Abstract:Concerns about women’s work were present at the advent of the modern method of national income accounting, and they have featured prominently in the most radical critiques of this method. During and after the Second World War, Phyllis Deane, a young researcher working under the supervision of Richard Stone, Austin Robinson and Arthur Lewis, grappled with the conceptual difficulties involved in measuring the ‘national’ incomes of mostly rural subsistence colonies in British central Africa. In constructing her estimates, Deane relied heavily on a multidisciplinary survey of nutrition conducted in interwar Nyasaland. Deane’s work was essentially an exercise in reductionism and bounding; she sought to extract from these data a single monetary estimate of production. Yet Deane also proved unwilling to exclude too much. She broke with her advisors’ favoured convention that activities not involved in market exchange should be excluded from the national income. Successive national income accountants around the world would reach disparate conclusions on method, particularly on the question of the ‘production boundary’—that is, the dividing line between those productive activities that would be included in the national income and those that would not. This issue became most contentious in the sphere of ‘non-monetary’ or ‘subsistence’ production performed mostly by female producers. While some statisticians included firewood collection, beer brewing and cooking, many others thought such activities beyond the bounds of ‘the economy’. Early decisions about the status of non-monetary production influenced the international standards enshrined in the United Nations System of National Accounts, first published in 1953. Beginning in the 1970s, second-wave feminists criticised the invisibility of women’s work in national income estimates. These critiques helped spur the inclusion of non-monetary activities in the accounts of many nations. Yet by the 1990s, many feminist critics—most notably New Zealand-born political economist Marilyn Waring—sought to move beyond GDP as a measure of welfare. These feminists called instead for greater reliance on measures such as the Human Development Index and time-use surveys. These measures may have appeared new, but they required the same multidisciplinary and intensive methods as Nyasaland’s interwar nutrition survey, which had served as the substrate for the earliest calculation of a ‘colonial national’ income. Drawing upon archives in the United Kingdom, Malawi and the United States, this paper argues that feminist economists and women’s work were central to both the post-war construction and the late-twentieth century critique of national income.

Hidden in Plain Sight: Unpaid Household Services and the Politics of GDP Measurement

Gross Economic-Ecological Product As an Integrated Measure for Ecological Service and Economic Products

Target-Based GDP Manipulation: Evidence from China

How GDP spread to China: the experimental diffusion of macroeconomic measurement

Estimating the Mental Wealth of nations: valuing social production and investment

GDP, wellbeing, and health: thoughts on the 2017 round of the International Comparison Program

Online Appendix of “Starving and Deceiving? How Disasters Reshape Politicians’ Incentives to Lie”

Outside the Economy: Women’s Work and Feminist Economics in the Construction and Critique of National Income Accounting

Measuring Genuine Progress: An Example from the UN Millennium Development Goals

Ghost of GDP: Sponge, Myth or Moustache Twitching?

How Government Statistics Adjust for Potential Biases from Quality Change and New Goods in an Age of Digital Technologies: A View from the Trenches

Beyond GDP: a review and conceptual framework for measuring sustainable and inclusive wellbeing

Does GDP measure growth in the economy or simply growth in the money supply?

GDP Spatialization in the Coastal Area of China Based on Multi-Sensor Remote Sensing Data and Land Use Data

Research on Some Statistical Issues Related with GDP

A new approach to measuring green GDP: a cross-country analysis

Estimation Of Gross Domestic Product Using Multi-Sensor Remote Sensing Data: A Case Study In Zhejiang Province, East China

A new database on Green GDP; 1970-2019: a framework for assessing the green economy

Fundamental implications of the neglect of servicisation by development economists

A review of limitations of GDP and alternative indices to monitor human wellbeing and to manage eco-system functionality

National accounting from the bottom up using large-scale financial transactions data: An application to input-output tables