Abstract:Introduction: Encountering political disagreements in our daily lives can discourage us from participating in democratic processes. To date, research has mainly focused on social motives or attitudinal mechanisms to explain this phenomenon. In the present study, we adopt a different approach and highlight metacognitive effects of attitudinal (in)congruence on processing fluency (i.e., perceived ease of processing) and subjective knowledge as well as their relationship with behavioral outcomes such as the intention to politically participate. Methods: In a pre-registered online experiment ( N = 1,258), participants saw a political social media post with six opinionated user-generated comments. These comments either all matched (congruent condition) or contradicted (incongruent condition) participants' personal opinions. Processing fluency, issue specific subjective knowledge, and intention to politically participate were then measured using established self-report scales. Results: In line with our hypotheses, the congruent stimuli evoked a higher feeling of processing fluency than the incongruent ones ( d = 0.21). Furthermore, participants in the congruent condition indicated a higher intention to politically participate ( d = 0.23) and rated their own knowledge on the topic as higher ( d = 0.22) than participants in the incongruent condition—even though the factual knowledge gain should be equal in both conditions. Finally, we observed positive relationships between processing fluency and subjective issue knowledge (β = 0.11) as well as between subjective issue knowledge and issue-specific political participation (β = 0.43). Discussion: Our findings highlight the importance of considering metacognitive constructs such as subjective knowledge to explain political behaviors and suggest that attitudinal congruence influences the way we perceive our own knowledge and information processing.

The effect of being conflict non-avoidant: linking conflict framing and political participation

Metacognitive effects of attitudinal (in)congruence on social media: relating processing fluency, subjective knowledge, and political participation

Incidental News Exposure on Social Media: A Campaign Communication Mediation Approach

Selective exposure in different political information environments – How media fragmentation and polarization shape congruent news use

Biased processing and opinion polarization: experimental refinement of argument communication theory in the context of the energy debate

Do News Frames Really Have Some Influence in the Real World? A Computational Analysis of Cumulative Framing Effects on Emotions and Opinions about Immigration

Incidental Exposure and News Engagement: Testing Temporal Order and the Role of Political Interest

The influence of partisan news on climate mitigation support: An investigation into the mediating role of perceived risk and efficacy

The Effects of Digital Media Images on Political Participation Online: Results of an Eye‐Tracking Experiment Integrating Individual Perceptions of “Photo News Factors”

Informed participation? An investigation of the relationship between exposure to different news channels and participation mediated through actual and perceived knowledge

Age and the effects of news media attention and social media use on political interest and participation: Do social media function as leveller?

Whose media are hostile? The spillover effect of interpersonal discussions on media bias perceptions

Algorithmic social media use and its relationship to attitude reinforcement and issue-specific political participation – The case of the 2015 European immigration movements

Beyond partisan filters: Can underreported news reduce issue polarization?

The Influence of Political Fit, Issue Fit, and Targeted Political Advertising Disclosures on Persuasion Knowledge, Party Evaluation, and Chilling Effects

A Longitudinal Test of Political Self-Effects on Social Media

Social viewing of news and political participation: The mediating roles of information acquisition, self-expression, and partisan identity

Disentangling the Echo Chamber: How Exposure to Congruent and Incongruent Opinion Climates on Social Networking Sites Impacts Users’ Processing and Selection of Information

The contingent reputational benefits of selective exposure to partisan information.

Media Frame and Audience Cognitive Bias: Assessing News Effectiveness from a Social Psychological Perspective

I Saw You in the News: Mediated and Direct Intergroup Contact Improve Outgroup Attitudes