palliative care specialist physicians determined that the etiology was irreversible; and estimated survival was 3 weeks or less. Patients treated with HPD, CPZ, or LPZ were analyzed. We measured RASS, NuDESC, Agitation Distress Scale (ADS), and Communication Capacity Scale (CCS) on Days 1 and 3.RESULTS: A total of 277 patients were enrolled, and 214 were analyzed (112 in HPD, 50 in CPZ, and 52 in LPZ). In all groups, the mean RASS-PAL score significantly decreased on Day 3 (1.37 to -1.01, 1.87 to -1.04, 1.79 to -0.62, respectively; P < 0.001); the NuDESC and ADS scores also significantly decreased. The percentages of patients with moderate to severe agitation and those with full communication capacity on Day 3 were not significantly different. The treatments were well-tolerated. While one-fourth of HPD group changed antipsychotics, 88% or more of CPZ and LPZ groups continued the initial antipsychotics.CONCLUSION: Haloperidol with as-needed benzodiazepine, chlorpromazine, or levomepromazine may be effective and safe for terminal agitation. Chlorpromazine and levomepromazine may have an advantage of no need to change medications.
medicine, general & internal,clinical neurology,health care sciences & services