Abstract:In the past several decades, women have made considerable progress toward gender equity in the USA, but women in general and women of color in particular continue to be underrepresented in some fields of STEM, notably engineering and computing. Women of color in these fields are also underrepresented in the STEM education research literature. In this article, we review the literature on sociocultural theory and empirical research grounded in it to propose a framework for thinking about how young women of color encounter and experience engineering and computing in local educational contexts, and how their encounters and experiences might be enhanced and lead to more sustained interests and identities in these fields. The framework motivates an examination of the interrelationships among institutional practices, normative discourses, identities, interactional dynamics, and experience-near external exclusions in the contexts of the young women's lives. As such, our concerns are less with provision of the <i>content</i> per se of engineering or computing and more with the structure, organization, and discourses of the educational contexts in which the groundwork is laid for the development of interests and identities related to these fields. We briefly review significant challenges faced by middle and high school girls and young women of color as they encounter in-school and out-of-school practices and interactional dynamics related to engineering and computing, respond to local and societal discourses circulating about these fields, form social and personal identities with respect to these fields, and grapple with external exclusions, e.g., undocumented legal status and unresponsive institutions, affecting pursuit of engineering and computing. We then examine ways in which scholars taking sociocultural approaches have addressed these challenges through action research. Next, we assess the promise and limitations of these efforts in overcoming the challenges. Due to the sociocultural perspective that frames our approach, the research methodology used in the work we review is primarily qualitative, and the approach to action is primarily participatory action research. We conclude the paper with a preliminary synthesis of research on the sociocultural system in which young women of color in the USA and Canada encounter and pursue engineering and computing, including its foundational components in mathematics and science education. We argue that this system repeatedly plays out in unequal opportunity structures, deficit discourses, marginalizing interactions, conflicting identity demands, and external exclusions for many young women of color. The system carries expectancies that make sustained participation in engineering and computing risky and difficult, even if these young women have interest, ability, or ambitions to pursue these fields. We propose a program of response to these barriers, based in sociocultural practice theory.

Critical race and feminist standpoint theories in physics education research: A historical review and potential applications

Racial equity in physics education research

Investigating society's educational debts due to racism and sexism in student attitudes about physics using quantitative critical race theory

Challenges faced by women and persons excluded because of their ethnicity and race in physics learning environments: Review of the literature and recommendations for departments and instructors

Diversity in Physics Education Research: A Decade of Inclusion and Future Challenges

Resistance to Critiques in the Academic Literature: An Example from Physics Education Research

Infusing Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Throughout Our Physics Curriculum: (Re)defining What It Means to Be a Physicist

Importance of accounting for student identities and intersectionality for creating equitable and inclusive physics learning environments

Associations between learning assistants, passing introductory physics, and equity: A quantitative critical race theory investigation

Equity in college physics student learning: A critical quantitative intersectionality investigation

Teaching and learning special relativity theory in secondary and lower undergraduate education: A literature review

Opinion | Think Physics, Think Man: Barrier's to Women's Participation in Physics Education

How the physics culture shapes the experiences of undergraduate women physics majors: A comparative case study of three physics departments

Gender Equity in Physics Labs: A Review

Women in physics in the United States: Reaching toward equity and inclusion

Science, technology, society, and environment (STSE) and pre-service physics teacher education: Lessons for physics and education faculty

Undergraduate physics students' experiences: Exploring the impact of underrepresented identities and intersectionality

On the teaching and learning of physics: A Criticism and a Systemic Approach

Enriching gender in PER: A binary past and a complex future

Bourdieu, networks, and movements: Using the concepts of habitus, field and capital to understand a network analysis of gender differences in undergraduate physics

Addressing underrepresentation of young women of color in engineering and computing through the lens of sociocultural theory