Abstract:Currently, many globally accessible forest mapping products can be utilized to monitor and assess the status of and changes in forests. However, substantial disparities exist among these products due to variations in forest definitions, classification methods, and remote sensing data sources. This becomes particularly conspicuous in regions characterized by significant deforestation, like Southeast Asia, where forest mapping uncertainty is more pronounced, presenting users with challenges in selecting appropriate datasets across diverse regions. Moreover, this situation impedes the further enhancement of accuracy for forest mapping products. The aim of this research is to assess the consistency and accuracy of six recently produced forest mapping products in Southeast Asia. These products include three 10 m land cover products (Finer Resolution Observation and Monitoring Global LC (FROM-GLC10), ESA WorldCover 10 m 2020 (ESA2020), and ESRI 2020 Land Cover (ESRI2020)) and three forest thematic mapping products (Global PALSAR-2 Forest/Non-Forest map (JAXA FNF2020), global 30 m spatial distribution of forest cover in 2020 (GFC30_2020), and Generated_Hansen2020, which was synthesized based on Hansen TreeCover2010 (Hansen2010) and Hansen Global Forest Change (Hansen GFC) for the year 2020). Firstly, the research compared the area and spatial consistency. Next, accuracy was assessed using field validation points and manual densification points. Finally, the research analyzed the geographical environmental and biophysical factors influencing consistency. The results show that ESRI2020 had the highest overall accuracy for forest, followed by ESA2020, FROM-GLC10, and Generated_Hansen2020. Regions with elevations ranging from 200 to 3000 m and slopes below 15° or above 25° showed high spatial consistency, whereas other regions showed low consistency. Inconsistent regions showed complex landscapes heavily influenced by human activities; these regions are prone to being confused with shrubs and cropland and are also impacted by rubber and oil palm plantations, significantly affecting the accuracy of forest mapping. Based on the research findings, ESRI2020 is recommended for mountainous areas and abundant forest regions. However, in areas significantly affected by human activities, such as forest and non-forest edges and mixed areas of plantations and natural forests, caution should be taken with product selection. The research has identified areas of forest inconsistency that require attention in future forest mapping. To enhance our understanding of forest mapping and generate high-precision forest cover maps, it is recommended to incorporate multi-source data, subdivide forest types, and increase the number of sample points.

Forest information at multiple scales: development, evaluation and application of the Norwegian forest resources map SR16

Large scale mapping of forest attributes using heterogeneous sets of airborne laser scanning and National Forest Inventory data

Mapping forest age using National Forest Inventory, airborne laser scanning, and Sentinel-2 data

A Two-Scale Approach for Estimating Forest Aboveground Biomass with Optical Remote Sensing Images in a Subtropical Forest of Nepal

Improved k-NN Mapping of Forest Attributes in Northern Canada Using Spaceborne L-Band SAR, Multispectral and LiDAR Data

Timber Volume Estimation Based on Airborne Laser Scanning -- Comparing the Use of National Forest Inventory and Forest Management Inventory Data

Prediction of Timber Quality Parameters of Forest Stands by Means of Small Footprint Airborne Laser Scanner Data

Prediction of butt rot volume in Norway spruce forest stands using harvester, remotely sensed and environmental data

Deriving forest monitoring variables from X-band InSAR SRTM height

Monitoring seedling stands using national forest inventory and multispectral airborne laser scanning data

Country-wide Retrieval of Forest Structure From Optical and SAR Satellite Imagery With Deep Ensembles

Comparison of four types of 3D data for timber volume estimation

A new approach for Spatializing the CAnadian National Forest Inventory (SCANFI) using Landsat dense time series

Practical large-scale forest stand inventory using a small-footprint airborne scanning laser

Enhancing the Precision of Forest Growing Stock Volume in the Estonian National Forest Inventory with Different Predictive Techniques and Remote Sensing Data

Per-Pixel Forest Attribute Mapping and Error Estimation: The Google Earth Engine and R dataDriven Tool

Towards operational remote sensing of forest carbon balance across Northern Europe

EcoDes-DK15: High-resolution ecological descriptors of vegetation and terrain derived from Denmark's national airborne laser scanning data set

Forest Height Mapping Using Feature Selection and Machine Learning by Integrating Multi-Source Satellite Data in Baoding City, North China

Mapping and Estimating Aboveground Biomass in an Alpine Treeline Ecotone under Model-Based Inference

A Comparison of Six Forest Mapping Products in Southeast Asia, Aided by Field Validation Data