Challenges in capstone project supervision by academic faculty: A case study
Avihai Shurin,,Shraga Shoval,Nitza Davidovitch,,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.33495/jerr_v11i4.23.114
2023-05-05
Journal of Educational Research and Reviews
Abstract:Supervision of capstone projects in engineering programs is an interdisciplinary challenge, for both students and Faculty. The project considered the highlight of the undergraduate program, summarizes all the knowledge students have accumulated throughout their studies and aims to train them for the challenges of graduate engineers. Although the project is usually perceived as leading to successful products and learning outcomes, pedagogical disparities are emerging, emphasizing a deep need for change. This study examines the essence of capstone supervision in Mechanical Engineering, the faculty’s role within it, and stakeholders’ perception, using questionnaires, semi-structured interviews, participant observation, and analysis of primary sources. The study reveals that in contrast to the significance of supervision found to stakeholders, Faculty are under considerable pressure and perceive the significance of supervision as low, and as a time-consuming task, without proper compensation. The current processes show significant pedagogical disparities and limitations, resulting in low interest from academic supervisors. In addition, the academic institution was found to have dissatisfaction with the faculty’s supervision, even though there are no clear definitions or guiding methods for the supervisors. Accordingly, academic institutions must create greater motivation, interest, and compensation among Faculty. It is necessary to reduce the load on supervisors and to foster independent functioning by students. Effective supervision is essential for success and student development, which requires a deep need for proper preparation and training Faculty to be supervisors. Desired learning outcomes should be updated in order to optimally prepare the students for their future role, and maintain the relevance of academic institutions. Keywords: Capstone project supervision, final project in engineering, supervisor-lecturer, engineering education, engineering faculty, instructional methods (syn: pedagogy), faculty training.