Abstract:Land policy making is a complex systemic process in which new policies emerge and are nonlinearly transferred. However, challenges remain, as the recent policy diffusion literature cannot match policy making to complex adaptive systems. This study elucidates the conjunctural causal mechanisms of local policy innovation and diffusion in China. To analyze the differences in China's land reform, a theoretical framework is established that includes four key conditions-incentive rules, local context, vertical governmental coercion and interregional diffusion-as well as three analytical principles, namely, nonlinearity, conjunction and intersection. Then, an archetype analysis based on the fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis method is conducted on 119 city governments that implemented land retention policies during the period of 2000-2019. The results systematically associate local policy action with five theory-based archetypes, each with its own narrative expression ("risk aversion", "reform pilot", "political learning", "induced competition", and "social evolution"). This article reveals that 1) China's administrative institutional structure shapes the reform motivation of local governments and their interaction with the central government, and the performance evaluation system for officials plays a key role in this dynamic; 2) local contexts can limit or amplify coercive and learning mechanisms, and policy knowledge can impede diffusion under certain conditions; and 3) the combination of archetypes occurs at three levels: theoretical mechanisms, conditional elements, and factor combinations. Overall, the study shows how multilevel factor interactions influence the decision-making process for China's land reform. These findings can serve as useful references for conjunctural causation research on policy innovation and diffusion in China and assist local decision makers in other countries in transition in developing sustainable land policies.

Political Recentralisation and the Diffusion of Solar Energy in China

The Vertically Decentralized Authoritarianism and the Mechanisms of Political Stability in China

Political Risk of Centralization and the Vertical Separation of Powers:Reform of Contemporary Social Management System from a Historical Perspective

China's climate change policy: Central–local governmental interaction

Growing China’s renewables sector: a developmental state approach

Land Policy Making in a Complex System: the Innovation and Diffusion Logic of China's Retained Land Policy Reform

Centralization or decentralization? the impact of different distributions of authority on China's environmental regulation

The Politics of Climate Change in China

Political Decentralization and the Path-Dependent Characteristics of the State Authoritarianism: an Integrated Conceptual Framework to Understand China’s Territorial Fragmentation

Emerging environmental Multi-Level Governance in China? Environmental protests, public participation and local institution-building

State capitalism, fragmented authoritarianism, and the politics of energy policymaking: Policy networks and electricity market liberalization in Guangdong, China

Low-carbon China: Emerging Phenomena and Implications for Innovation Governance

What Motivates Local Sustainability Policy Action in China? the Case of Low-Carbon City Pilot Program

A systematic analysis of stakeholder interaction and the barriers towards upscaling urban residential solar PV: The case of Shanghai, China

Spatio-temporal Dynamics and Determinants of New Energy Policy Diffusion in China: A Policy Citation Approach

Multi-level governance and competing sustainability aims: Politics of renewable energy development and nature conservation in Changdao, China

Assessing the roles of efficient market versus regulatory capture in China's power market reform

Understanding institutional barriers for wind curtailment in China

Inter-regional Diffusion of Policy Innovation in China: A Comparative Case Study

The transfer of provincial officials and electricity transactions in China

Exploring the role of environmental regulation on energy security: Contextual findings for sustainable development in Chinese Provinces