Abstract:Content moderation by social media companies is a challenge for regulators around the world. The European Union is trying to tackle this challenge with its Digital Services Act (DSA). Notably, Article 14 DSA aims to impose language requirements based on the principle of legal certainty to social media companies' terms and conditions, of which community standards (CS) are a part. The principle of legal certainty is one of the building blocks of international human rights law, and its inclusion in the DSA illustrates the human rights‐based approach anchored in this European regulation. Based on a content analysis of Facebook's CS, this paper shows that their standards do not meet European requirements for legal certainty and argues that important changes in content moderation governance would be needed for proper compliance. Such changes could generate a domino effect beyond the European Union and on Facebook's content moderation governance itself. At the same time, the DSA could also generate a boomerang effect on the legal certainty principle as such. From this perspective, the paper contributes to the literature on regulatory governance studies, and on international human rights law in social media studies from a European Union perspective. 摘要社交媒体公司的内容审核对世界各地的监管机构来说都是一个挑战。欧盟正试图通过其《数字服务法》(DSA)来应对这一挑战。值得注意的是,DSA第14条旨在基于法律确定性原则对社交媒体公司的条款和条件施加语言要求,这些条款包括社区标准(CS)。法律确定性原则是国际人权法的基石之一,将其纳入DSA体现了该欧洲法规中基于人权的做法。基于对脸书CS的内容分析,本文表明,脸书的标准不符合欧洲对法律确定性的要求,并论证认为,需要对内容审核治理进行重大改变才能实现正确合规。此类改变可能会在欧盟之外以及脸书的内容审核治理本身产生多米诺骨牌效应。与此同时,DSA也可能对法律确定性原则产生回旋效应。从这个角度来看,本文为"监管治理研究以及欧盟视角下社交媒体研究中的国际人权法"的相关文献作贡献。 Resumen La moderación de contenidos por parte de las empresas de redes sociales es un desafío para los reguladores de todo el mundo. La Unión Europea está intentando afrontar este desafío con su Ley de Servicios Digitales (DSA). En particular, el artículo 14 de la DSA tiene como objetivo imponer requisitos lingüísticos basados en el principio de seguridad jurídica a los términos y condiciones de las empresas de redes sociales, de los cuales los estándares comunitarios (CS) forman parte. El principio de seguridad jurídica es uno de los pilares del derecho internacional de los derechos humanos, y su inclusión en la DSA ilustra el enfoque basado en los derechos humanos anclado en esta regulación europea. Basado en un análisis de contenido de la CS de Facebook, este artículo muestra que sus estándares no cumplen con los requisitos europeos de seguridad jurídica y sostiene que se necesitarían cambios importantes en la gobernanza de la moderación de contenido para un cumplimiento adecuado. Tales cambios podrían generar un efecto dominó más allá de la Unión Europea y en la propia gobernanza de la moderación de contenidos de Facebook. Al mismo tiempo, la DSA también podría generar un efecto boomerang sobre el principio de seguridad jurídica como tal. Desde esta perspectiva, el artículo contribuye a la literatura sobre estudios de gobernanza regulatoria y sobre el derecho internacional de los derechos humanos en los estudios de redes sociales desde la perspectiva de la Unión Europea.

Information Disclosure by the European Union as a Tool to Improve Implementation? A Comparative Analysis of the Perception of Domestic Regulators

Fragmented Transparency: The Visibility of Agency Science in European Union Risk Regulation

ABC of Online Consumer Disclosure Duties: Improving Transparency and Legal Certainty in Europe

Judicial Enforcement of Environmental Democracy: a Critical Analysis of Case Law on Access to Environmental Information in the European Union

Left to interest groups? On the prospects for enforcing environmental law in the European Union

Environmental information disclosure: a cross-country analysis from European Union public companies

Non-disclosure of developmental neurotoxicity studies obstructs the safety assessment of pesticides in the European Union

The Quality of Environmental Data Disclosure. The case of Public Companies from the European Union Countries

An implementation assessment of China's Environmental Information Disclosure Decree

Legitimacy through targeted transparency? Regulatory effectiveness and sustainability of lobbying regulation in the European Union

Does the Directive of the European Union on disclosure of non-financial and diversity information improve reporting?

Can Facebook's community standards keep up with legal certainty? Content moderation governance under the pressure of the Digital Services Act

The limits of environmental accounting disclosure: enforcement of regulations, standards and interpretative strategies

Differentiated policy implementation in the European Union

Implementing the Marine Strategy Framework Directive: A policy perspective on regulatory, institutional and stakeholder impediments to effective implementation

Ecosystem approaches in the practice of national enforcement

Disclosing product placement in audiovisual media services: a practical and scientific perspective on the implementation of disclosures across the European Union

Reflections on the European Union’s Participation in Negotiations of the Global Plastic Pollution Instrument under International Environmental Law

Environmental information disclosure and public choice decisions for urban river restoration: A comparative study between Brussels (Belgium) and Guangzhou (China)

The Impact of the Rule of Law on Energy Policy in European Union Member States

Compliance with EU environmental law. The iceberg is melting