A Review of the In Vivo Evidence Investigating the Role of Nitrite Exposure from Processed Meat Consumption in the Development of Colorectal Cancer

William Crowe,Christopher T Elliott,Brian D Green,Christopher T. Elliott,Brian D. Green
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/nu11112673
IF: 5.9
2019-11-05
Nutrients
Abstract:The World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF) 2007 stated that the consumption of processed meat is a convincing cause of colorectal cancer (CRC), and therefore, the public should avoid it entirely. Sodium nitrite has emerged as a putative candidate responsible for the CRC-inducing effects of processed meats. Sodium nitrite is purported to prevent the growth of Clostridium botulinum and other food-spoiling bacteria, but recent, contradictory peer-reviewed evidence has emerged, leading to media reports questioning the necessity of nitrite addition. To date, eleven preclinical studies have investigated the effect of consuming nitrite/nitrite-containing meat on the development of CRC, but the results do not provide an overall consensus. A sizable number of human clinical studies have investigated the relationship between processed meat consumption and CRC risk with widely varying results. The unique approach of the present literature review was to include analysis that limited the human studies to those involving only nitrite-containing meat. The majority of these studies reported that nitrite-containing processed meat was associated with increased CRC risk. Nitrite consumption can lead to the formation of N-nitroso compounds (NOC), some of which are carcinogenic. Therefore, this focused perspective based on the current body of evidence links the consumption of meat containing nitrites and CRC risk.
nutrition & dietetics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationship between the consumption of processed meat products containing nitrite and the development of colorectal cancer (CRC). Specifically, the paper aims to evaluate the role of nitrite as a potentially carcinogenic component in processed meat products and analyze its impact on human health. The paper explores this issue by reviewing existing in - vivo evidence, especially those studies specifically examining the relationship between processed meat products containing nitrite and CRC risk. ### Background of the paper - **Definition of processed meat products**: Processed meat products refer to meats that have been treated by means of curing, fermentation, salting, smoking, etc., in order to extend the shelf life or improve the flavor. - **The role of nitrite**: Nitrite is an effective preservative that can prevent the growth of pathogenic bacteria such as Clostridium botulinum, and at the same time can enhance the color and flavor of processed meat products. - **Nitrite and N - nitroso compounds**: The intake of nitrite may lead to the formation of endogenous N - nitroso compounds (NOC), some of which are carcinogenic. ### Research purposes - **Evaluate the carcinogenic potential of nitrite**: By reviewing existing clinical and pre - clinical studies, evaluate whether nitrite is the main cause of CRC caused by processed meat products. - **Analyze the consistency of research results**: Explore the differences in results between different studies and try to explain the reasons for these differences. - **Provide scientific basis**: Provide a scientific basis for public health policies, especially in terms of consumption recommendations for processed meat products. ### Methods - **Literature search**: Use three databases, PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science, for literature search. Keywords include "colorectal cancer", "CRC", "processed meat products", "sausage", "bacon", "nitrite" and "N - nitroso compounds". - **Inclusion and exclusion criteria**: Inclusion criteria include full - text availability, written in English, human studies containing single or multiple colorectal cancer measurement indicators. Exclusion criteria include reviews and technical reports, studies using only in - vitro techniques. ### Results - **Pre - clinical studies**: A total of 11 pre - clinical studies explored the impact of processed meat products containing nitrite on the development of CRC, but the results were inconsistent. Some studies found that nitrite exposure increased the risk of CRC, while other studies did not find a significant association. - **Clinical studies**: A total of 49 human studies explored the relationship between processed meat products and CRC. Among them, 23 studies found that processed meat products were associated with an increased risk of CRC, 25 studies did not find a significant association, and 1 study found that processed meat products had a protective effect on CRC. ### Conclusions - **Methodological differences**: There are methodological inconsistencies in pre - clinical studies, such as the lack of dose - response studies and the heterogeneity of animal models. - **Importance of human studies**: Although pre - clinical studies provide valuable information, the results of human studies are more important because they more directly reflect the situation in real life. - **Future research directions**: Future research should focus on spontaneous CRC models, such as ApcMin mice, and explore the synergistic effects of other potentially carcinogenic components in processed meat products. In general, this paper attempts to evaluate the potential impact of nitrite in processed meat products on the development of CRC by systematically reviewing existing in - vivo evidence, and provide a scientific basis for public health policies.