Abstract:Network communities are a fundamental characteristic of human brain's circuit organization. Community detection methods are differentially sensitive to the connectome topology and can yield highly dissimilar estimates, especially in underdeveloped brains, leading to method‐dependent mappings to cognitive and other parameters. A probabilistic approach may be more robust than modularity‐maximization and geometric methods. Community structure is a fundamental topological characteristic of optimally organized brain networks. Currently, there is no clear standard or systematic approach for selecting the most appropriate community detection method. Furthermore, the impact of method choice on the accuracy and robustness of estimated communities (and network modularity), as well as method‐dependent relationships between network communities and cognitive and other individual measures, are not well understood. This study analyzed large datasets of real brain networks (estimated from resting‐state fMRI from n = 5251 pre/early adolescents in the adolescent brain cognitive development [ABCD] study), and n = 5338 synthetic networks with heterogeneous, data‐inspired topologies, with the goal to investigate and compare three classes of community detection methods: (i) modularity maximization‐based (Newman and Louvain), (ii) probabilistic (Bayesian inference within the framework of stochastic block modeling (SBM)), and (iii) geometric (based on graph Ricci flow). Extensive comparisons between methods and their individual accuracy (relative to the ground truth in synthetic networks), and reliability (when applied to multiple fMRI runs from the same brains) suggest that the underlying brain network topology plays a critical role in the accuracy, reliability and agreement of community detection methods. Consistent method (dis)similarities, and their correlations with topological properties, were estimated across fMRI runs. Based on synthetic graphs, most methods performed similarly and had comparable high accuracy only in some topological regimes, specifically those corresponding to developed connectomes with at least quasi‐optimal community organization. In contrast, in densely and/or weakly connected networks with difficult to detect communities, the methods yielded highly dissimilar results, with Bayesian inference within SBM having significantly higher accuracy compared to all others. Associations between method‐specific modularity and demographic, anthropometric, physiological and cognitive parameters showed mostly method invariance but some method dependence as well. Although method sensitivity to different levels of community structure may in part explain method‐dependent associations between modularity estimates and parameters of interest, method dependence also highlights potential issues of reliability and reproducibility. These findings suggest that a probabilistic approach, such as Bayesian inference in the framework of SBM, may provide consistently reliable estimates of community structure across network topologies. In addition, to maximize robustness of biological inferences, identified network communities and their cognitive, behavioral and other correlates should be confirmed with multiple reliable detection methods.

Distance-dependent consensus thresholds for generating group-representative structural brain networks

An exponential random graph modeling approach to creating group-based representative whole-brain connectivity networks

A Deconvolution-Based Approach to Identifying Large-Scale Effective Connectivity.

Resolving structural variability in network models and the brain

Single-Subject Morphological Brain Networks: Connectivity Mapping, Topological Characterization and Test-Retest Reliability

Construction of Multi-Scale Consistent Brain Networks: Methods and Applications

Sparse DCM for whole-brain effective connectivity from resting-state fMRI data

Connectome-scale Group-Wise Consistent Resting-State Network Analysis in Autism Spectrum Disorder.

Structurally informed resting-state effective connectivity recapitulates cortical hierarchy

Estimating effective connectivity in linear brain network models

Toward Leveraging Human Connectomic Data in Large Consortia: Generalizability of fMRI-Based Brain Graphs Across Sites, Sessions, and Paradigms

Community detection in the human connectome: Method types, differences and their impact on inference

Statistical Brain Network Analysis

Proportional thresholding in resting-state fMRI functional connectivity networks and consequences for patient-control connectome studies: Issues and recommendations

Resolving Structure in Human Brain Organization: Identifying Mesoscale Organization in Weighted Network Representations

Group-representative functional network estimation from multi-subject fMRI data via MRF-based image segmentation

Comparison of Brain Networks based on Predictive Models of Connectivity

The specificity of different-distance connections in human structural connectomes

Inferring Group-Wise Consistent Multimodal Brain Networks Via Multi-View Spectral Clustering

Modeling of Large-Scale Functional Brain Networks Based on Structural Connectivity from DTI: Comparison with EEG Derived Phase Coupling Networks and Evaluation of Alternative Methods along the Modeling Path

A Two-Part Mixed-Effects Modeling Framework For Analyzing Whole-Brain Network Data