Abstract:Background: Globally, policy-makers are currently grappling with both economic and non-economic measures to combat tobacco consumption. Among economic measures, advertising/sponsorship ban, alternative cropping and alternative livelihood measures are considered, in addition, to imposing heavy taxes on all tobacco products. However, the price responsiveness of major tobacco products has not been extensively studied empirically in the Indian context, especially by income status of consumers. Objective: The key objective of this study is to examine the pattern of price elasticity of major tobacco products (bidi, cigarette and leaf tobacco) by income quintiles. Methods: The study utilizes data from Consumer Expenditure Survey of households, a nationally representative data collected by the National Sample Survey Organization (NSSO) for the 66th (2009-10) round. The sample size was 100,855 households, of which 50,074 were tobacco using households. The study draws its theoretical framework a model developed by Deaton (1988, 1997) to estimate own and cross price elasticity of three types of tobacco products. The model uses the augmented utility function of consumer behavior, with a two-stage two-equations system of unit values and budget shares. The price elasticity is estimated after correcting for the effect of any measurement error in unit values and budget shares arising due to differences in quality of products. Results: Unit values were highest for both bidis and cigarettes in the richest quintile groups (Rs 0.363 and 2.52, respectively). Highest unit value for leaf tobacco was Rs. 3.27 in the second richest quintile group. Budget share regression coefficients show that an increase in household size will increase the budget share of both bidis and leaf tobacco by 0.001% for both urban and rural areas (p-value<0.001). Overall price elasticities were: bidi -0.721; cigarette -0.241; and leaf tobacco -0.55. Price elasticities for bidi was highest in the richest quintile (-0.511) and lowest in the poorer quintile (-0.247). For cigarettes, the lowest elasticity was in the middle quintile (-0.082) and highest in the richest quintile (-0.280). For leaf tobacco, highest elasticity was in the poorest quintile (-0.408) and lowest in the richer quintile (-0.178). Conclusions: Overall, rural elasticities were higher than urban, indicating that rural consumers are more price responsive. Bidis were the most price elastic of all tobacco products, suggesting that increases in bidi prices will deter bidi consumption. Leaf tobacco displayed moderate elasticity, suggesting that increases in tax may result in a tradeoff between consumption decline and government revenue. Elasticities for cigarettes were the least of all products, suggesting that cigarette smokers are more resistant to price changes. However, elasticities by quintile groups indicate high price responsiveness in the wealthier quintiles for cigarettes and bidis, suggesting that increases in prices will also affect their consumption patterns. Overall, while a broad spectrum rise in tax rates across all tobacco products are critical, simplifying tax structure and tax governance must receive utmost importance in the current policy regime against tobacco control.

Does cigarette demand respond to price increases in Uganda? Price elasticity estimates using the Uganda National Panel Survey and Deaton’s method

Price Elasticity of Demand for Cigarette Items: Evidence from South Kalimantan Province of Indonesia

Cigarette Prices and Smoking Among Youth in 16 African Countries: Evidence From the Global Youth Tobacco Survey

The price sensitivity of cigarette consumption in Bangladesh: evidence from the International Tobacco Control (ITC) Bangladesh Wave 1 (2009) and Wave 2 (2010) Surveys

Tobacco price elasticity by socioeconomic characteristics in Ecuador

A Cross-Country Study of Cigarette Affordability and Single-Stick Purchases Using Survey Data From African Countries

Price elasticity of demand of non-cigarette tobacco products: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Price and Income Elasticities of Cigarette Smoking Demand in Bangladesh: Evidence from Urban Adolescents and Young Adults

The impact of cigarette taxes and advertising on the demand for cigarettes in Ukraine

Quantity, quality, and regional price variation of cigarettes: Demand analysis based on a household survey in China

Real-world, Anti-Tobacco Environmental Impact Upon Price-Induced Smoking Reduction among Urban Chinese Men: Evidence from China's 2015 Cigarette Tax Increase.

Cigarette excise tax structure and cigarette prices in nine sub-Saharan African countries: evidence from the Global Adult Tobacco Survey

Price and income elasticity of cigarette demand in Bosnia and Herzegovina by different socioeconomic groups

Carbon pricing and household welfare: evidence from Uganda

Cigarette Prices and Smoking Experimentation among Zimbabwean children: a survival analysis of the 2014 Global Youth Tobacco Survey

Effect of price and income on the demand for sugar-sweetened beverages in Nigeria: an analysis of household consumption data using an almost ideal demand system (AIDS)

The price elasticity of heated tobacco and cigarette demand: Empirical evaluation across countries

The effects of a rise in cigarette price on cigarette consumption, tobacco taxation revenues, and of smoking-related deaths in 28 EU countries-- applying threshold regression modelling

Price Elasticity of Tobacco Products Among Quintile Groups in India, 2009-10

Male Smoking Reduction Behaviour in Response to China's 2015 Cigarette Tax Increase.

Differential responsiveness to cigarette price by education and income among adult urban Chinese smokers: findings from the ITC China Survey