Influence of a 3-month low-calorie Mediterranean diet compared to the vegetarian diet on human gut microbiota and SCFA: the CARDIVEG Study

Giuditta Pagliai,Edda Russo,Elena Niccolai,Monica Dinu,Vincenzo Di Pilato,Alessandro Magrini,Gianluca Bartolucci,Simone Baldi,Marta Menicatti,Betti Giusti,Rossella Marcucci,Gian Maria Rossolini,Alessandro Casini,Francesco Sofi,Amedeo Amedei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00394-019-02050-0
IF: 4.8646
2019-07-10
European Journal of Nutrition
Abstract:<span class="a-plus-plus abstract-section id-a-sec1"><h3 class="a-plus-plus">Purpose</h3><p class="a-plus-plus">We evaluated the effect of low-calorie mediterranean (MD) and vegetarian (VD) diets on gut microbiome (GM) composition and short-chain-fatty acids (SCFA) production.</p></span><span class="a-plus-plus abstract-section id-a-sec2"><h3 class="a-plus-plus">Methods</h3><p class="a-plus-plus">We performed next generation sequencing (NGS) of 16S rRNA and SCFA analysis on fecal samples of 23 overweight omnivores (16 F; 7 M) with low-to-moderate cardiovascular risk. They were randomly assigned to a VD or MD, each lasting 3 months, with a crossover study design.</p></span><span class="a-plus-plus abstract-section id-a-sec3"><h3 class="a-plus-plus">Results</h3><p class="a-plus-plus">Dietary interventions did not produce significant diversity in the GM composition at higher ranks (family and above), neither between nor within MD and VD, but they did it at genus level. MD significantly changed the abundance of <em class="a-plus-plus">Enterorhabdus</em>, <em class="a-plus-plus">Lachnoclostridium</em> and <em class="a-plus-plus">Parabacteroides</em>, while VD significantly affected the abundance of <em class="a-plus-plus">Anaerostipes</em>, <em class="a-plus-plus">Streptococcus</em>, <em class="a-plus-plus">Clostridium</em> sensu stricto, and <em class="a-plus-plus">Odoribacter</em>. Comparison of the mean variation of each SCFA between MD and VD showed an opposite and statistically significant trend for propionic acid (+ 10% vs − 28%, respectively, <em class="a-plus-plus">p</em> = 0.034). In addition, variations of SCFA were negatively correlated with changes of some inflammatory cytokines such as VEGF, MCP-1, IL-17, IP-10 and IL-12, only after MD. Finally, correlation analyses showed a potential relationship—modulated by the two diets—between changes of genera and changes of clinical and biochemical parameters.</p></span><span class="a-plus-plus abstract-section id-a-sec4"><h3 class="a-plus-plus">Conclusions</h3><p class="a-plus-plus">A short-term dietary intervention with MD or VD does not induce major change in the GM, suggesting that a diet should last longer than 3 months for scratching the microbial resilience. Changes in SCFA production support their role in modulating the inflammatory response, thus mediating the anti-inflammatory and protective properties of MD.</p></span>
nutrition & dietetics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore the effects of a three - month Mediterranean diet (MD) and vegetarian diet (VD) on the composition of the human gut microbiota (GM) and short - chain fatty acid (SCFA) production. Specifically, researchers hope to understand, by comparing these two diet patterns, how they change the structure and function of the gut microbiota and whether these changes are related to risk factors for cardiovascular diseases. ### Main research objectives: 1. **Evaluate the impact of dietary interventions on the gut microbiota**: Researchers hope to observe the short - term effects of these two diet patterns on the composition of the gut microbiota through a low - calorie Mediterranean diet and a vegetarian diet. 2. **Analyze the impact of dietary interventions on short - chain fatty acid production**: Researchers also focus on the effects of these two diet patterns on the production of short - chain fatty acids (such as acetic acid, butyric acid, and propionic acid), especially whether the changes in these fatty acids are related to the regulation of the inflammatory response. 3. **Explore the impact of dietary interventions on inflammatory cytokines**: Researchers further analyze the relationship between the changes in short - chain fatty acids and the changes in inflammatory cytokines (such as VEGF, MCP - 1, IL - 17, IP - 10, and IL - 12) after dietary interventions. ### Research methods: - **Research subjects**: 23 overweight omnivores (16 females and 7 males) with a low - to - moderate cardiovascular risk. - **Design**: A crossover design was adopted, and participants were randomly assigned to the Mediterranean diet or vegetarian diet group, with each diet lasting three months. - **Sample collection**: Fecal samples were collected at baseline, before and after each dietary intervention for 16S rRNA sequencing and short - chain fatty acid analysis. - **Data analysis**: Multiple statistical methods (such as PERMANOVA, PCA, PLSDA, etc.) were used to analyze the changes in the microbiota composition and short - chain fatty acids. ### Main findings: - **Changes in microbiota composition**: Dietary interventions significantly changed the abundances of certain microorganisms at the genus level, but had no significant impact on the diversity at higher taxonomic levels (such as family and above). - The Mediterranean diet significantly changed the abundances of Enterorhabdus, Lachnoclostridium, and Parabacteroides. - The vegetarian diet significantly changed the abundances of Anaerostipes, Streptococcus, Clostridium sensu stricto, and Odoribacter. - **Changes in short - chain fatty acids**: The Mediterranean diet and the vegetarian diet had different effects on the production of short - chain fatty acids, especially in terms of propionic acid. - The Mediterranean diet led to a 10% increase in propionic acid, while the vegetarian diet led to a 28% decrease in propionic acid. - **Changes in inflammatory cytokines**: After the Mediterranean diet, the changes in short - chain fatty acids were negatively correlated with the changes in certain inflammatory cytokines (such as VEGF, MCP - 1, IL - 17, IP - 10, and IL - 12), indicating that short - chain fatty acids may play an anti - inflammatory role by regulating the inflammatory response. ### Conclusions: - Short - term dietary interventions (three months) have little impact on the overall diversity of the gut microbiota, but have a significant impact on the abundances of certain specific genera. - The changes in short - chain fatty acids support their role in regulating the inflammatory response, thereby mediating the anti - inflammatory and protective properties of the Mediterranean diet. - To more comprehensively understand the impact of diet on the gut microbiota, longer - term dietary interventions may be required. Through these findings, researchers provide an important scientific basis for further research on the relationship between diet and the gut microbiota.