Abstract:This study examined the alignment and predictive power of instructional practices as reported by teachers, students, and external raters by using the Shanghai data that included 85 teachers and 2,613 students who participated in the Global Teaching Insights study. Results from exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis along with ordinary least square regression indicate that the same four conceptual components including classroom discourse (e.g., allowing students to explain their ideas and engage in peer discussions), meaning-making (e.g., explaining why a mathematical procedure works), cognitive activation (e.g., encouraging students’ critical thinking in solving complex tasks), and clarity instruction (e.g., teachers’ giving clear explanation of subject matter) were identified in the instructional practices reported by teachers and their students. The cognitive activation factor in the data reported by teachers emerged as the most significant predictor of students’ post-test scores, whereas the classroom discourse factor in the data reported by students accounted for the largest portion of variance in students’ post-test scores. Furthermore, our analysis revealed that the alignment between ratings reported by students and external raters was the highest, and student ratings of their mathematics teachers’ instructional practices demonstrated the highest predictive power for students’ post-test scores. Results of this study provide important empirical evidence for the merit of cognitive activation and classroom discourse in mathematics teaching and inspire researchers, practitioners, and policy-makers to pay careful attention to student-reported instructional practices that can serve as a better source of data in measuring mathematics teaching quality.

Examining discourse structures in Chinese and U.S. elementary mathematics classes

Comparing perceived and observed instructional practices and their predictive power for student mathematics achievement: An analysis of Shanghai data from OECD global teaching inSights

Exploring the Association between Learning Approaches and Classroom Learning Behaviors Presented by Chinese and American Undergraduates

Relations of Instructional Tasks to Teacher–Student Discourse in Mathematics Classrooms of Chinese Primary Schools

Changes in Instructional Tasks and Their Influence on Classroom Discourse in Reformed Mathematics Classrooms of Chinese Primary Schools

“Shh!”: Shifting discourse patterns and techniques of surveillance in middle-school mathematics classrooms

A Brief Comparison of the U.S. and Chinese Middle School Mathematics Programs

What is Effective Classroom Dialog? A Comparative Study of Classroom Dialog in Chinese Expert and Novice Mathematics Teachers’ Classrooms

The magnitude representations of fractions of Chinese students: evidence from behavioral experiment and eye-tracking

Chinese primary school mathematics teachers working in a centralised curriculum system: a case study of two primary schools in North‐East China

Gender Gap in Mathematics and Physics in Chinese Middle Schools: A Case Study of a Beijing’s District

A Comparative Analysis of the Distributive Property in U.S. and Chinese Elementary Mathematics Textbooks

Gender differences in mathematics academic performance of high school students in western China

Examining the Relationship Between Teachers’ Instructional Practices and Students’ Mathematics Achievement

Understanding Chinese mathematics teaching: how secondary mathematics teachers’ beliefs and knowledge influence their teaching in mainland China

Development and validation of a sensitive liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry method for quantitation of flavopiridol in plasma enables accurate estimation of pharmacokinetic parameters with a clinically active dosing schedule.

US and Chinese elementary teachers’ noticing of cross-cultural mathematics videos

An Examination of the Implementation of Mathematics Lessons in a Chinese Kindergarten Classroom in the Setting of Standards Reform

Individual Differences in Fourth-Grade Math Achievement in Chinese and English

Developing written discourse knowledge in whole language and code emphasis classrooms

Effect of the flipped classroom on the mathematics performance of middle school students