Tissue-specific DNA methylation in a cluster of rabbit (-like globin genes ( gene mapping / molecular cloning / gene expression )
Che-Kun James Shen,T. Maniatis
Abstract:The relationship between DNA methylation and differential expression of rabbit a-like globin genes was studied by using restriction enzymes that cleave the sequence C-C-G-G but are differentially inhibited by the presence of 5methylcytosine. The methylation frequency of 13 -C-G sites that flank a set of four closely linked rabbit a-like globin genes was determined. This analysis revealed that certain sites surrounding embryonic and adult globin genes are relatively undermethylated in DNA from embryonic and adult erythroid tissues, respectively. This pattern is most pronounced for three sites that are undermethylated in erythroid cells but are totally methylated in nonerythroid cells. We conclude that the degree of CpG methylation in the rabbit a-like globin gene cluster is correlated with gene activity, but the effect is confined to relatively small regions of DNA. The genomes of most eukaryotes contain only one major modified base, 5-methylcytosine. In mammalian DNA, this modified base constitutes 2-7% of the total cytosine and is found mainly within the dinucleotide sequence CpG (1, 2). Although the biological function of cytosine methylation has not been established, a number of investigators have proposed that it plays a regulatory role in differential gene expression (3-6). The distribution of 5-methylcytosine near specific eukaryotic genes has been studied by using restriction enzymes that recognize CpG-containing sequences (7-12). In general, undermethylation is associated with gene activity, but a causal relationship between undermethylation and gene expression has yet to be demonstrated. The restriction enzyme assay is based primarily on the use of enzymes Hpa II (13) and Msp I (14-16), both of which recognize and cut the unmodified C-C-G-G sequence. If, however, the internal C is methylated, the sequence is resistant to Hpa II but not Msp I cleavage (14-17). Thus, parallel digestion of a DNA sample with Hpa II or Msp I makes it possible to differentiate between DNA modification and restriction site polymorphism. We have used this assay to analyze the differential methylation of C-C-G-G sequences within a cluster of rabbit $-like globin genes, using DNA obtained from different rabbit tissues. The rabbit f-like globin genes provide an interesting system for studying the relationship between DNA methylation and gene activity because these genes are coordinately and sequentially expressed during development. Two types of embryonic f-like globin polypeptides, E(y) and e(z), have been detected in the nucleated erythroid cells derived from the yolk sac blood islands of the embryos (18-20). Starting at about 12 days of gestation, these two e chains are gradually replaced by the adult fi-globin chain, and the fetal liver becomes the primary center for erythropoiesis. In the adult, the bone marrow and spleen are the major erythropoietic sites and only the adult fi-globin polypeptide is synthesized. The rabbit f-like globin gene cluster has been cloned in a set of overlapping bacteriophage recombinants (21, 22). The cluster contains four genes, which have been designated fl1 through fl4. The genes f3 and fl4 are transcribed in embryonic but not in adult erythroid cells and presumably encode the e(y) and E(z) chains. f1, which encodes the adult fi-globin polypeptide, is transcribed primarily in adult erythroid cells (Fig. 1). A small amount of the f1 transcript is also detected in embryonic erythroid cells. The fl2 gene does not appear to be transcribed in any erythroid tissues (22). Nucleotide sequence analysis indicated that this gene cannot encode a functional globin polypeptide and is a fi-globin pseudogene (unpublished data). As shown in Fig. 1, all of the genes are transcribed from the same DNA strand and they are arranged on the chromosome in the order of their expression during development. The same relationship between gene order and developmental expression has been observed in several other mammalian globin gene clusters (see ref. 23 for review). Although tissue-specific methylation patterns of several individual eukaryotic genes have been reported (7-12), the well-characterized rabbit f-like globin gene cluster provides an opportunity to study the methylation pattern of large regions of chromosomal DNA that contain coordinately as well as sequentially expressed genes. In this paper, we report the results of experiments which indicate that certain C-C-G-G sites surrounding embryonic and adult f-globin genes are relatively undermethylated in the DNA from erythroid tissues, whereas the same sites are methylated to a greater extent in nonerythroid tissues. However, we do not find a uniform pattern of DNA methylation over large regions of the gene cluster. MATERIALS AND METHODS DNA Preparation. Rabbit DNA was purified from different tissues by using published procedures (24). DNA from bone marrow and blood islands was isolated from a single female New Zealand White rabbit (rabbit I). This bone marrow DNA will be referred to as bone marrow I DNA. DNA of the bone marrow, kidney, liver, and spleen of a second rabbit (rabbit II) was kindly provided by V. Parker. The bone marrow DNA of this rabbit is designated as bone marrow II DNA. The brain DNA of a third rabbit was a gift from A. Efstratiadis. Hybridization Probes. The subclones containing mainly the large introns of the four rabbit globin genes were provided by R. Hardison (fl4, f3), E. Lacy (f2), and C. O'Connell (flu). The intron fragments were purified by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and labeled with 32P by nick translation (25). Blot Hybridization. Genomic rabbit DNA was digested to completion with Hpa II or Msp I, alone or in combination with other enzymes (New England BioLabs, Beverly, MA, and BeAbbreviation: kb, kilobase. 6634 The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U. S. C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 77 (1980) 6635