Abstract:There has been intensive research from academics and practitioners regarding models for predicting bankruptcy and default events, for credit risk management. Seminal academic research has evaluated bankruptcy using traditional statistics techniques (e.g. discriminant analysis and logistic regression) and early artificial intelligence models (e.g. artificial neural networks). In this study, we test machine learning models (support vector machines, bagging, boosting, and random forest) to predict bankruptcy one year prior to the event, and compare their performance with results from discriminant analysis, logistic regression, and neural networks. We use data from 1985 to 2013 on North American firms, integrating information from the Salomon Center database and Compustat, analysing more than 10,000 firm-year observations. The key insight of the study is a substantial improvement in prediction accuracy using machine learning techniques especially when, in addition to the original Altman’s Z-score variables, we include six complementary financial indicators. Based on Carton and Hofer (2006), we use new variables, such as the operating margin, change in return-on-equity, change in price-to-book, and growth measures related to assets, sales, and number of employees, as predictive variables. Machine learning models show, on average, approximately 10% more accuracy in relation to traditional models. Comparing the best models, with all predictive variables, the machine learning technique related to random forest led to 87% accuracy, whereas logistic regression and linear discriminant analysis led to 69% and 50% accuracy, respectively, in the testing sample. We find that bagging, boosting, and random forest models outperform the others techniques, and that all prediction accuracy in the testing sample improves when the additional variables are included. Our research adds to the discussion of the continuing debate about superiority of computational methods over statistical techniques such as in Tsai, Hsu, and Yen (2014) and Yeh, Chi, and Lin (2014). In particular, for machine learning mechanisms, we do not find SVM to lead to higher accuracy rates than other models. This result contradicts outcomes from Danenas and Garsva (2015) and Cleofas-Sanchez, Garcia, Marques, and Senchez (2016), but corroborates, for instance, Wang, Ma, and Yang (2014), Liang, Lu, Tsai, and Shih (2016), and Cano et al. (2017). Our study supports the applicability of the expert systems by practitioners as in Heo and Yang (2014), Kim, Kang, and Kim (2015) and Xiao, Xiao, and Wang (2016).

Effects of main bank switching on new business bankruptcy

Main bank relationships and risk taking in Japanese listed firms

Bankruptcy Litigation and Relationship Banking

Accounting Frauds and Main-Bank Monitoring in Japanese Corporations

Main bank impairment and corporate cash holdings during the global financial crisis

The unexpected consequences of company bankruptcy: An investigation into the spillover effect of local economic liquidation

Outside or inside the firm? The impact of debt financing on the exit routes of start-up firms

A comparison of Bayesian, Hazard, and Mixed Logit model of bankruptcy prediction

On the Costs of a Bank-Centered Financial System: Evidence from the Changing Main Bank Relations in Japan

The profitability of banks in Japan

The Cost of Involuntary Relationship Destruction

Forced Bank Relationship Loss: Accounting Information Opacity and Loan Conditions

Bank Business Model Migrations in Europe: Determinants and Effects

The decline of bank ownership and firm's capital structure: evidence from Japanese business groups

Fresh Start Policies and Small Business Activity: Evidence From a Natural Experiment

The effects of business models on bank risk before, during and after financial crisis: evidence from China

Bank Credit to SMEs in Japan: Evidence from Normal Times, the Global Financial Crisis, and the COVID-19 Crisis

Impacts of crisis on SME bankruptcy prediction models' performance

Do forecasts of bankruptcy cause bankruptcy? A machine learning sensitivity analysis

Machine learning models and bankruptcy prediction

Bankruptcy judicial reform and corporate trade credit financing