Abstract:Introduction: The implementation of evidence-informed policies and practices across systems is a complex, multifaceted endeavor, often requiring the mobilization of multiple organizations from a range of contexts. In order to facilitate this process, policy makers, innovation developers and service deliverers are increasingly calling upon intermediaries to support implementation, yet relatively little is known about precisely how they contribute to implementation. This study examines the role of intermediaries supporting the implementation of evidence-informed policies and practices in the mental health and addictions systems of New Zealand, Ontario, Canada and Sweden. Methods: Using a comparative case study methodology and taking an integrated knowledge translation approach, we drew from established explanatory frameworks and implementation theory to address three questions: (1) Why were the intermediaries established? (2) How are intermediaries structured and what strategies do they use in systems to support the implementation of policy directions? and (3) What explains the lack of use of particular strategies? Data collection included three site visits, 49 key informant interviews and document analysis. Results: In each jurisdiction, a unique set of problems (e.g., negative events involving people with mental illness), policies (e.g., feedback on effectiveness of existing policies) and political events (e.g., changes in government) were coupled by a policy entrepreneur to bring intermediaries onto the decision agenda. While intermediaries varied greatly in their structure and characteristics, both the strategies they used and the strategies they didn't use were surprisingly similar. Specifically it was notable that none of the intermediaries used strategies that directly targeted the public, nor used audit and feedback. This emerged as the principle policy puzzle. Our analysis identified five reasons for these strategies not being employed: (1) their need to build/maintain healthy relationships with policy actors; (2) their need to build/maintain healthy relationships with service delivery system actors; (3) role differentiation with other system actors; (4) perceived lack of "fit" with the role of policy intermediaries; and (5) resource limitations that preclude intensive distributed (program-level) work. Conclusion: Policy makers and implementers must consider capacity to support implementation, and our study identifies how intermediaries can be developed and harnessed to support the implementation process.

The Role of Intermediaries in Social Innovation: The Case of Social Procurement in Australia

The Impact of Informal Social Interaction on Innovation Capability in the Context of Buyer-Supplier Dyads

The Roles of Intermediaries in Sectoral Innovation Systems and Clusters in China and Thailand: an Overview

The roles and dynamics of transition intermediaries in enabling sustainable public food procurement: insights from Spain

The innovation impacts of public procurement offices: The case of healthcare procurement

The Role of Intermediary Organizations in Enhancing the Innovation Capability of MSMEs: Evidence from a Chinese Case

The Impact of Intermediaries on Innovation Performance at Small- and Medium-Sized Enterprises in the Yangtze River Delta

Institutional intermediaries as legitimizing agents for social enterprise in China and India

Supplier–supplier Coopetition and Buyer Innovation: a Perspective of Learning and Competitive Tension Within the Focal Buyer's Supplier Network

Policy instruments for public procurement of innovation: Choice, design and assessment

Piggy in the Middle: How Direct Customer Power Affects First-Tier Suppliers’ Adoption of Socially Responsible Procurement Practices and Performance

Understanding the Impact of Buyer Extra-Role Behavior on Supply-Side Operational Transparency: A Serial Mediation Model

A systematic review on barriers and enablers toward circular procurement management

The long shadow of public policy; Barriers to a value-based approach in healthcare procurement

Intermediaries in the justice system for people with communication disability: Enacting Sustainable Development Goal 16 in Ireland, Northern Ireland, and New Zealand

Coordinating multi-level collective action: how intermediaries and digital governance can help supply chains tackle grand challenges

Role transitions at the prosumer level: spillover effects in the collaborative economy from an interactive marketing perspective

Bridging the Gaps or Fecklessness? A Moderated Mediating Examination of Intermediaries’ Effects on Corporate Innovation

Conceptualising the systemic activities of intermediaries in sustainability transitions

An examination of mental health policy implementation efforts and the intermediaries that support them in New Zealand, Canada and Sweden: a comparative case study

Unpacking the Roles of Shareholder Engagement Intermediaries: A Case Study of an Engagement Process on Carbon Risk