Theoretical versus Practical Energy: A Plea for More Transparency in the Energy Calculation of Different Rechargeable Battery Systems

Johannes Betz,Georg Bieker,Paul Meister,Tobias Placke,Martin Winter,Richard Schmuch
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/aenm.201803170
IF: 27.8
2018-12-21
Advanced Energy Materials
Abstract:Electrochemical energy storage at a large scale poses one of the main technological challenges of this century. The scientific community in academia and industry worldwide intensively is exploring various alternative rechargeable battery concepts beside state‐of‐the‐art lithium ion batteries (LIBs), for example, all‐solid‐state batteries, lithium/sulfur batteries, magnesium/sulfur batteries or dual‐ion batteries that could outperform LIBs in different aspects. Often, these concepts also promise very high theoretical energies per mass or volume. However, as theoretical values exclude numerous relevant parameters, they do not translate directly into practically achievable energy values: The gaps between practical capacities and voltages compared to the theoretical values differ for each system. In order to provide high transparency and to illustrate which cell components are most important in the limitation of the practical energy values, in this study, the specific energies and energy densities are calculated in six subsequent steps—from the theoretical energy values of the active materials alone to the practical energy values in an 18650 cylindrical cell. By providing a tool to calculate the energy values of six different battery technologies with different assumptions made evident, this study aims for more transparency and reliability in the comparison of different cell chemistries. The practical energy content of different alternative cell chemistries (all‐solid‐state batteries, different types of lithium/sulfur batteries, magnesium/sulfur batteries, dual‐ion batteries) in comparison to lithium ion batteries is estimated in six calculation steps, from the theoretical energy content at material level to the practical energy at cell level. Special emphasis is placed on the necessary amount of electrolyte.
materials science, multidisciplinary,chemistry, physical,physics, applied, condensed matter,energy & fuels
What problem does this paper attempt to address?