Abstract:Purpose Strategies to promote more sustainable consumer choices have been gaining interest among tourism and hospitality scholars. In particular, behavioral economic theories of decision-making have gained popularity in the past decade, led by behavioral interventions (BIs) such as the nudge movement. This paper aims to present a critical reflection on this recent trend, with a specific focus on whether these BI approaches are an adequate tool to contribute to long-term behavioral changes, one crucial aim of the promotion of sustainable consumption. Design/methodology/approach Based on a critical review of recent significant academic works in the field, this paper reflects on how nudge principles are applied in the hospitality and tourism sectors, as well as the usual justifications given for their use. This paper then discusses the potential limitations, both theoretical and practical, of using these short-term focused approaches to decisions that intend to have long-term outcomes and aims. Findings BIs in hospitality and tourism have the potential to create long-term sustainable changes through a more comprehensive view of behavioral factors influencing decisions; however, such approaches would need to be strongly embedded in theoretical arguments that question "how" and "why" behavior change could be sustainable in the long term. This paper proposes a conceptual framework to address these concerns for future research. Research limitations/implications This critical reflection proposes a comprehensive framework that will help guide stronger theoretically motivated identification, design and empirical testing of BIs and nudges. Industry can eventually benefit from theoretically stronger interventions that provide a balance between the short-term and long-term influence of BIs to attain customer loyalty and eventually greater value for business stakeholders. Originality/value This reflection paper critically reviews the basis of BIs and recommends a framework to strengthen their theoretical arguments. This reflection focuses on the theoretical critique of BIs and nudges to ensure long-term behavior changes are sustainable. The paper also proposes a comprehensive framework that incorporates well-founded theoretical models to enhance BIs and nudge literature.

Effects of nature-based solutions (NBS) on eco-friendly hotel guests’ mental health perceptions, satisfaction, switching barriers, and revisit intentions

Hotels’ Eco-Friendly Physical Environment as Nature-Based Solutions for Decreasing Burnout and Increasing Job Satisfaction and Performance

Impact of airport green atmospherics on mental health value, image, and loyalty among visitors and workers

How and when Does Religiosity Contribute to Tourists’ Intention to Behave Pro-Environmentally in Hotels?

Rationality or morality? A comparative study of pro-environmental intentions of local and nonlocal visitors in nature-based destinations

Exploring the Role of Healthy Green Spaces, Psychological Resilience, Attitude, Brand Attachment, and Price Reasonableness in Increasing Hotel Guest Retention

Impact of green atmospherics on guest and employee well-being response, place dependence, and behavior in the luxury hotel sector

Sustainable consumer choices – critical reflection on hospitality and tourism

A Study of the Integrated Model with Norm Activation Model and Theory of Planned Behavior: Applying the Green Hotel’s Corporate Social Responsibilities

The impact of deontological and teleological variables on the intention to visit green hotel: The moderating role of trust

Can Environmentally Sustainable Development and Green Innovation of Hotels Trigger the Formation of a Positive Brand and Price Premium?

An empirical analysis of green convention attendees' switching intentions

Biophilic Urban Hotel Design and Restorative Experiencescapes

Anticipating Z-generation tourists' green hotel visit intention utilizing an extended theory of planned behavior

Enhancing consumers' intention to stay in an eco-resort via climate change anxiety and connectedness to nature

How Green Marketing Influences Customers’ Green Behavioral Intentions in the Context of Hot-Spring Hotels

Engaging with restorative environments in wellness tourism

Assessing Green Practices on Eco-Friendly Hotel Customer Loyalty: A Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling and Fuzzy-Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis Hybrid Approach

The Effects of Atmosphere on Perceived Values and Customer Satisfaction toward the Theme Hotel: The Moderating Role of Green Practice Perception

Research on Factors Influencing Hotel Consumers' Health: A Systematic Review and Ways Forward

From nature experience to visitors' pro-environmental behavior: the role of perceived restorativeness and well-being