Abstract:Context: Digital twin (DT) ecosystems are rapidly evolving, connecting many stakeholders, such as manufacturers, customers, and application platform providers. These ecosystems require collaboration and interaction between diverse actors to create value. This study delves into the collaboration of such stakeholders within DT-focused ecosystems. Objective: This research aims to understand stakeholder collaboration within DT ecosystems, identify potential challenges, and provide insights for managing these stakeholders. It also seeks to define the DT ecosystem and its implications for both research and practice. Method: A systematic literature review was conducted, supplemented by empirical evidence gathered from interviews with DT experts who were knowledgeable about the DT ecosystem. The study also analyzed DT systems, stakeholder roles, and the challenges with ecosystem-focused DT development. Results: The study identified various stakeholders and their roles in adding value to a DT ecosystem. It highlighted the benefits of stakeholder collaboration, such as knowledge gain during DT system development. The research also revealed the technical and non-technical challenges encountered in ecosystem-focused DTs, emphasizing the importance of standardization as a solution. A new definition of the DT ecosystem was proposed, emphasizing its data-driven nature, interconnected DTs, stakeholder value creation, and technology enablement. Conclusion: Stakeholder collaboration is pivotal in DT ecosystems, with each actor playing a distinct role. Addressing challenges, especially through standardization (OPC UA and ISO 23247), can lead to more efficient and coherent DT ecosystems. The insights provided by this study can guide industries in designing, developing, and maintaining their DT ecosystems, ensuring value creation and stakeholder satisfaction. Future research avenues that emphasize the importance of understanding the challenges involved and deploy appropriate solutions were suggested.

Towards creation of a reference architecture for trust-based digital ecosystems

The Ecosystem of Trust (EoT): Enabling effective deployment of autonomous systems through collaborative and trusted ecosystems

Stakeholders collaborations, challenges and emerging concepts in digital twin ecosystems

Digital Twin Evolution for Sustainable Smart Ecosystems

Digital Twin-Enabled Decision Support Services in Industrial Ecosystems

Digital Ecosystems: Ecosystem-Oriented Architectures

Towards Reference Architectures for Trustworthy Collaborative Cyber-Physical Systems: Reference Architectures as Boundary Objects

An Architecture Based on Digital Twins for Smart Power Distribution System

EtherTwin: Blockchain-based Secure Digital Twin Information Management

Model of Trust Management for Digital Industry Services. Towards E-Commerce 4.0

Distributed Trust Through the Lens of Software Architecture

An architecture of an Intelligent Digital Twin in a Cyber-Physical Production System

Medium-Level Architectures for Digital Twins: Bridging Conceptual Reference Architectures to Practical Implementation in Cloud, Edge and Cloud–Edge Deployments

The Emergence of Cognitive Digital Twin: Vision, Challenges and Opportunities.

Digital Ecosystems: Evolving Service-Oriented Architectures

A survey of the state‐of‐the‐art approaches for evaluating trust in software ecosystems

The Universal Trust Machine: A survey on the Web3 path towards enabling long term digital cooperation through decentralised trust

A Survey on Digital Twins: Architecture, Enabling Technologies, Security and Privacy, and Future Prospects

CTRUST: A Dynamic Trust Model for Collaborative Applications in the Internet of Things.

Emergence of Digital Twins

Digital twins: artificial intelligence and the IoT cyber-physical systems in Industry 4.0