Abstract:Repeated interactions provide an evolutionary explanation for one-shot human cooperation that is counterintuitive but orthodox 1,2,3 . Intergroup competition 4,5,6,7 provides an explanation that is intuitive but heterodox. Here, using models and a behavioural experiment, we show that neither mechanism reliably supports cooperation. Ambiguous reciprocity, a class of strategies that is generally ignored in models of reciprocal altruism, undermines cooperation under repeated interactions. This finding challenges repeated interactions as an evolutionary explanation for cooperation in general, which further challenges the claim that repeated interactions in the past can explain one-shot cooperation in the present. Intergroup competitions also do not reliably support cooperation because groups quickly become extremely similar, which limits scope for group selection. Moreover, even if groups vary, group competitions may generate little group selection for multiple reasons. Cooperative groups, for example, may tend to compete against each other 8 . Whereas repeated interactions and group competitions do not support cooperation by themselves, combining them triggers powerful synergies because group competitions constrain the corrosive effect of ambiguous reciprocity. Evolved strategies often consist of cooperative reciprocity with ingroup partners and uncooperative reciprocity with outgroup partners. Results from a behavioural experiment in Papua New Guinea fit exactly this pattern. They thus suggest neither an evolutionary history of repeated interactions without group competition nor a history of group competition without repeated interactions. Instead, our results suggest social motives that evolved under the joint influence of both mechanisms.

Evolution of indirect reciprocity by image scoring

Cooperation and Charity in Spatial Public Goods Game under Different Strategy Update Rules

Numerical and Analytical Study of Evolution of Indirect Reciprocity

Evolution of cooperation between individuals

Dynamics of heuristics selection for cooperative behaviour

The co-evolution of direct, indirect and generalized reciprocity

Cooperative Trends in a Modified Image Scoring Model

Evolutionary Dynamics of Direct and Indirect Reciprocity on Networked Populations

Cooperation through image scoring in humans.

The evolution of cooperation and diversity by integrated indirect reciprocity

The Evolution Of Cooperation In The Presence Of Costs Of Information Transfer

Evolutionary Dynamics of Direct and Indirect Reciprocities with Directional Interactions

Indirect reciprocity with stochastic rules

Evolution of reciprocity with limited payoff memory

The evolution of conditional moral assessment in indirect reciprocity

The evolution of cooperation

Indirect reciprocity can stabilize cooperation without the second-order free rider problem

Super-additive cooperation

Evolution of cooperation with asymmetric social interactions

Evolutionary stability of cooperation by the leading eight norms in indirect reciprocity under noisy and private assessment