Abstract:Street view imagery (SVI) is increasingly in competition with traditional remote sensing sources and assuming its domination in myriads of studies, mainly thanks to the omnipresence of commercial services such as Google Street View. Similar to other spatial data, SVI may be of variable quality and burdened with a variety of errors. Recently, this concern has been amplified with the rise of volunteered SVI such as Mapillary and KartaView, which – akin to other instances of Volunteered Geographic Information (VGI) – are of heterogeneous quality. However, unlike with many other forms of spatial data, there has not been much discussion about the quality of SVI datasets, let alone a standard and mechanism to assess them. Further, current spatial data quality standards are not entirely applicable to SVI due to its particularities. Following a multi-pronged method, we establish a comprehensive framework for describing and assessing the quality of SVI. We present a categorised set of 48 elements that suggest the quality of imagery and associated data such as geographic information and metadata. The framework is applicable to any source of SVI, including both commercial and crowdsourcing services. In the implementation, which we release open-source, we assess several quality elements of SVI datasets across 9 cities. The results expose varying quality of SVI and affirm the importance of the work. Given the exponential volume of studies taking advantage of SVI, but largely overlooking quality aspects, this work is a timely contribution that will benefit data providers, contributors, and users. It may also be applied on other forms of image-based VGI, and underpin establishing a formal international standard in the future. On a broader perspective, while providing an overdue definition of SVI, this work also reveals issues and open questions that impede delineating and assessing this diverse form of urban and terrestrial imagery.

Remote sensing data quality model: from data sources to lifecycle phases

Assessing Data Quality Within Available Context

Water Quality Monitoring and Evaluation Using Remote Sensing Techniques in China: a Systematic Review

Spatial data quality and beyond

Modeling data quality for risk assessment of GIS

A survey of open-source data quality tools: shedding light on the materialization of data quality dimensions in practice

The Analysis and Modelling of the Quality of Information Acquired from Weather Station Sensors

Definition and Evaluation of Data Quality: User-Oriented Data Object-Driven Approach to Data Quality Assessment

A comprehensive framework for evaluating the quality of street view imagery

Quantitative Remote Sensing at Ultra-High Resolution with UAV Spectroscopy: A Review of Sensor Technology, Measurement Procedures, and Data Correction Workflows

Data Quality in Empirical Software Engineering: A Targeted Review

Data Quality Assessment: Challenges and Opportunities

A Geostatistical Approach to Spatial Quality Assessment of Coarse Spatial Resolution Remote Sensing Products

A Review of Remote Sensing for Water Quality Retrieval: Progress and Challenges

The Source-End Method of Remote Sensing Information Quality Enhancement and the Physical Basis of Geoscience-Photoelectric Parameters Connection

DAQUA-MASS: An ISO 8000-61 Based Data Quality Management Methodology for Sensor Data

Sensor data quality: a systematic review

Measuring Data Quality of Geoscience Datasets Using Data Mining Techniques

A method for quality management of vegetation phenophases derived from satellite remote sensing data

Integrating Remote Sensing Methods for Monitoring Lake Water Quality: A Comprehensive Review