Abstract:Introduction: The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) estimated that in 2019, intersection crashes accounted for $179 billion of economic damages and $639 billion in societal damages. Intersection advanced driver assist systems (I-ADASs) and automated driving systems (ADS) are designed and have been actively deployed to avoid or mitigate these intersection crash scenarios. Given the indeterminate parameter space for describing collision scenarios, evaluators, and designers are all challenged with condensing the possible intersection crash configurations into digestible, executable conditions for scenario-based simulation testing. The objective of this study is to identify functional intersection crash configurations for I-ADAS and ADS safety evaluation. Methods: Real-world intersection crash characteristics are important considerations for scenario testing as these features can directly correlate to or influence causality, controllability, and potential injury severity. To identify functional intersection crash types, similar crash scenarios were grouped together by identified critical features using an unsupervised decision tree model. A key advantage of this approach was that the implemented cluster crash scenarios would be understandable and interpretable by users. Unsupervised decision trees work by generating uniformly distributed synthetic data with features from real data and classifying all the data as real or synthetic. Long, non-diverging branches were manually pruned to reduce overfitting and improve model performance. Feature importance values were computed based on how effective a given variable grouped the crashes together. Data sources: This analysis selected intersection cases that only involved two vehicles from the Crash Investigation Sampling System (CISS) spanning 2017 to 2020. Crash features such as road geometry, intersection signal, and vehicle configuration were important to consider for scenario generation. CISS contained the traffic device, device functionality, vehicle intended pre-event movement, road alignment, road profile, trafficway flow, number of lanes, and crash type for each crash case. Intersection geometry, intersecting road angle, each vehicles' legal moves, and the presence of a two-way-left-turn-lane (TWLTL), channelized roads, bike lanes, crosswalks, street parking, slip lanes, and visual obstructions were manually recorded from the scene diagram. Results: The tree identified 44 functional intersection crash configurations after pruning. These clusters have five main sections: Straight-crossing path (SCP) crashes at 4-legged intersections, Left-Turn-Across-Path/Opposite Direction (LTAP/OD) crashes at 4-legged intersections, other crash types at 4-legged intersections, roundabout and multileg intersections, and 3-legged intersection crashes. The features that best split the data were TWLTL, lane travel direction violation, and traffic control device functionality. The largest cluster was SCP crashes at 4-legged, undivided intersections where the traffic control device was working and both vehicles did not violate the direction of their lane of travel. This cluster was adjacent to 32 vehicles in similar SCP crashes except a vehicle performed an unexpected maneuver based on their lane position. Conclusion: These 44 identified crash configurations could be useful in bolstering the robustness of I-ADAS and ADS intersection scenario testing as they are a compact representation of all the police reported intersection crashes where a vehicle was towed. Future studies could generate logical scenarios with distributions of initial conditions and behaviors from these clusters that could be used to evaluate an I-ADAS or ADS.

Severity analysis of tree and utility pole crashes: Applying fast and frugal heuristics

The crash severity impacts of fixed roadside objects

Crash frequency prediction based on extreme value theory using roadside lidar-based vehicle trajectory data

Identification of Significant Factors in Fatal-Injury Highway Crashes Using Genetic Algorithm and Neural Network

Analyses of rear-end crashes based on classification tree models

Predicting Crashes on Expressway Ramps with Real-Time Traffic and Weather Data

Investigation of Freeway Incident Duration Using Classification and Regression Trees Based on Multisource Data

Real-time Traffic Accident Risk Prediction based on Frequent Pattern Tree

Wrong-way driving crash injury analysis on arterial road networks using non-parametric data mining techniques

Short-Term Segment-Level Crash Risk Prediction Using Advanced Data Modeling with Proactive and Reactive Crash Data

Identifying high crash risk segments in rural roads using ensemble decision tree-based models

Severity assessment of accidents involving roadside trees based on occupant injury analysis

Identifying roadway departure crash patterns on rural two-lane highways under different lighting conditions: association knowledge using data mining approach

Investigation of injury severities in single-vehicle crashes in North Carolina using mixed logit models

Clustering-Based Roadway Segment Division for the Identification of High-Crash Locations

A Statistical Analysis of Recent Traffic Crashes in Massachusetts

Approach-level real-time crash risk analysis for signalized intersections

Determination of functional scenarios for intersection collisions

Developing a new real-time traffic safety management framework for urban expressways utilizing reinforcement learning tree

Crash Risk Evaluation and Crash Severity Pattern Analysis for Different Types of Urban Junctions: Fault Tree Analysis and Association Rules Approaches

Analysis Framework to Assess Crash Severity for Large Trucks on Rural Interstate Roads Utilizing the Latent Class and Random Parameter Model