Fifth-Grade Bilingual Students and Precursors to “Subtractive Schooling”
Jo Worthy,Alejandra Rodríguez-Galindo,Lori Czop Assaf,Leticia Martínez,Kimberley Cuero
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15235882.2003.10162807
2003-07-01
Bilingual Research Journal
Abstract:In this paper, we present a yearlong ethnographic study of fifth-grade students who are either immigrants or the children of immigrants from Latin American countries, predominantly Mexico. We examined how they used their two languages at home, in the community, and at school. We also examined their perspectives, and those of their parents and teacher, about bilingualism and their awareness of barriers they may face in the future. Interviews and observations suggest these students were in a supportive bilingual environment. Their teacher provided materials and instruction in both languages. As a fluent Spanish speaker and cultural insider, she believes that proficiency in Spanish is important and serves as a strong foundation for acquiring English. The students' parents all valued maintenance of Spanish, and several were proactive in trying to ensure their children remained fluent Spanish speakers. At the time of the study, most students could speak, read, and write Spanish fluently and were concurrently learning English. At first glance, it appeared that the students in this study had been largely sheltered from the pressures to assimilate and that their prospects for maintaining their native-language proficiency were favorable. However, contradictory messages about bilingualism soon became apparent. Students demonstrated awareness of the pressures they will face in the future and acknowledged they must be prepared to struggle to maintain their language and culture. This study's findings help to explicate the conflicts that students in upper elementary grades feel about being bilingual within the dominant English monolingual culture.