The Epistemological Significance of Comparing Social and Scientific Approaches to Minority Languages in France and Spain

Christian Lagarde
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-24340-1_4
2019-01-01
Abstract:Initially, the article provides a comparative assessment of the linguistic policies carried out in two neighboring states, which correspond to divergent levels of centralism. Then linguistic provisions in the existing constitutional texts (the Constitution in France 1958; in Spain – 1978) and other legal provisions are examined. The result is a comparative picture of legal concepts that characterize the plurality of languages and, specially, minority languages of the two countries: official/state language, native language/regional language, patrimonial language. From the French side, a disorderly policy is carried out in the face of the concept; from the Spanish side it is quite fuzzy, but simultaneous and stratified. Therefore sociolinguistic national history is very important, both in identifying the categories of the languages and in implementing policies in this sector.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?