Abstract:Recent studies suggest that practice with approximate and non-symbolic arithmetic problems improves the math performance of adults, school aged children, and preschoolers. However, the relative effectiveness of approximate arithmetic training compared to available educational games, and the type of math skills that approximate arithmetic targets are unknown. The present study was designed to (1) compare the effectiveness of approximate arithmetic training to two commercially available numeral and letter identification tablet applications and (2) to examine the specific type of math skills that benefit from approximate arithmetic training. Preschool children (<i>n</i> = 158) were pseudo-randomly assigned to one of three conditions: approximate arithmetic, letter identification, or numeral identification. All children were trained for 10 short sessions and given pre and post tests of informal and formal math, executive function, short term memory, vocabulary, alphabet knowledge, and number word knowledge. We found a significant interaction between initial math performance and training condition, such that children with low pretest math performance benefited from approximate arithmetic training, and children with high pretest math performance benefited from symbol identification training. This effect was restricted to informal, and not formal, math problems. There were also effects of gender, socio-economic status, and age on post-test informal math score after intervention. A median split on pretest math ability indicated that children in the low half of math scores in the approximate arithmetic training condition performed significantly better than children in the letter identification training condition on post-test informal math problems when controlling for pretest, age, gender, and socio-economic status. Our results support the conclusion that approximate arithmetic training may be especially effective for children with low math skills, and that approximate arithmetic training improves early informal, but not formal, math skills.

Benefits of Playing Numerical Card Games on Head Start Children’s Mathematical Skills

No evidence that playing a linear number board game improves numerical skills beyond teaching as usual: A randomized controlled trial in 4- to 5-year-old primary school children.

Racing dragons and remembering aliens: Benefits of playing number and working memory games on kindergartners' numerical knowledge

Numerical Processing Efficiency Improved in Children Using Mental Abacus: ERP Evidence Utilizing a Numerical Stroop Task

Effectiveness of Parent–Child Number Board Game Playing in Promoting Chinese Kindergarteners’ Numeracy Skills and Mathematics Interest

Play-integrated fostering of basic mathematical skills: findings of two experiments

Longitudinally adaptive assessment and instruction increase numerical skills of preschool children

Numerical Magnitude Processing in Abacus-Trained Children with Superior Mathematical Ability: an Eeg Study

Numerical Processing Efficiency Improved in Experienced Mental Abacus Children.

Why numerical symbols count in the development of mathematical skills: evidence from brain and behavior

Promoting Effects of RtI-Based Mathematical Play Training on Number Sense Growth among Low-SES Preschool Children

Digital games for learning basic arithmetic at home

Factors Influencing Children's Numerical Development:Surface Similarity Effect and Shared Labels Effect

Early symbolic numeracy and gross, fine, and perceptual-motor skills in Mexican preschool children

Approximate Arithmetic Training Improves Informal Math Performance in Low Achieving Preschoolers

Intervention effects on low performing preschoolers' early mathematical skills: Adding fundamental motor skill practice as a supporting method

Chinese Preschool Children's Home Numeracy Experiences and Their Mathematical Abilities

Relations between preschoolers' mathematical language understanding and specific numeracy skills

Symbolic Magnitude Understanding Predicts Preschoolers’ Later Addition Skills

Improving Children’s Knowledge of Fraction Magnitudes

The roles of mathematical language and emergent literacy skills in the longitudinal prediction of specific early numeracy skills