Abstract:[1] Edward D. Latham's Tonality as Drama presents an interdisciplinary methodology for opera analysis that fuses the dramatic theories of Konstantin Stanislavsky with the musical theories of Heinrich Schenker. The approach attempts to transcend previous analytic endeavors by providing a systematic account of the connections between dramatic action and tonal processes within the music. While the text is anything but light on theory, its audience is tripartite: the scholarly musician (including musicologists, theorists, and Schenkerians), the opera performer (including singers, directors, and conductors), and the more general opera enthusiast. Latham approaches both his theoretical and analytical chapters with the diverse background of his audience in mind. Each group is offered the necessary explanations to avoid alienating or offending a specific type of reader, all the while strengthening his credibility with each group by presenting a well-rounded historical, theoretical, and performance-based analytical interpretation of each of the four selected American operas.[2] The Stanislavsky System, a well-respected approach to acting, is likely unknown to most musical readers; however, Latham provides a thorough history and description of Stanislavsky's theory in Chapter 2. While the approach to analyzing a dramatic role is summarized in its entirety, that which is most pertinent to Latham's study is identified as "Internal Preparation" or "Units/Objectives" (27). Stanislavsky defines an objective as "the goal of a character for a given unit of the drama," while "the overarching goal of a character" for the play is that character's "superobjective" (28). Latham describes the levels in Stanislavsky's large-scale hierarchy, including additions made by various proponents of the Stanislavsky method, as follows: "1) the super-superobjective (SSO); 2) the superobjective (SO); 3) the interrupted objective (IO); 4) the main objective (MO); 3) the beat objective (BO); and 4) the line objective (LO). Other types of objectives that may be included at each level are the hidden objective (HO) and the subconscious objective (SbO)." (31)[3] While the music-theoretically inclined may already notice a useful and convenient parallel between the hierarchical and fundamentally organic systems of Schenker and Stanislavsky, Latham further points to similarities in the historical development and reception of the two systems. Critical, however, is Latham's delineation of specific points of comparison between a Stanislavskian conception of drama and a Schenkerian conception of tonal music. He turns to aesthetician James Merriman's work to justify the pairing: "in order to compare features of music and drama, those features must be possible in both mediums."(1)Latham identifies dramatic closure-the character's achievement of objectives-and tonal closure-the completion of the Ursatz-as the primary feature held in common between drama and music. As a means of avoiding accidental or ad hoc correlation between the dramatic and musical closure, as might occur with works composed completely within the tonal system, Latham chooses works for analysis from American operas composed during the first half of the twentieth century. In doing so, he selects operas that employ tonal processes for the express purpose of dramatic effect, what he calls "strategic tonality" (8-9).[4] Through the analysis of Scott Joplin's Treemonisha, George Gershwin's Porgy and Bess, Kurt Weill's Street Scene, and Aaron Copland's The Tender Land, Latham identifies four drama-centric background-level paradigms: the open-ended coda, the prolonged permanent interruption, the multi-movement Anstieg (initial ascent), and the multi-movement initial arpeggiation (11-13). It is with careful consideration of not only Schenker's writings, but also the writings of Carl Schachter, William Rothstein, Allen Forte, Adele Katz, Patrick McCreless, David Neumeyer, Matthew Brown, and others that Latham attempts to make his own mark on the Schenkerian doctrine. …

Opera in the Jazz Age

Italian-Style Opera Houses: A Historical Review

Interpretation Content of the Modern Musical Theater: Portrait in the Style of ad Libitum

The Role of Culture in Global Structural Transformation: Opera and the Baroque Crisis in Seventeenth-Century Europe

Analysing law in opera

An analysis of the essence of Chinese opera and vocal music from the perspective of hermeneutics and reception aesthetics

Unreliable Authors, Unreliable History: Opera in Joe Wright’s Adaptation of Atonement

Women in Opera: Not Yet Defeated

Jazz Performance of 1920s as a Component of Popular American Music

Oklahoma!: ideology and politics in the vernacular tradition of the American musical

Jazz and the Philosophy of Art

FEMALE IMAGES IN OPERA CREATIVITY OF THE AMERICAN COMPOSERS

The Historical and Cultural Role of the Vienna-Budapest Operetta

Venice and Opera in the 18th Century

Influence of jazz and musical forms on pop and song culture

Musical and Theatrical Creativity in the Logos of Music History

Vocal Vibrato Characteristics in Historical and Contemporary Opera, Operetta, and Schlager

The Music-Hall Actress and Transcending Femininity in the Victorian Public Sphere. A Re-Orientation of Her Moral Status

Modern Chinese Opera in the formative years: Extrapolation of music and its socio-cultural development

Phenomena, Poiēsis, and Performance Profiling: Temporal-Textual Emphasis and Creative Process Analysis in Turandot at the Metropolitan Opera

Review of Edward D. Latham, Tonality as Drama: Closure and Interruption in Four Twentieth-Century American Operas (Denton: University of North Texas Press, 2008)