Abstract:Background: The causal relationships between neural substrates and human language have been investigated by transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS). However, the robustness of TMS neuromodulatory effects is still largely unspecified. This study aims to systematically examine the efficacy of TMS on healthy participants' language performance. Methods: For this meta-analysis, we searched PubMed , Web of Science , PsycINFO , Scopus , and Google Scholar from database inception until October 15, 2022 for eligible TMS studies on language comprehension and production in healthy adults published in English. The quality of the included studies was assessed with the Cochrane risk of bias tool. Potential publication biases were assessed by funnel plots and the Egger Test. We conducted overall as well as moderator meta-analyses. Effect sizes were estimated using Hedges' g ( g ) and entered into a three-level random effects model. Results: Thirty-seven studies (797 participants) with 77 effect sizes were included. The three-level random effects model revealed significant overall TMS effects on language performance in healthy participants (RT: g = 0.16, 95% CI: 0.04–0.29; ACC: g = 0.14, 95% CI: 0.04–0.24). Further moderator analyses indicated that (a) for language tasks , TMS induced significant neuromodulatory effects on semantic and phonological tasks, but didn't show significance for syntactic tasks; (b) for cortical targets , TMS effects were not significant in left frontal, temporal or parietal regions, but were marginally significant in the inferior frontal gyrus in a finer-scale analysis; (c) for stimulation parameters , stimulation sites extracted from previous studies, rTMS, and intensities calibrated to the individual resting motor threshold are more prone to induce robust TMS effects. As for stimulation frequencies and timing, both high and low frequencies, online and offline stimulation elicited significant effects; (d) for experimental designs , studies adopting sham TMS or no TMS as the control condition and within-subject design obtained more significant effects. Discussion: Overall, the results show that TMS may robustly modulate healthy adults' language performance and scrutinize the brain-and-language relation in a profound fashion. However, due to limited sample size and constraints in the current meta-analysis approach, analyses at a more comprehensive level were not conducted and results need to be confirmed by future studies. Systematic review registration: [https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.php?RecordID=366481], identifier [CRD42022366481].

Transcranial magnetic stimulation during British Sign Language production reveals monitoring of discrete linguistic units in left superior parietal lobule

Tactile Stimulation Improves Sensorimotor Rhythm-Based BCI Performance in Stroke Patients.

Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Facilitates Neural Speech Decoding

Talking hands: tongue motor excitability during observation of hand gestures associated with words

Changes in corticospinal motor excitability induced by non-motor linguistic tasks

Neuromodulatory effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation on language performance in healthy participants: Systematic review and meta-analysis

How Auditory Experience Differentially Influences the Function of Left and Right Superior Temporal Cortices

A common neural system is activated in hearing non-signers to process French sign language and spoken French

Stimulating the Brain's Language Network: Syntactic Ambiguity Resolution after TMS to the Inferior Frontal Gyrus and Middle Temporal Gyrus

Transcallosal generation of phase aligned beta-bursts underlies TMS-induced interhemispheric inhibition

Brain Activations Associated with Sign Production Using Word and Picture Inputs in Deaf Signers

Context, transparency and culture in motor resonance phenomena: Causal evidence of the motor cortex

Analysis of the visual spatiotemporal properties of American Sign Language

Neuroanatomical differences in visual, motor, and language cortices between congenitally deaf signers, hearing signers, and hearing non-signers

Transcranial direct stimulation over left inferior frontal gyrus improves language production and comprehension in post-stroke aphasia: A double-blind randomized controlled study

Continuous theta burst stimulation-induced suppression of the right fronto-thalamic-cerebellar circuit accompanies improvement in language performance in poststroke aphasia: A resting-state fMRI study

Transcranial magnetic stimulation over supramarginal gyrus stimulates primary motor cortex directly and impairs manual dexterity: Implications for TMS focality

Transformation but not generation of motor images is disrupted following stimulation over the left inferior parietal lobe

Enhanced motor function and its neurophysiological correlates after navigated low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation over the contralesional motor cortex in stroke

Reduced neural selectivity for mental states in deaf children with delayed exposure to sign language

Switching off: disruptive TMS reveals distinct contributions of the posterior middle temporal gyrus and angular gyrus to bilingual speech production