Abstract:Electrochemical nitrogen reduction to ammonia has recently gathered enormous interest as an attractive carbon-neutral alternative to the Haber-Bosch process. However, this novel process severely suffers from poor reproducibility and reliability. As reported recently in Nature, Chorkendorff and colleagues implemented a systematic benchmarking protocol to eliminate the false and retain the true in nitrogen electroreduction research. Electrochemical nitrogen reduction to ammonia has recently gathered enormous interest as an attractive carbon-neutral alternative to the Haber-Bosch process. However, this novel process severely suffers from poor reproducibility and reliability. As reported recently in Nature, Chorkendorff and colleagues implemented a systematic benchmarking protocol to eliminate the false and retain the true in nitrogen electroreduction research. Ammonia, the second highest produced chemical in the world (170 Mt year–1), is the vital ingredient in most fertilizers used to sustain the ever-growing global population and is also being considered for use in renewable energy storage as an energy-dense carbon-neutral liquid fuel. Today, the preeminent Haber-Bosch process contributes 90% of annual ammonia production. However, this century-old process requires massive energy input and capital cost and creates significant CO2 emissions.1Chen J.G. Crooks R.M. Seefeldt L.C. Bren K.L. Bullock R.M. Darensbourg M.Y. Holland P.L. Hoffman B. Janik M.J. Jones A.K. et al.Beyond fossil fuel-driven nitrogen transformations.Science. 2018; 360: eaar6611Crossref PubMed Scopus (896) Google Scholar Recently, the electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) using renewable electricity under ambient conditions was proposed in principle as a perfect alternative to the Haber-Bosch process.2Soloveichik G. Electrochemical synthesis of ammonia as a potential alternative to the Haber-Bosch process.Nat. Catal. 2019; 2: 377-380Crossref Scopus (253) Google Scholar Ideally, this would make ammonia production less dependent on fossil fuels and decentralized for on-site and on-demand production.2Soloveichik G. Electrochemical synthesis of ammonia as a potential alternative to the Haber-Bosch process.Nat. Catal. 2019; 2: 377-380Crossref Scopus (253) Google Scholar, 3Wang L. Xia M. Wang H. Huang K. Qian C. Maravelias C.T. Ozin G.A. Greening ammonia toward the solar ammonia refinery.Joule. 2018; 2: 1055-1074Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (420) Google Scholar To date, various electrocatalysts and strategies to enhance electrochemical NRR activity and selectivity have been reported. However, significant doubt and discussion has arisen as to whether these results should be ascribed to actual N2 electroreduction or false positives.4MacLaughlin C. Role for standardization in electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis: A conversation with Leo Liu, Lauren Greenlee, and Douglas MacFarlane.ACS Energy Lett. 2019; 4: 1432-1436Crossref Scopus (19) Google Scholar Although many artifact sources have been recognized and a series of control experiments have been established since 2018,5Greenlee L.F. Renner J.N. Foster S.L. The use of controls for consistent and accurate measurements of electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis from dinitrogen.ACS Catal. 2018; 8: 7820-7827Crossref Scopus (197) Google Scholar, 6Chen G.-F. Ren S. Zhang L. Cheng H. Luo Y. Zhu K. Ding L.-X. Wang H. Advances in electrocatalytic N2 reduction—Strategies to tackle the selectivity challenge.Small Methods. 2018; 2: 1800337Google Scholar, 7Suryanto B.H.R. Du H.-L. Wang D. Chen J. Simonov A.N. MacFarlane D.R. Challenges and prospects in the catalysis of electroreduction of nitrogen to ammonia.Nat. Catal. 2019; 2: 290-296Crossref Scopus (716) Google Scholar, 8Tang C. Qiao S.-Z. How to explore ambient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reliably and insightfully.Chem. Soc. Rev. 2019; 48: 3166-3180Crossref PubMed Google Scholar the reliability, accuracy, and reproducibility of recent literature still requires improvement. Therefore, a benchmarking protocol for electrochemical NRR research regarding contamination elimination, control experiments, and data reporting is urgently needed. In a landmark study recently published in Nature, Chorkendorff and colleagues highlighted this “true or false” issue in the electrochemical NRR research community.9Andersen S.Z. Čolić V. Yang S. Schwalbe J.A. Nielander A.C. McEnaney J.M. Enemark-Rasmussen K. Baker J.G. Singh A.R. Rohr B.A. et al.A rigorous electrochemical ammonia synthesis protocol with quantitative isotope measurements.Nature. 2019; 570: 504-508Crossref PubMed Scopus (719) Google Scholar They put forward a rigorous protocol to correctly quantify N2 electroreduction activity and re-evaluated several catalysts and processes, revealing both the feasibility and challenges of electrochemical NRR. Thorough identification and efficient elimination of all potential contaminant sources is the prerequisite to design and conduct meaningful NRR experiments. In addition to some gradually recognized contaminant sources, the authors especially emphasize artifacts originating from ion-conducting membranes and feed gas streams. Nafion membranes have been shown to allow significant accumulation, release, and crossover of ammonia, resulting in false negatives or positives. Alternatively, a microporous polypropylene membrane, Celgard 3401, was recommended for all aqueous experiments without the requirement of a cleaning procedure. However, commercial Celgard membranes are highly hydrophobic and designed for lithium batteries and thus require specific hydrophilic treatment while maintaining mechanical flexibility for aqueous NRR. High-purity N2 gas or even isotope-labeled 15N2 gas usually contains a tiny amount of impurities in the form of NH3 or NOx. The former contamination can be rationally excluded using control experiments with N2 at open-circuit potential (OCP), while the latter cannot be independently probed because NOx can readily be reduced electrochemically to NH3. The feed gas was thus suggested to be dealt with by first passing over an appropriate adsorbent, such as a Cu impurity trap composed of Cu-Zn-Al oxide catalysts, or a commercial gas purifier (MicroTorr MC1-902F, SAES Pure Gas). To definitely detect and quantify the electroreduction of N2 to NH3, the proposed experimental protocol is composed of a standardized set of control experiments and quantitative isotope measurements with 15N2 gas. The control measurements with Ar under the exact same conditions and with N2 at OCP are important to probe contamination within the cell, catalyst, and feed gas. The isotope-labeled experiments quantitatively detected by 1H-NMR is required to confirm that the detected ammonia is unequivocally derived from N2 electroreduction. Given the low conversion rate and high cost of 15N2 gas, the authors designed a gas circulation setup for isotope measurements where 15N2 gas was continuously cycled, scrubbed, and re-supplied to the electrode surface. It is highly creditable that the authors reported a detailed explanation of the NMR experiments and gas circulation setup for new researchers to follow. Repeated experiments to establish reproducible results with error bars and actual concentrations of detected ammonia in all measurements are required to be reported for a meaningful comparison with other works. Following this protocol, the authors tested the most promising pure metal catalysts (Ru, Re, and Rh) in aqueous media and re-evaluated several of the more promising processes and catalysts reported so far but have only been able to successfully confirm electrochemical ammonia synthesis using lithium electrodeposition in tetrahydrofuran (Figure 1). It reveals that electrochemical ammonia synthesis is indeed feasible, while most of the previously reported results are required to be rigorously re-evaluated. It is noteworthy that the pure metal catalysts were tested at potentials more negative than –1 V versus RHE in this work, where hydrogen adsorption likely dominates both thermodynamically and kinetically at the active sites and the NRR is thus highly restrained.10Singh A.R. Rohr B.A. Schwalbe J.A. Cargnello M. Chan K. Jaramillo T.F. Chorkendorff I. Nørskov J.K. Electrochemical ammonia synthesis—The selectivity challenge.ACS Catal. 2017; 7: 706-709Crossref Scopus (526) Google Scholar Measurements at smaller overpotentials are necessary before any definite conclusions for general conditions are reached. Besides, the lithium-mediated strategy is substantially distinct from routine electrochemical NRR in that the extremely strong triple bond is spontaneously split by lithium to form Li3N rather than electrochemically dissociated into NxHy intermediates. Electrochemical NRR is a fascinating field with high expectations. Although the re-evaluation studies in this work highlight the questionable reliability and reproducibility of previous literature, the proposed rigorous protocol is anticipated to enable a more meaningful and effective exploration of electrochemical NRR. Data reproducibility and accuracy should always come first to enable long-term development, and studies are enthusiastically welcome to further clarify possible artifacts and perfect the rigorous protocols.4MacLaughlin C. Role for standardization in electrocatalytic ammonia synthesis: A conversation with Leo Liu, Lauren Greenlee, and Douglas MacFarlane.ACS Energy Lett. 2019; 4: 1432-1436Crossref Scopus (19) Google Scholar, 8Tang C. Qiao S.-Z. How to explore ambient electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reliably and insightfully.Chem. Soc. Rev. 2019; 48: 3166-3180Crossref PubMed Google Scholar Given the massive effort required for the proposed protocols above, it may be highly expected and reasonable to develop a more accessible and also persuasive approach for the efficient screening of potential catalysts. On the basis of rigorous and reproducible experiments, continued advancements in both electrocatalysts and methodology will thus be more reliable, meaningful, and insightful, which will ultimately contribute to green ammonia production and sustainable society.

A rigorous electrochemical ammonia synthesis protocol with quantitative isotope measurements

Accelerating the development of electrocatalysts for electrochemical nitrogen fixation through theoretical and computational approaches

Enhancement of Lithium-Mediated Ammonia Synthesis By Addition of Oxygen

(Invited) Electrochemical Nitrogen Fixation under Ambient Conditions

True or False in Electrochemical Nitrogen Reduction

Electrosynthesis of ammonia with high selectivity and high rates via engineering of the solid-electrolyte interphase

Calcium-mediated nitrogen reduction for electrochemical ammonia synthesis

Ambient Electro-Synthesis of Ammonia - Electrode Porosity and Composition Engineering

Ambient Electrosynthesis of Ammonia: Electrode Porosity and Composition Engineering

Continuous-flow electrosynthesis of ammonia by nitrogen reduction and hydrogen oxidation

(Digital Presentation) Where Are We in Terms of Energy Efficiency to Produce Green Ammonia – Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia Compared to Haber-Bosch Process

Benchmarking Heterogeneous Photocatalysts for the Nitrogen Reduction Reaction

Electrochemical ammonia synthesis via nitrate reduction on Fe single atom catalyst

Recent Advances in Electrocatalytic Nitrogen Reduction to Produce Ammonia Under Ambient Conditions

Homogeneous, Heterogeneous and Biological Catalysts for Electrochemical N2 Reduction towards NH3 under Ambient Conditions

Atomic Modulation, Structural Design, and Systematic Optimization for Efficient Electrochemical Nitrogen Reduction

(Invited) Electrocatalytic Synthesis of Ammonia and Urea

Boosting electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction to ammonia in alkaline media

Recent Advances in Designing Catalysts and Reaction Systems for Electrochemical Synthesis of Ammonia

Homogeneous, Heterogeneous, and Biological Catalysts for Electrochemical N2 Reduction Toward NH3 under Ambient Conditions

Iron Based Catalysts for Nitrogen Reduction Reaction