Abstract:Purpose More companies embrace flexible work arrangements (FWA) as one of their employee retention strategies, yet its effectiveness is not consistent. Generally, past researchers use the social exchange theory to explain how FWA lowers turnover intention, while the rest adopts the border theory to justify why FWA can be ineffective. Here, the authors compare the competing theories for the first time to differentiate the theoretical reasoning of three forms of FWA (flex time, flex leave and homeworking). Two mediators (organisational commitment and work−family conflicts) are chosen to represent the mechanism of each theory. Design/methodology/approach The authors employ the latest wave of the International Social Survey Program (ISSP) Work Orientation Module from 2015. Based on nationally representative data from 35 nations and 17,604 participants, the authors employed simple mediation and parallel double-mediation models via bootstrapping procedures to investigate the theoretical reasoning behind each FWA. Findings The results indicate that organisational commitment and work−family conflicts as significant mediators in all models, supporting both theories. The authors first tested each mediator in separated models. In models concerning the social exchange theory, all FWA lead to increased organisational commitment before lowering turnover intention, implying the beneficial outcomes of FWA. However, findings also support the border theory's perspective where flex time and homeworking increase turnover intention through heightened work−family conflicts. The parallel double-mediation further suggests that all three FWA forms have their unique theoretical framework, impacting turnover intention differently. Originality/value Both the social exchange theory and border theory are well-developed theories but grounded on different theoretical reasoning. This is the first paper that compares both theoretical perspectives in the context of FWA. It offers a new perspective in explaining the inconclusive effectiveness of FWA and provides future researchers a more integrated interpretation and prediction of FWA's impact on turnover intention.

The effects of flexible work practices on employee attitudes: evidence from a large-scale panel study in Germany

Flexible work practices and organizational attractiveness in Germany: The mediating role of anticipated organizational support

Effects of a flexible work-time design on employee- and company-related aims

Do Work–Life Measures Really Matter? The Impact of Flexible Working Hours and Home-Based Teleworking in Preventing Voluntary Employee Exits

The role of health in flexible working arrangements in Germany

Flexible men and Successful Women: The Effects of Flexible Working Hours on German Couples’ Wages

Diversity of flexible working time arrangements and workers' health: An analysis of a workers' panel and linked employer-employee data for France

Effect of Flexible Work Arrangements on Turnover Intention: Does Job Independence Matter?

Flexible working and well-being: evidence from the UK

For better or worse: How more flexibility in working time arrangements and parental leave experiences affect fathers' working and childcare hours in Germany

Flexibility for equality: Examining the impact of flexible working time arrangements on women's convergence in working hours

Behind the times? Associations of working-time autonomy with health-related and occupational outcomes in health care personnel– a latent profile analysis

Does flexible work arrangements decrease or increase turnover intention? A comparison between the social exchange theory and border theory

Transitions to parenthood, flexible working and time-based work-to-family conflicts: A gendered life course and organisational change perspective

Flexible work arrangements in open workspaces and relations to occupational stress, need for recovery and psychological detachment from work

Different contexts, different effects? Work time and mental health in the United States and Germany

Healthy and Happy Working from Home? Effects of Working from Home on Employee Health and Job Satisfaction

Flexible work arrangements and employee health: A meta-analytic review

Organizational leisure benefits – a resource to facilitate employees’ work-life balance?

Lessons from family firms: the use of flexible work arrangements and its consequences

On the Effect of Employer Offered Leave of Work on Participation in Continuing Vocational Education and Training – Investigating the Intention-Behavior Relation