Abstract:There is a considerable body of literature that outlines the dangers of mobile phone use by drivers. However, there is very little research that explores the role and effectiveness of attempts to tackle this specific road user problem. Generally, normative motives are more likely to generate compliance with traffic law, and are more likely to be developed through approaches which focus on engagement and education. There would seem to be little potential for them to be developed through the use of penalty points and fines, which rely on more instrumental logic. Nonetheless, the decision was made in the UK in recent years to cease offering 'courses' (inputs to detected phone-using drivers offered as an alternative to prosecution) for mobile phone offences. This decision was made despite a lack of evidence one way or another about their effectiveness in tackling both handheld mobile phone use and handsfree mobile phone distraction - a form of distraction not explicitly covered in law. This research project aimed to explore driver education as an alternative to prosecution for mobile phone use while driving offences, focusing on perceptions and experiences of one particular educational intervention. This paper draws on 46 semi-structured interviews with those involved in delivering a specific intervention aimed at reducing handheld mobile phone use by drivers that was previously offered as an alternative to prosecution in the UK; the police officers identifying offenders for referral to such courses, those delivering the intervention, drivers attending the course as an alternative to prosecution and members of the public attending the course as general education. Four key themes, with underpinning subthemes, emerged; 1) Police officer discretion and control over entry into the criminal justice system 2) Police-public interactions, 3) Course experiences, and 4) Post-course considerations. Firstly, police officer discretion is an important determinant of criminal justice system outcome, based on subjective rather than legal decisions about whether or not to report drivers for an offence. Secondly, police officers negotiate encounters with road users using the avoidance of prosecution as a way of diffusing difficult conversations, sometimes by offering a course as a preferable alternative to prosecution, sometimes by encouraging handsfree phone use. Thirdly, course attendance provides an opportunity to develop both normative alignment through increased understanding of police work, and to appreciate a range of instrumental consequences associated with mobile phone use. Both self-reportedly impacted upon mobile phone use while driving. Finally, post-course considerations emphasised a focus on who should be offered courses as an alternative to prosecution, focusing upon desires for both punitive and rehabilitative responses to mobile phone using drivers.

‘A Very Expensive Lesson’: Counting the Costs of Penalty Notices for Anti-social Behaviour

Commodifying Justice: Discursive Strategies Used in the Legitimation of Infringement Notices for Minor Offences

Reconfiguring the violent encounter? Preloading, security staff and breathalyser use in the night-time economy

The increasing role of provincial administrative sanctions in Canadian impaired driving enforcement

What works and what does not work in reducing juvenile graffiti offending? A comparison of changes that occurred in the frequency of persistent graffitists’ patterns of offending following the announcement of two successive initiatives aimed at reducing graffiti proliferation

Punishment for Drunk Driving: A Study under the Malaysian Law

Changes in New Zealand's alcohol environment following implementation of the Sale and Supply of Alcohol Act (2012)

‘Weeds of Our Own Making’: Language Ideologies, Swearing and the Criminal Law

The consequences of drunken driving in South Africa

Detect and Deter or Catch and Release: Are Financial Penalties an Effective Way to Penalise Deliberate Tax Evaders?

Taking the right course: The possibilities and challenges of offering alternatives to prosecution for drivers detected using mobile phones while driving

The Impact of Last Drinks Legislation: Exit Intoxication and Perceptions of Risk within Nighttime Entertainment Districts in Brisbane, Australia

Modelling the impacts of volumetric and minimum unit pricing for alcohol on social harms in Australia

Battered Women, Startled Householders and Psychological Self-Defence: Anglo-Australian Perspectives

Young Drivers, Deterrence Theory, and Punishment Avoidance: A Qualitative Exploration

A cost-benefit analysis of enforcement efforts to reduce serving intoxicated patrons

The impact of Indigenous‐led programs on alcohol‐related criminal incidents: a multiple baseline design evaluation

Can counter-advertising exposing alcohol sponsorship and harms influence sport spectators' support for alcohol policies? An experimental study

An injury awareness education program on outcomes of juvenile justice offenders in Western Australia: an economic analysis

A historical overview of legislated alcohol policy in the Northern Territory of Australia: 1979-2021

From Magna Carta To The Contemporary System Of Financial Penalties In The Criminal Law