Culture: The Creator and the Creation of International Investment Law

Marcin Menkes
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3344614
2016-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:A civilisation cannot exist without culture. It would sound like a truism if it wasn’t for the legal lack of acknowledgment of this fact. Although military and even economic threats justify emergency exemptions to treaty obligations, culture tends to be perceived as less important, along with environmental concerns or social responsibility. Given the significance of cultural heritage, the questions arise about the extent to which the protection of this heritage constitutes a fundamental duty of a host state and whether vague provisions are used as a veil for the mistreatment of foreign investments. By referring to a range of state intervention (normative, administrative and judicial actions) and cultural goods (tangible and intangible, already protected and aspiring to be enlisted), I analyse cases from Poland and South Africa. I try to find the equilibrium between the perception of culture as an object of international investment law, to be weighed against other considerations, and as a constituent factor crucial to a state’s identity and substance.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?