Abstract:As water scarcity becomes more acute in many parts of the world, crop modeling tools that effectively simulating crop response to deficit irrigation strategies to help investigate management improvement are needed. Identifying the strengths and weaknesses of the crop models with different growth-engines are therefore of great importance. The objective of this study was to investigate the capability and improvements of the new version of a solar energy-driven crop model (DSSAT-CERES-Maize, v4.7.5.0) in simulating water consumption and yield of hybrid seed maize under different soil water conditions, and its comparison with a water-driven crop model (AquaCrop, v4.0). Data obtained from a 4-year (2012–2015) field trial on maize grown under different irrigation treatments at Wuwei, Northwest China, was used for this assessment. These models were calibrated and validated using measured daily evapotranspiration (ET), leaf area index (LAI), aboveground biomass, yield (Y), harvest index (HI) and soil water content (SWC). Daily ET was measured using a combination of an eddy covariance (EC) system, sap flow sensors, and micro-lysimeter cylinders. The ability of DSSAT-CERES-Maize using the two different ET options, i.e., Priestley-Taylor/Ritchie (PT) and FAO-56 Penman-Monteith (PM) was analyzed. The results showed that DSSAT-CERES-Maize with the PT approach had fair agreement with measured daily ET of maize under non-water stress condition (R2=0.85; NRMSE=26.7%), but poor agreement with ET under water stress conditions (R2=0.51; NRMSE=43.8%). DSSAT-CERES-Maize with the PM approach systematically underestimated ET by up to 13% under non-water stress condition, which was mainly attributed to that the maximum static CERES-Maize crop coefficient (EORATIO) was currently hard coded to 1.0. Using the PT or FAO-56 PM approach as ET input in DSSAT-CERES-Maize showed no different effect on final biomass (B) and Y simulation for full irrigation. But for water stress conditions, DSSAT-CERES-Maize with the FAO-56 PM approach simulated B and Y with higher overestimation to the measured data than those simulated using the PT approach. The simulated LAI, biomass and SWC by DSSAT-CERES-Maize using the PT approach generally well followed the trend of the measured values for most irrigation treatments. The model with the PT approach showed acceptable prediction for B and Y of different irrigation treatments across years, with NRMSE of 15.5% and 26.2%, respectively, but the accuracy decreased with an aggravation of water stress. Furthermore, the strengths and weaknesses of DSSAT-CERES-Maize and AquaCrop, and their different cores of growth-engines, i.e. RUE and normalized water productivity (WP*) were carefully discussed. It was concluded that DSSAT-CERES-Maize was a superior estimate of maize yield than was AquaCrop, especially when the climate varied dramatically between years. But DSSAT-CERES-Maize, for the simulation of maize water consumption in an arid region where drought often occurs, was inferior to AquaCrop. These results contribute to recommend the appropriate crop model for specific modeling goals.

Parameter Estimation and Verification of the DSSATModel of Winter Wheat for Simulation and Development in North China

Development and verification of soil water balance and crop growth simulation model

Validation of the Effect of DSSAT Model on Winter Wheat under Conservation Tillage Treatments in West Henan

Simulation of Water Cycling in Wheat-maize Field in North China

Assessment of the AquaCrop Model for Use in Simulation of Irrigated Winter Wheat Canopy Cover, Biomass, and Grain Yield in the North China Plain

Winter Wheat Drought Monitoring with Multi-temporal MODIS data and AquaCrop Model—A Case Study in Henan Province

Model validation and crop coefficients for irrigation scheduling in the North China plain

Calibration and Validation of SiBcrop Model for Simulating LAI and Surface Heat Fluxes of Winter Wheat in the North China Plain

Simulation of Water Dynamics and Irrigation Scheduling for Winter Wheat and Maize in Seasonal Frost Areas

Modeling Soil Water Content and Crop-Growth Metrics in a Wheat Field in the North China Plain Using RZWQM2

Evaluation Of Drought Monitoring Effect Of Winter Wheat In Henan Province Of China Based On Multi-Source Data

Prediction of crop yield, water consumption and water use efficiency with a SVAT-crop growth model using remotely sensed data on the North China Plain

Estimating evapotranspiration and yield of wheat and maize croplands through a remote sensing-based model

Application of DSSAT crop model on prediction of potential yield of spring wheat in Ningxia

Capability of a solar energy-driven crop model for simulating water consumption and yield of maize and its comparison with a water-driven crop model

Estimation of Winter Wheat Production Potential Based on Remotely-Sensed Imagery and Process-Based Model Simulations

Simulation of Evapotranspiration and Carbon Dioxide Flux in the Wheat-Maize Rotation Croplands of the North China Plain Using the Simple Biosphere Model

Retrieving crop physiological parameters and assessing water deficiency using MODIS data during the winter wheat growing period

Integrating a Novel Irrigation Approximation Method with a Process-Based Remote Sensing Model to Estimate Multi-Years' Winter Wheat Yield over the North China Plain

Assessing the Remotely Sensed Drought Severity Index for Agricultural Drought Monitoring and Impact Analysis in North China

An Assessment of Irrigation Practices: Sprinkler Irrigation of Winter Wheat in the North China Plain