Optimization for Locating Emergency Medical Service Facilities: A Case Study for Health Planning from China
Yufan Deng,Yumeng Zhang,Jay Pan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/RMHP.S304475
2021-05-01
Risk Management and Healthcare Policy
Abstract:Yufan Deng, 1, 2 Yumeng Zhang, 1, 2 Jay Pan 1, 2 1 HEOA Group, West China School of Public Health and West China Fourth Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu, Sichuan, People's Republic of China; 2 Institute for Healthy Cities and West China Research Center for Rural Health Development, Sichuan University, Chengdu, Sichuan, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Jay Pan West China School of Public Health, Sichuan University, No. 17, Section 3, Ren Min Nan Road, Chengdu, 610041, Sichuan, People's Republic of China Email Purpose: Rational location of emergency medical service (EMS) facilities could improve access to EMS, and thus assist in saving patients' lives and improving their health outcomes. A considerable amount of spatial optimization research has been devoted to the development of models to support location planning in the context of EMS, with extensive applications in policy making around the world. However, in China, studies on the location of EMS facilities have not been paid enough attention to, let alone their practical applications. This paper conducted location optimization for EMS facilities in Chengdu, one of the biggest cities in southwest China with more than 16.5 million population, aiming to optimize the EMS system by adding (upgrading) a minimum number of EMS facilities to achieve a given population coverage. Methods: Location optimization was conducted according to regional health policy goal for the EMS system in Chengdu, China, 2017. The nearest-neighbor approach was used to calculate the shortest travel time based on geographical information system (GIS). The location set covering model was used to formulate the optimization problem under China's context, and genetic algorithm (GA) was employed to determine the optimized locations. Results: The results showed that a minimum number of 55 new facilities were required to upgrade to EMS facilities to achieve the policy goal of 90% population coverage of EMS within 15 minutes. Access to EMS also improved substantially in terms of shortest travel time after facility upgrading. The weighted median shortest travel time to EMS facilities in Chengdu decreased by 14.57%, from 6.45 minutes to 5.51 minutes. Conclusion: Our study showed that the solution could effectively achieve the policy goal of population coverage with a minimum number of new EMS facilities. Our findings would support evidence-based decision-making in future EMS planning in China. Keywords: emergency medical care, EMS location, genetic algorithm, location set covering problem Emergency medical service (EMS) is one of the most fundamental services in healthcare system, it is responsible for urgent pre-hospital treatment and patient transfer in the case of medical emergent events. 1 Timely and efficient provision of EMS has a significant impact on patients' health and recovery, thus plays a vital role in saving patients' lives, improving health outcomes, and reducing rate of mortality. 2–4 On this account, the improvement of EMS system has long been advocated throughout a worldwide range 5 , 6 and is recognized as an important part of health planning in most countries. 7–11 Of all the problems arising in EMS planning, locating EMS facilities has gained great attention from both local governments and academia. It has been widely concerned in the city development plan, so as to meet the safety needs of residents and facilitate the realization of health goals. Location problem, which seeks the optimal layout of facilities for a given objective, is one of the most studied area of Operations Research (OR). A considerable amount of research work has been devoted to developing models to support decision-makings in the context of facility location. Regardless of details of specific conditions and issues, typical location problems could fall into the following categories according to their optimization objectives: (i) the p- median problem; (ii) the p- center problem; (iii) the location set covering problem; and (iv) the maximum coverage location problem. 12 A thorough overview of location science can be found in the book of Laporte et al. 13 Other popular models and specific topics for location of EMS facilities were carefully reviewed in Aringhieri et al 14 and Bélanger et al. 15 Based on planning objectives, various studies have used different models to ass -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services,health policy & services