Abstract:Abstract Background Programme developers have the responsibility of ongoing programme renewal and evaluation to ensure that curricula remain responsive to rapidly changing educational and healthcare contexts. In reporting on programmes, significant emphasis is often placed on content and outcomes of Master’s in Health Professions Education (MHPE) programmes. However, less emphasis has been placed on meaningful evaluation of all aspects of these programmes, particularly from a student perspective including what worked and what needs to be enhanced, as well as any emergent or unplanned factors. As the number of established MHPE programmes increases, so does the need for evaluation models that consider programme complexity. In this article we consider a MHPE programme against a model that provided scope for going beyond ‘did it work?’ Our intention was to determine whether the renewed MPhil in HPE programme was implemented as planned, and to which extent it achieved the planned outcomes. Methods This programme evaluation was conducted in an interpretive paradigm. We collected qualitative data at two points. Firstly, at the start of students’ first-year with voluntary participation in focus groups and secondly, a year later with voluntary participation in individual interviews. Two members of the research team performed the initial thematic analysis of both the focus group interviews and the individual interviews. Thereafter, the full author team worked collaboratively discussing the themes until we reached consensus, looking specifically to identify any “emergent” factors. Results We identified three themes in the student data related to the process of implementing the new programme and the outcomes from it, including those aspects that could be regarded as emergent or unplanned: balancing work, personal lives and studies; managing the hybrid learning approach; and the scholarly journey. Conclusions While many of the outcomes of the renewed programme were met, not all manifested as had been planned. The experience of the programme differed from one student to the next such that at the end of the two years they were at different points in their scholarly journeys. We realised that although we sought to be pedagogically sound in the process of curriculum renewal, we did not take into account the complex matrix of influences that sit outside the formal curriculum. Future renewal activities should intentionally and sensitively consider those factors, both planned and emergent, that influence a student’s journey towards becoming a scholarly teacher and teaching scholar.

Educating Evaluators 1976–2017: An Expanded Analysis of University-Based Evaluation Education Programs

Mapping Evaluation, Appraisal and Stance in Discourse (2000–2015): A Bibliometric Analysis

Identifying areas and approaches for improving evaluation processes in environmental education in the United States of America

Teaching program evaluation: How blending theory and practice enhance student-evaluator competencies in an education policy graduate program

A Mixed Methods Evaluation of Teaching Evaluation: Innovative Course-Based Service-Learning Model on Program Evaluation Competencies

Teaching Evaluation Through Community-Engaged Learning Courses

How does research evaluation impact educational research? Exploring intended and unintended consequences of research assessment in the United Kingdom, 1986–2014

Planning for Program Evaluation Improves Implementation and Assessment

Planned or emergent? An evaluation of a Master’s in Health Professions Education programme

A Review of Research on Theory and Practice of Higher Education Evaluation

Internal evaluation of medical programs is more than housework: A scoping review

Effectiveness of Evaluation Evidence to Influence Change in Primary Education Sub-sector in Uganda

Program evaluation in rehabilitation

Using contribution analysis to evaluate health professions and health sciences programs

A Professional Grounding and History of the Development and Formal Use of Evaluator Competencies

Teachers performance evaluation: the experience of the Dentist Academic Program of the Universidad del Valle.

Classroom evaluation - values, interests and teacher development

Assessment and evaluation in geographical and environmental education

Fifty years of social work education: Analysis of motivations and outcomes

A culturally responsive evaluation framework and its application in environmental education

Examining Online Course Evaluations and the Quality of Student Feedback