The Roman Empire and its Germanic Peoples . By Herwig Wolfram. Translated by Thomas Dunlap. Berkeley: University of California Press. 1997. Originally published as Das Reich und die Germanen. Berlin: Siedler Verlag. 1990. Pp. xx + 361. $39.95. ISBN 0-520-08511-6.
M. Salzman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/156916100746338
IF: 0.5199
2000-06-01
Central European History
Abstract:The translation of Herwig Wolframs Das Reich und die Germanen provides for the English speaking public a wide-ranging, synthetic description of the interaction of the Germanic peoples and the Romans from the third to the eighth centuries E. C. This confusing succession of Germanic tribes and their tangled relations with the Romans are brilliantly set within a historical and theoretical framework based on the idea that the Germans were not strongly defined tribes who overran the Roman Empire. Yet the present volume offers the reader a challenge. The methodological and theoretical bases for Wolfram's approach set out in the first two chapters are, unfortunately, far too elliptical and dense to be easily understood. One must turn to Wolfram's other works to get a full discussion of a concept of key importance to this book, ethnogenesis, a word that does not here even appear in the index. (A more recent short volume, Die Germanen, appeared in 1995 and provides a better introduction to this idea as well.) For Wolfram, ethnogenesis is the process whereby the barbarians of late antiquity came together to identify themselves as an ethnic group. In his view, the barbarians were not originally tribes, but armed groups of men who served the empire. Their profession gave them their mobility. As these heterogeneous people came together to serve, the successful military king (reiks, rex) and his army and nobles would attract followers. But to attract even more men, the barbarian kings and nobles told stories derived from non-Roman sources about their royal lineage and descent from the pagan gods. These myths, combined with military success, augmented the appeal of the military king and his nobles. In time, as these groups settled within an area and attracted locals, these stories turned into migration myths. In this way, the armed group developed an ethnic identity; full ethnogenesis had occured. Wolfram's conceptualization of ethnogenesis is important, for it, along with the work of scholars like Wenskus, has transformed scholarly notions of the "barbarian invasions and migrations" in the late empire. These were not the destructive movements of foreigners who brought on the decline of Rome, but the product of Roman culture interacting with groups within its territories. Wolfram's view also lies behind the present book, in which he devotes chapters 5 through 14 to an analysis of the political and military fates of each of the Germanic peoples from their mythical/legendary genesis into late antiquity. Yet the reader interested in the components of ethnogenesis finds a far
History,Art