The hidden value of in-between spaces for children’s self-directed play within outdoor school environments

Fatemeh Aminpour,Kate Bishop,Linda Corkery

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2019.103683

IF: 8.119

2020-02-01

Landscape and Urban Planning

Abstract:Despite the important role of outdoor school environments in children's recess, school ground design does not often manage to support children's self-directed play. This paper argues for the value of so called 'in-between spaces' for children in outdoor school environments that has not been studied sufficiently from their perspectives. Employing a socio-ecological framework, this participatory qualitative study used three methods to identify the multiple environmental characteristics of in-between spaces that support children's self-directed play. Sixty behaviour mapping sessions, 78 walking tours, and 18 focus groups were completed with children aged 8–10 during school recess. The context–sensitive data were collected in three public primary school grounds in Sydney, Australia. Using inductive thematic analysis, the physical, social and organisational characteristics of children's chosen in-between spaces were identified. The results revealed that children's preferred in-between spaces included small enclosures, edges and natural settings with affordances supporting their self-directed play. These spaces offered children an opportunity to redress gender imbalance and mitigate the impact of overcrowding, problems that often inhibited children's self-directed play in the formal spaces of school grounds. Despite children's interest in in-between spaces, they were not valued in school grounds and were often characterised as out-of-bounds where children were not allowed during the recess time. The discussion argues for the value of in-between spaces where children can find the support of all the environmental characteristics to operate their self-directed play. School design and school policy should recognise these spaces for their spatial value for children's play in schools.

environmental studies,ecology,geography, physical,regional & urban planning,urban studies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: although the outdoor school environment plays an important role in children's recess, the current school site design often fails to fully support children's self - directed play. In particular, the so - called "in - between spaces", the value of these spaces for children's self - directed play has not been fully studied from the perspective of children. This article explores the multiple environmental characteristics (physical, social and organizational characteristics) of these "in - between spaces" and their supporting role for children's self - directed play through the social - ecological framework. Specifically, the paper aims to:

1. **Identify the environmental characteristics of "in - between spaces"**: Through participatory qualitative research methods, identify multiple environmental characteristics of "in - between spaces" that support children's self - directed play.
2. **Highlight the value of "in - between spaces"**: Reveal how these spaces provide support for children, especially in terms of gender balance and alleviating congestion problems that are difficult to achieve in formal spaces.
3. **Call for recognition in school design and policy**: Propose that school design and policy should recognize the importance of "in - between spaces" in supporting children's self - directed play and provide appropriate spatial value for them.

The paper collected behavioral data of children during recess in three public primary schools in Sydney through methods such as behavior mapping, walking interviews and focus group discussions, thereby in - depth analyzing the physical, social and organizational characteristics of these "in - between spaces".