Abstract:Empirical This study examines how the practice of pension fund investment management informs the ownership behavior of pension funds vis‐à‐vis investee corporations. Using data from: 35 in‐depth semi‐structured interviews with pension fund trustees, executives, investment officers and financial intermediaries; documentary analysis; and observations of four fund investment meetings, we find a variation in pension fund behavior, where a very small number of well‐resourced and internally managed pension funds exhibit engaged ownership behavior. By contrast, the vast majority of pension funds operate at a considerable distance from their investee corporations having delegated pension fund investment management to a chain of external relationships involving actuaries, investment consultants, and fund managers. These relationships are laced with divergent interests and influence dynamics, which explain why these pension funds give primary emphasis to fund investment performance and display little concern for matters of ownership and corporate governance. The “New Financial Capitalism” is characterized by ownership concentration, yet at the same time liquidity and a lack of institutional investor engagement with corporations. Findings suggest that the principal‐agent view of the relationship between institutional investors and corporate managers is more assumed than demonstrated. This widely assumed theory of investor ownership and control is shown to be contingent upon the meanings and practices that underpin investment fund management by institutions. Shareowner engagement is proposed as a solution to problems of corporate governance. Findings about the relationships within the investment chain undermine the notions of pension funds behaving as owners and upholding corporate governance and accountability. This raises skepticism about realizing aspirations for engaged ownership and shareowner stewardship contained in institutional investors' engagement codes such as the Stewardship Code (2010) and contemporary policy debate in the UK and beyond.

Re-assessing the role of financial professionals in pension fund investment strategies

Risk and Portfolio Choices in Individual and Collective Pension Plans

Financial Risks and the Pension Protection Fund: Can it Survive Them?

UK pension funds' patience and liquidity in the age of market-based finance

Research on the Pension Investment and Asset Management

Active Versus Passive Investment Management Of State Pension Plans: Implications For Personal Finance

Communication and personal selection of pension saver’s financial risk

Global pension systems and their reform: Worldwide drivers, trends and challenges

Globalization Trend of Pension Fund Investment: Across Selected OECD Countries

[Health and investment: How are the 237 billion euro of the German professional pension funds invested?]

Feed the Beast: Finance Capitalism and the Spread of Pension Privatisation in Europe

Hedging longevity risk in defined contribution pension schemes

Creating French-style pension funds: Business, labour and the battle over patient capital

Engaged versus Disengaged Ownership: The Case of Pension Funds in the UK

Financial Performance Adequacy of Pension Fund Managers in Nigeria

Assessing the impact of pension institutions on the development of global finance

The Financial Industry Sets Sights on Institutional Investors: A Relational Approach to Property Investment Outsourcing

Three essays in pension finance

Pension accounting information and firm value: An analysis of FTSE 100 companies

Public Pension Fund Management: Best Practice and International Experience

Experts versus representatives? Financialised valuation and institutional change in financial governance