Exergaming Executive Functions: An Immersive Virtual Reality-Based Cognitive Training for Adults Aged 50 and Older

Kuo-Ting Huang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1089/cyber.2019.0269
2020-03-01
Abstract:Prior research suggests that both exergaming and virtual reality (VR)-based training programs could improve executive functions in older adults. However, few studies investigated whether combining exergaming with VR would be more effective. This study seeks to (a) investigate whether playing exergames in an immersive virtual environment (IVE) would yield differential outcomes in selected executive functions, including inhibition, task switching, and working, and (b) examine the role of feeling of presence as a potential mediator between immersive exergaming and cognitive improvement in specific domains. Thirty-three participants over 50 years of age (mean age = 62) participated in a 4-week training program and were randomly assigned into an IVE and non-IVE to play an exergame (Fruit Ninja) for eight sessions within 4 weeks. The results revealed a significant effect of the IVE on the Stroop Test and Trail Making Test after the 4-week training. Furthermore, the impacts of the IVE exergaming on these two tasks were mediated by the feeling of presence. These findings suggested that the immersive experience of exergaming would elicit the feeling of presence, which later contributes to improved cognitive performances in inhibition and task switching. For the theoretical implications, this study extends previous research by showing that (a) feeling of presence could contribute to older adults' cognitive improvement, and (b) the impacts of immersive exergame training on executive functions vary across individual domains. Additionally, this study provides practical implications such that the design of exergames could emphasize the game features requiring mental simulation, which can serve as a novel strategy for preventing cognitive decline in midlife and old age.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: whether the combination of exergaming and immersive virtual reality (IVE) can more effectively improve the executive functions of adults over 50 years old, especially inhibitory control, task - switching and working memory. Specifically, the research aims to explore two main issues: 1. **Explore whether exergaming in an immersive virtual environment will bring different executive function improvement effects**: - Researchers hope to understand whether playing exergaming in an immersive virtual environment can improve specific executive functions (such as inhibitory control, task - switching and working memory) more than playing the same game in a non - immersive environment. 2. **Examine the role of "presence" as a potential mediating variable**: - Researchers further explore whether "presence" (i.e., the subjective experience of players feeling that they are in a virtual environment) mediates between immersive exergaming and cognitive improvement. In other words, researchers want to verify whether presence enhances the cognitive performance of players, thus leading to better executive function improvement. ### Specific research hypotheses - **H1**: Individuals who play exergaming in an immersive virtual environment will have better improvements in inhibitory control, task - switching and working memory than those who play the same game in a non - immersive virtual environment. - **H2**: Presence will mediate the relationship between VR exergaming and specific executive functions (such as inhibitory control, task - switching and working memory). ### Research background As people age, the cognitive functions of the elderly may gradually decline, especially executive functions. Previous studies have shown that exergaming and virtual reality training programs can improve the cognitive functions of the elderly. However, there are few studies on the combination of exergaming and virtual reality, and these studies have not yet determined whether this combination can more effectively improve cognitive functions. Therefore, this study fills this gap through experimental design and further explores the role of immersion in it. ### Brief description of methods The study adopted a randomized controlled experimental design and recruited a total of 33 participants aged 50 and above. Participants were randomly assigned to the immersive virtual environment group (IVE) and the non - immersive virtual environment group (non - IVE) and underwent 4 - week exergaming training. The changes in participants' executive functions were evaluated through pre - and post - tests, and their presence experiences were measured using questionnaires. ### Brief description of results The results showed that participants who played exergaming in the immersive virtual environment had significant improvements in inhibitory control and task - switching, while there was no significant difference in working memory. In addition, presence did mediate the positive impact of immersive exergaming on inhibitory control and task - switching, but had no significant mediating effect on working memory. In conclusion, this study not only verifies the positive impact of immersive virtual reality exergaming on the executive functions of the elderly, but also reveals the important role of presence in it, providing new strategies and theoretical bases for preventing cognitive decline in the elderly in the future.