Abstract:To address the increasingly severe environmental challenges and achieve the "dual carbon" goals, the Chinese government has implemented a series of subsidy policies to promote green innovation and transformation of heavily polluting enterprises. However, against the backdrop of fierce market competition and tightening resource constraints, many companies still lack sufficient inherent motivation for green innovation. This study employs a systematic literature review method, analyzing relevant research from databases such as Web of Science, Scopus, and CNKI, aiming to systematically elucidate the research trajectory of government subsidies' impact on the green innovation performance of heavily polluting enterprises, thereby providing a theoretical perspective for improving relevant policy designs. The paper first posits that the logical starting point for government subsidies in green innovation lies in correcting environmental externalities, laying the foundation for subsequent discussions. It then examines the "incentive effect" and "crowding-out effect" of government subsidies on enterprises' green innovation performance, analyzes the non-linear relationship between government subsidies and corporate green innovation performance, and discusses the limitations of existing research from three aspects: relationship complexity, classification mechanisms, and influencing factors. Building on this, the paper integrates institutional theory with principal-agent theory to construct a multi-level analytical framework. This framework emphasizes the regulatory role of external institutional pressures, such as environmental regulations, on the effectiveness of subsidy implementation, while also focusing on how internal agency problems within enterprises may lead to inefficient utilization of subsidies, and how environmental information disclosure can help mitigate this issue. The study finds that there exists a non-linear relationship between subsidy intensity and green innovation performance, exhibiting "incentive effects" and "crowding-out effects" at different subsidy levels. Concurrently, factors such as environmental regulations, enterprise characteristics, and information disclosure practices play a moderating role in the effectiveness of subsidies. These findings have significant implications for policy-making, including designing subsidy schemes that avoid potential crowding-out effects at high subsidy levels, strengthening environmental regulations to enhance the effectiveness of R&D subsidies, implementing robust environmental information disclosure mechanisms, and formulating differentiated subsidy policies based on enterprise characteristics.

The impacts of government R&D subsidies on green innovation: Evidence from Chinese energy-intensive firms

Government environmental protection subsidies and corporate green innovation: Evidence from Chinese microenterprises

Do government subsidies improve innovation investment for new energy firms: A quasi-natural experiment of China's listed companies

More Government Subsidies, More Innovation of New Energy Firms? Evidence from China

Government R&D Subsidies and Firms' Innovation Performance: Empirical Evidence Based on Listed Companies in the New Energy Industry

More government subsidies, more green innovation? The evidence from Chinese new energy vehicle enterprises

Assessing the impact of R&D Investments, government subsidies on energy efficiency: empirical analysis from the Chinese listed firms

Do subsidies and R&D investment boost energy transition performance? Evidence from Chinese renewable energy firms

Do government subsidies promote enterprise green innovation? Evidence from listed companies in China

Positive or negative? R&D subsidies and green technology innovation: Evidence from China's renewable energy industry

The Influences of Government Subsidies on Performance of New Energy Firms: A Firm Heterogeneity Perspective

The effects of green fiscal policies and R&D investment on a firm's market value: New evidence from the renewable energy industry in China

Impact of Government Subsidies on Green Innovation in Polluting Enterprises: A Review

Impact of financial subsidies on the R&D intensity of new energy vehicles: A case study of 88 listed enterprises in China

The Effectiveness of Government Subsidies on Manufacturing Innovation: Evidence from the New Energy Vehicle Industry in China

Government Subsidies and Enterprise Innovation: Evidence from China's Photovoltaic Industry

Do Environmental Subsidies Spur Environmental Innovation? Empirical Evidence from Chinese Listed Firms

Government environmental protection subsidies, environmental tax collection, and green innovation: evidence from listed enterprises in China

Does green credit affect the green innovation performance of high-polluting and energy-intensive enterprises? Evidence from a quasi-natural experiment

The Impact of Government Subsidies and R&D Investment on the Operating Performance of New Energy Enterprises in China