The Impact of Harsh Parental Discipline and Emotional Warmth on Adolescent Problem Behaviors
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s466830
IF: 3.974
2024-06-07
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Ludan Zhang, 1 Ruijie Wang, 2 Liang Chen 2 1 Development and Planning Department, Weifang University of Science and Technology, Weifang, People's Republic of China; 2 School of Psychology, Shandong Normal University, Jinan, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Liang Chen, School of Psychology, Shandong Normal University, No. 88, East Wenhua Road, Jinan, Shandong, 250014, People's Republic of China, Email Purpose: This study, grounded in Social Information Processing Theory, integrates emotional warmth and harsh discipline into a unified model to investigate their differential effects on adolescents' internalized and externalized problem behaviors, as well as to explore the potential divergences in the mediating role of inhibitory control. Patients and Methods: Four hundred and twenty-eight adolescents completed validated scales of Egna Minnen av Barndoms Uppfostran (EMBU), Inhibitory Control and The Youth Self-Report (YSR), Data analysis was performed using SPSS 26.0 and Mplus7.4 to examine the relationship between harsh parental discipline, emotional warmth, adolescent inhibitory control, and internalized and externalized problem behaviors and the mediating effects. Results: The present study revealed that (1) Harsh parental discipline negatively predicted both internalized and externalized problems in adolescents, while emotional warmth from fathers positively predicted internalized problem behaviors; (2) Inhibitory control acted as a mediator in the impact of harsh parental discipline on problem behaviors, while the mediating effect between paternal emotional warmth and internalization issues was not significant. Conclusion: The impact of emotional warmth and harsh discipline on adolescent internalized and externalized problems varied. In families practicing a mixed parenting style, harsh discipline had a more significant effect on adolescents, primarily mediated through inhibitory control. Keywords: harsh discipline, emotional warmth, inhibitory control, problem behaviors, adolescents Problem behaviors are critical indicators of adolescents' social adaptation and are generally classified into internalized and externalized problem behaviors. 1 Internalized problem behaviors refer to negative emotions experienced by individuals, such as depression and anxiety, while externalized problem behaviors mainly involve conduct-related actions, including aggression, disciplinary violations, and so forth. 2 These behaviors are closely related to individual growth, family happiness, and social stability. Existing research indicates a high prevalence of both internalized and externalized problem behaviors among adolescents. 3 A meta-analysis on Chinese students revealed that depression (28.0%) and anxiety (26.3%) are the primary internalized issues affecting high school students' mental health. 4 Similarly, recent studies show a significant prevalence of externalized problem behaviors in adolescence, with rates as high as 35.1%. 5 Therefore, exploring the influencing factors and mechanisms of adolescent problem behaviors is of great significance. 6,7 Parenting styles refer to the relatively stable emotional atmosphere and behavioral modes exhibited by parents during child-rearing. 8 Both emotional warmth and harsh discipline are widely recognized in the East and West as significant parenting styles influencing individual development. 9,10 Emotional warmth is characterized by supportive and caring responses from parents to fulfill children's emotional needs, whereas harsh discipline refers to coercive actions or negative emotional expressions in response to children's inappropriate behaviors. 11,12 There is a close relationship between adolescent problem behaviors and parenting styles characterized by emotional warmth and harsh discipline. Existing studies have shown a negative correlation between parental warmth and problem behaviors; 13 for example, paternal warmth significantly predicts a reduction in children's externalizing problem behaviors one year later. 14 Longitudinal studies have found that parental physical punishment significantly predicts externalized problem behaviors such as aggression and disciplinary violations. 15 Authoritarian, strict, and punitive parenting methods are more likely to result in aggressive behaviors in children. 16,17 Other research indicates that strict parental control positively predicts internalized problem behaviors in children. 18 In summary, previous studies have primarily examined parental emotional warmth or harsh discipline as single-dimensional factors, neglecting the simultaneous presence of -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary