Science education textbook research trends: a systematic literature review

Karel Vojíř,Martin Rusek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2019.1613584

IF: 2.3

2019-05-23

International Journal of Science Education

Abstract:The number of science education research papers has been rapidly rising in recent years. This number has been particularly influenced by researchers from non-English speaking countries who contribute to the field. With this number of papers, literature reviews gain in importance as they help researchers more easily orient themselves in problem areas. The authors of this study present a literature review on science textbook research. The importance of textbooks in education is indisputable, yet research in this field is surprisingly unbalanced between particular regions or states. In this paper, a review of 183 papers published between 2000 and 2018, indexed to the Web of Science database, is introduced. The results show that researchers in Europe and the USA focus on textbook research more than researchers elsewhere in the world. The textbooks most frequently researched on are science books for secondary schools. Textbook research consists mostly of analysing learning concepts and how concepts are integrated, non-textual elements in textbooks, visual representations, learning content or learning text analysis.

education & educational research

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are the trend and current situation analysis of scientific education textbook research. Specifically, through the method of systematic literature review, the author analyzed 183 relevant papers published in the Web of Science database between 2000 and 2018, aiming to answer the following research questions:

1. **What are the regions and specific locations of the textbooks analyzed?**
- The paper explored the distribution of scientific textbook research in different countries and regions and found that the research in Europe and North America was the most concentrated, accounting for 69% of the proportion.

2. **Who are the key contributors in this field?**
- By analyzing the publication records of authors, some highly productive researchers were identified, such as M. Niaz (Venezuela) and N. M. Gericke (Sweden), who have published several influential papers in this field.

3. **Which journals most frequently publish papers on scientific textbook research?**
- The research results show that journals such as the International Journal of Science Education and Chemistry Education Research and Practice are the main publishing platforms.

4. **Which papers are the most cited?**
- Through citation analysis, several papers with important influence in this field were identified. For example, the paper by Biber, Conrad, and Cortes (2004) has the highest number of citations, reaching 304 times.

5. **Which educational level are the most analyzed textbooks aimed at?**
- Most of the research focused on secondary school textbooks, accounting for 58%, followed by higher education textbooks (26%) and primary school textbooks (12%).

6. **Which topics are the most and least studied?**
- The research content mainly focuses on the content of textbooks (20%), learning concepts and their integration (19%), and non - text learning content interpretation (18%). Other less - studied topics include student learning and elements guiding their learning (8%), text (6%), historical development of textbooks (5%), etc.

Through the answers to these questions, the paper aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the field of scientific textbook research and help researchers better understand the research trends and development trends in this field.