Teaching Effectiveness of SPOC Flipped Classroom in College:A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
Chunyan LIU,Dan LI,Baoren ZHANG,Xiaoling HU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13966/j.cnki.kfjyyj.2019.01.009
2019-01-01
Abstract:In recent years, the flipped classroom has become the mainstream mode of digital education in colleges. There are numerous research studies on SPOC flipped classroom instruction, and most of them show great potential. However, the small sample size of these studies cannot be used as strong evidence to promote the SPOC flipped classroom. Therefore, this study used systematic review method to compare and analyze the teaching effects of SPOC flipped classroom and traditional teaching in college and used meta-analysis method to conduct the statistical analysis of the effect values by homogeneity study, so as to increase the sample sizes to obtain the scientific conclusions. ERIC, Teacher Reference Center, Education Research Complete, Web of Science, CNKI, VIP and Wanfang databases, and many online research registration platform such as Cochrane Collaboration Library, Campbell Collaboration Library, EPPI, WWC and System for Information on Grey Literature in Europe ( OpenSIGLE) were searched from January2007 to July 2018. The reviewers screened all quantitative studies about the effectiveness of SPOC flipped classroom and traditional classroom teaching according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, assessed the quality and extracted the data from 19 original controlled studies included. RevMan Manager 5. 3 software was used to conduct meta-analysis. The results of Meta-analysis showed that the test scores, knowledge understanding ability, knowledge application ability, self-learning ability, self-management ability and learning motivation of SPOC flipped classroom were higher than traditional classroom. There was no significant difference in passing rate, excellent rate, and collaboration ability in the SPOC flipped classroom and traditional classroom teaching. Students had higher interest, seriousness, participation, and satisfaction in the SPOC flipped classroom. We conclude that there is no significant difference in achievement rate, and collaboration ability between SPOC flipped classroom and traditional classroom, but the SPOC flipped classroom outperforms the traditional one in terms of improving academic performance and some learning abilities. Students are more active and satisfied in the SPOC flipped classroom. Of course, this study has its own limitations, and further research is needed.