Bilingualism in Ukraine: defining attitudes to Ukrainian and Russian through geographical and generational variations in language practices
O. Ivanova
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1558/SOLS.V7I3.249
2014-04-28
Abstract:AbstractThis paper examines the question of attitudes to Ukrainian-Russian bilingualism in post-Soviet Ukraine. Since the dissolution of the USSR, Ukrainian society has been subject to a new language policy, which reconsiders the status of both Ukrainian and Russian and, thus, contributes to changes in the sociolinguistic situation in the country. The common process of ukrainization is aimed at reconstruction of the titular Ukrainian language and is based on the principle of linguistic homogeneity in Ukrainian society. This paper presents results of an empirical study, which explores changes in the language preferences, attitudes and practices in Ukraine in view of the post-independence language policy. It analyses the distribution of Ukrainian and Russian in different geographical and sociolinguistic zones of the country. It focuses on deviations that contextual and social factors produce in the disposition of speakers to use both languages in contact and searches for corroboration of a generational change. The paper presents a proposal for a geosociolinguistic classification of Ukraine and delimits socio-political, social and contextual factors correlating with the language preferences and attitudes of the speakers.KEYWORDS: UKRAINE, BILINGUALISM, ATTITUDES TO LANGUAGE, DIGLOSSIA, UKRAINIAN, RUSSIAN1 IntroductionAttitudes towards the coexistence of two languages commonly frame the percep- tual and functional construction of a bilingual society. Societal bilingualism both manages and is managed by such attitudes: a complex of evaluative orientations to languages in contact that is reflected in positive or negative reactions to them (Garrett, 2010:20). Attitudes make a clearly psychological construct about a language's correction, appropriation, correspondence, and even its aesthetics and the personal qualities of its speakers (Trudgill and Hernandez-Campoy, 2007:26- 27). In a bilingual community, attitudes act as an authority and shape a complex perspective on languages' social correlates and their functional existence. They outline the functional type of bilingualism and the spectrum of the languages in contact. As an empiric reproduction of the speakers' psychological constructs, attitudes engage in context-dependent language uses.Attitudes to bilingualism have been studied in many world communities with different historical and linguistic backgrounds. For some speech communities attitudes have been described as stable; for others, they have been defined as variable under socio-political changes (Dewaele, 2010:124). In this regard, bilin- gual communities with a recently altered socio-political scenario incite particular sociolinguistic interest in the reconstruction of attitudes. Identity negotiation, contextualised by the recovery of stateness in societies in transition, grants recon- sideration and further definition of the speakers' attitudes to the languages in contact.In this line, post-Soviet countries represent a particular continuum, where a remodelling of attitudes to bilingualism is currently taking place. Frequently compared to postcolonial communities (Kuzio, 2002; Pavlenko and Blackledge, 2004; Ciscel, 2008), post-Soviet countries as societies in transition are subject to new language policies, which reconsider the role of the post-Soviet bilingualisms and modify speakers' attitudes. Twenty years after the dissolution of the USSR, the planning of bilingualisms is still the chief factor governing the sociolinguistic situation in the post-Soviet area.In one of the post-Soviet countries, Ukraine, shifts in attitudes are determined by the historical singularity of Ukrainian-Russian bilingualism and its social variation. Currently, language policy and planning in Ukraine have given rise to important differences in the language behaviour of Ukrainians. Most of them are either symmetrically or asymmetrically bilingual and their attitudes to Ukrainian- Russian bilingualism are conditioned by many social factors. …
Linguistics,Sociology,Political Science