Evaluation of appendicitis risk prediction models in adults with suspected appendicitis

A. Bhangu,D Nepogodiev,JH Matthews,GL Morley,DN Naumann,A Ball,P Chauhan,S Bhanderi,I Mohamed,JC Glasbey,RJW Wilkin,TM Drake,J Clements,NS Blencowe,PJJ Herrod,F Pata,M Frasson,R Blanco‐Colino,AS Soares,A Bhangu,D Nepogodiev,A Bhangu,JH Matthews,GL Morley,S Bhanderi,A Ball,P Chauhan,S Jain,I Mohamed,T Amuthalingam,R Tyler,JC Glasbey,RJW Wilkin,F Pata,M Frasson,R Blanco‐Colino,AS Soares,A Bhangu,D Nepogodiev,EA Griffiths,TD Pinkney,O Gee,DG Morton,A Beggs,D Beral,A Bhangu,NS Blencowe,D Bowley,N Cruickshank,I Daniels,E Griffiths,ST Hornby,JN Lund,P Marriott,TD Pinkney,P Singh,NJ Smart,D Speake,C Thompson,J Torkington,A Torrance,R Vohra,O Warren,RJW Wilkin,DC Winter,F Pata,G Pellino,A Sgrò,A Simioni,V Farina,M Podda,S Di Saverio,A Birindelli,S Pasquali,ITSurg,AS Soares,PT Surg,R Blanco‐Colino,M Frasson,NS Blencowe,W Bolton,CJ Bradshaw,CS Chean,G Harris,JB Haddow,NB Jamieson,S McCain,J Mason,D Milgrom,GR Nana,Noor Mohamed,JO Brien,JCH Pearce,M Rabie,K Sahnan,P Sarmah,C Skerritt,MA Ghazanfar,L Sreedharan,S Kabwama,Gray,IW Kamande,S Nazarian,FA Dar,AT Misky,S Arunachalam,CS Twum‐Barima,IM Mohamed,KL Connor,PO Coe,A Kosti,M Elshaer,DA Colvin,MP Charalambous,KTD Yeung,LAG Merker,TEM Morrison,AJ Thaventhiran,TM Gilbert,JM Clements,G Hicks,S Afshar,NC Mckinley,N Assaf,T Hanna,EGE Macinnes,N Thavanesan,AS Dubois,LK Palani‐Velu,S Tezas,LPS Yow,RW Radwan,NB Jamieson,M Abdelrahman,KA Lee,Z A Zarka,NA Mcdowall,CY Tan,ML Venn,DL Ashmore,Whitehorn,AM Golder,A Reddy,C Delimpalta,OH Kay,P Sarmah,SM Shah,I Eiben,C Doyle,V Tudyka,E Issa,H West,HK Brewer,EZ Farrow,NS Taylor,CJ Smart,NP Griffiths,C Halkias,P Vitish‐Sharma,Knight,NG Mowbray,JB Olivier,KJ Lee,KD Clement,DRR Chrastek,N Panda,MJ Connor,Fahmy,ES Bryan,WS Ngu,SO Adegbola,EM Vaughan,W Stupalkowska,LFC Simmonds,A Malik,A Hussein,MJ Karim,T Singhal,R Ormiston,D Nepogodiev,VWS Kung,MA Rabie,JH Park,N Lal,D Worku,M D'Auria,A Ang,M Orizu,E Gammeri,ECS Clough,CH Choy,PJJ Herrod,S Lawday,AJ Hann,D Robinson,Wardle,D Mcdonnell,DG Rutherford,LM Hickey,AG Garg,S Rezvani,CR Bell,F Mahmood,S Rehman,G Donaldson,A Peleki,L Pearce,OL Sharp,S Jain,S Singh,DB Thompson,O El‐Tayar,M Hollyman,Rupasinghe,DB Toomey,MP Murray,N Amtul,RJ Mersh,RC Newton,W Al‐Khyatt,GF Stephens,SH Abbas,Iqbal,CE Brown,S Renshaw,KA Hureibi,UP Pullabatla‐Venkata,N O Donohoe,A Myatt,RJ Egan,K Rangarajan,M Trail,SC Mckay,NFT Engall,E Jerome,DC Townsend,BY Patel,S Pronin,N Chandratreya,JH Choong,TM Mohamed,NJ Hudson‐Peacock,R Manson,S Bhanderi,KRM Hebbar,BS Mothe,CR Weegenaar,M Saad,CR Bowman,F Serventi,F Fleres,C Foppa,G Pata,G Baronio,D Pertile,A Lucchi,A Sagnotta,I Maretto,T Campagnaro,M Gatti,EGJ Gjoni,F Roscio,M Inama,F Coccolini,A Sgrò,F Colombo,A Avanzolini,S Aresu,A De‐Manzoni‐Garberini,DA Merlini,A Chessa,N Tamini,S Mulas,N Cillara,D Coletta,J Atzeni,E Erdas,G Gallo,E Francone,P Di Gioia,A Birindelli,CL Bianchi,F Ferrara,A Biancafarina,M Podda,S Scabini,L Marano,A Miegge,D Sasia,G Savino,F Pata,M Scatizzi,FE D'Amico,GA Arcuri,L Gavagna,G Salamone,F Tatulli,E Goldin,ML Matos,Caldeira,J Romano,J Pereira,JGM Azevedo,JM Azevedo,JFF Simoes,ACQ Silva,AS Soares,DP O'Leary,ND Kennedy,EM Quinn,AY Zhang,PM Neary,JA De‐Marchi,BR O'Connor,K Wijesundera,NM Foley,J Wong,ND Kennedy,LA Tiedt,JC Bolger,TM Connelly,OS Ahmed,V Vigorita,V García,J Arredondo,E Redondo,B Sainz,I Aldrey,A Landaluce‐Olavarria,A De Andrés Gómez,E Cordoba,MN Sánchez‐Fuentes,C Cerdán‐Santacruz,J Beltran‐De‐Heredia,MTGM García,T Veres,A García‐Novoa,A Melero Abellán,L García‐Catalá,M Ruiz‐Marín,P Menendez,S Roldán‐Ortiz,JA Navas‐Cuéllar,D Sabia,JC Gomez‐Rosado,M Serrano Navidad,C Caula,ER Sanchez,E Espin‐Basany,D Fernández‐Martínez,AF Bravo‐Gutiérrez,C Payá‐Llorente,P Dujovne,F Lima,V Soria‐Aledo,CJ Gomez,I Pascual‐Miguelañez,M Muinelo,C Magadan Alvarez,HJ Vargas‐Pierola,M Vallve‐Bernal,JM Hidalgo‐Rosas,JJ Arenal‐Vera,F Sena‐Ruiz,L Sanchez‐Guillen,P Villarejo‐Campos,L Tallon‐Aguilar,A Garcea,JM Bennett,L Whittaker,AL Gidwani,CK Byrnes,SMF Saunders,MH Shiwani,N Ashraf,AK Venkatasubramaniam,KE Bevan,D Mcarthur,AK Mustafa,JP Griffith,JM Blazeby,A Charalabopoulos,W Campbell,G Reese,OJ Warren,M Peacock,D Menzies,D Jenner,NJ Eardley,S Yoong,M Abulafi,H Avalapati,R Thompson,P Nastro,R Kochupapy,D Beral,BM Stubbs,R McIntyre,J Crozier,PK Patel,V Pento,WD Beasley,CSD Roxburgh,ST Hornby,H Youssef,R Alexander,S Denley,F Di Franco,A Quddus,A Saha,I Hunter,JAF Hannay,A Reddy,VR Velchuru,GEL Bond‐Smith,Y Salama,A Bhargava,SP Panagiotopoulos,N Watson,V Tudyka,G Garcea,AP Boddy,PG Dunning,Geraint Lloyd,SV Gurjar,CJ Smart,J Hill,B Andrews,A Singh,F Ruzvidzo,G Shingler,D Mahon,S Elgaddal,CJ Payne,IA Shaikh,S Dalmia,Nair,JG Finch,KS Chapple,S Bawa,J Watfah,CA Carden,R Makhija,M Rao,J Sarveswaran,V Vijay,S Rekhraj,T Singhal,B Knight,TD Pinkney,MN Siddiqui,JF Sebastian,P Glen,S Vakis,H Ebied,R Vohra,R Rajaram,J Gray,D Mcgrath,G Faulkner,S Gopalswamy,JN Lund,NJ Smart,M Varcada,A Woodward,GL Williams,K Szentpali,R Ravindran,C Bronder,MA Thaha,A Rate,V Daya Shetty,VSR Rao,Sajid,B Clements,Patel,C Mason,G Branagan,A Torrance,K Maude,G Kaur,A Lyons,P Ainsworth,R Hagger,AZ Zadi,SU Maslekar,J Kinross,S Irukulla,W Hawkins,S Wheatstone,T Magro,STR Bailey,G Marshall,J Mccullough,G Marangoni,EL Leung,CM Borg,S Gopinath,J Torkington,J Kirkby‐Bott,S Yalamarthi,S Mirza,M Brett,S Ramcharan,V Pandey,B Thava,D Speake,N Chandratreya,SM Andreani,SJ Sahay,B Aravind,M Downey,D Nicol,P Whitehouse,A Sharma,N Francis,P Chitsabesan,DJ Stewart,GG Norcia,E Cucinotta,F Cianchi,U Fumagalli Romario,L Taglietti,P Capelli,G Garulli,A Parisi,D Nitti,A Guglielmi,A Alonzo,IS Scandroglio,F Roscio,G Moretto,L Ansaloni,A Pietrabissa,D Foschi,N Vettoretto,G Ercolani,M Coppola,E Colangelo,E Morandi,A Chessa,N Tamini,P Niolu,M Pala,M Coletti,A Pisanu,A Nicolosi,G Sammarco,S Berti,P Soliani,V Tonini,CL Bianchi,M Stella,G Ceccarelli,C De Nisco,S Scabini,G Castagnoli,P De Nardi,F Borghi,F Agresta,A Benevento,S Cantafio,FE D'Amico,MC Cesari,M Rubbini,G Salamone,G Chetta,F De Marchi,MF Nora,HS Sousa,CA Nascimento,CAO Casimiro,SD Costa,MJ Rosa,NMD Carvalho,JCF Correia,AP Gomes,AD Hill,TN Walsh,MA Aremu,J Mulsow,S El‐Masry,J Gillick,J Garvin,M Caldwell,B Mehigan,DC Winter,CB Peirce,F Cooke,K Mealy,A Ruano,G Ais,J Fueyo,E Redondo,B Sainz,AE Parajó,A Landaluce‐Olavarria,JC Bernal‐Sprekelsen,E Cordoba,JA Monzón‐Abad,C Cerdán‐Santacruz,F Blanco,T Veres,A Melero Abellán,A Arroyo,M Ruiz‐Marín,P Menendez,MC Bazán‐Hinojo,JA Navas‐Cuéllar,MI Ramos‐Bernado,JA Lopez‐Ruiz,T Golda,D Julià,MM Cuadrado,E Espin‐Basany,D Fernández‐Martínez,AF Bravo‐Gutiérrez,Gómez‐Abril,P Dujovne,J Martinez,JL Aguayo,M Millan,M Alvarez‐Gallego,M Muinelo‐Lorenzo,JI Martin Parra,E Muñoz‐Muñoz,PE González De Chaves‐Rodríguez,G Cánovas‐Moreno,M Rodriguez‐Lopez,JJ Segura‐Sampedro,A García‐Granero,FJ Redondo‐Calvo,L Tallon‐Aguilar,A Garcea,S Dyson,D Thakur,L Sreedharan,C Swords,O Siaw,M Zelazek,R Woo,A Badran,N Aruparayil,P Christopoulos,B Chambers,N O'Neill,RH Long,Gray,P Mccaughey,MJ Lynch Wong,RS Mccain,HC Lennox‐Warburton,C Moore,KM Manektella,IW Kamande,S Mcilwaine,S Rupani,DJ Simpson,J Wauchope,M Ng,L Christian,A Crone,JB Haddow,R Sacks,S Nazarian,NRA Symons,A Lazzaro,SD Patil,FA Dar,S Roomi,I Silva,JM Hodgson,C Ly,AT Misky,H Froud,H Patel,S Arunachalam,P Cay,RS Karwal,S Arunachalam,D Danquah‐Boateng,BJM Berry,HD Esmail,CS Twum‐Barima,H Maripi,D Bilku,MA McKelvie,K Miller,A Maina,R Velho,R Hasan,R Clingan,SMH Jah,K Waite,A Jones,S Buckley‐Jones,L Lecky‐Thompson,KL Connor,N Saghir,S Mansoor,D Mistry,R Brown,A Wong,S Gurung,F Wensley,TA Fleming,RKL Griggs,A Kosti,S Haines,S Bedoya,A Beverstock,J Johnson,M Elshaer,G Govind,O Niaz,DA Colvin,ARS Dyal,E Tokidis,S Punj,A Leusink,KTD Yeung,I Rudland,M Kelly,R Morgan,S Al‐Musawi,C Lek,A Gilbert,A Gosal,R Mahoney,I Parwaiz,TEM Morrison,MJ Mitchard,B Ribeiro,H Merai,EA Dean,S Khan,A Baginski,C Mann,W Foers,L Jones,B Woodward,DM Mcwhirter,AT Thomas,TG Gilbert,LW Weatherburn,JP Pilkington,FC Cameron,TM Gilbert,CS Chean,JM Clements,JD Clements,C Mccann,S Davidson,L Hackney,JS Clements,A Martin,G Hicks,DT Du,Z Shakoor,SK Yen,M Adnan,S Ranathunga,S Sana,YH Tay,MY Chin,M Gillespie,AG Brown,U Campbell,N Assaf,M Chatzikonstantinou,B Mahendran,T Flack,M Chowdhary,JM Lim,EGE Macinnes,E Whiteman,JA Shepherd,A Pedder,N Thavanesan,KL Siggens,CW Lai,V Morrison‐Jones,Z Hayat,AS Dubois,I Nehikhare,C Macleod,HC Quinn,A Brown,G Neagle,LK Palani‐Velu,SM Chok,FM Carrano,OA Abbassi,GA Divekar,S Halmer,LPS Yow,V Pento,RE Adams,PL Davies,SY Wong,R Amarasinghe,LE Tague,E Jones,RW Radwan,A Martin,E Jones,NB Jamieson,J Singh,K Boza,SD Kelly,F Morrison,W Hei Chan,NS Blencowe,M Abdelrahman,EJ Wilson,OO Awokoya,Griffiths,EN Kirkham,AE Cotton,A Adimonye,PA Leighton,KA Lee,A Abdelrahman,H Cartwright,Z Gates,M Miguras,ZA Zarka,K Khan,C Louw,T Grove,T Badenoch,J Mckeon,NA Mcdowall,CS Wood,RP Leitch,P Sgardelis,MI Perera,D Nagarajan,Y Malam,K Theodoropoulou,ML Venn,S Rajagopal,S Kaptanis,D Popova,O Olagbaiye,S Tayeh,S Rigby,DL Ashmore,MP Harris,Whitehorn,KZ Ren,G Liaw,S Zhou,F White,AM Golder,CM Marshall,JH Mitchell,DJ Anderson,V Kanakala,A Hollingsworth,KR Paramasevon,J Milward,S Ahmed,C Delimpalta,BF Fanibi,N Ferguson,EA Dickson,AV Shaw,OH Kay,F Dixon,S Morrish,R Dandy,P Fooks,P Sharma,N Islam,V Tabain,R Keegan,P Sarmah,J Ahel,T Alhammali,J Graveston,EJ Balai,J Graveston,SM Shah,K Rothnie,GP Pankin,IE Eiben,NJ Jackson,M Dhar,D Nash,C Doyle,S Dharamavaram,M Seth,F Chowdhury,M Rezacova,N Seneviratne,EJ Turner,C Currow,E Issa,JD Isherwood,BM Hobson,H West,DH Lui,GR Nana,V Rodger,N Ting,HK Brewer,D Photiou,EZ Farrow,D Taze,S Lodhia,L Earnshaw,K Kumar,A Neale,J Bastianpillai,M Cipparrone,A Barrie,NS Taylor,Z Nash,L Anandan,K Tailor,Z Vinnicombe,S Krivan,R Kuo,A Giorga,H Habib,K Malik,M Bogdan,FP Mahon‐Daly,MJ Athersmith,JA Strange,NP Griffiths,C Wheeler,L Summerfield,RA Khaw,O Ashour,E Iosif,M Fadel,K Gopalakrishnan,N Orme,S Williams,M Rashid,A Sultana,N Patel,Knight,R Pearson,T Yasin,V Bevan,NG Mowbray,B Al‐Sarireh,JB Olivier,M Brown,N Mohd,EE Howie,M Poudevigne,C Paget,H Rallage,K Chui,F Fawzi,S Layman,E Okorocha,GM Jama,P Orawiec,O Kouli,A Hassane,KD Clement,J Kilkenny,AA Devine,M Laurenson,I Slezak,T Barker,EYL Lau,M Limbada,J O'Brien,J Weaver,T Barker,N Panda,S Hajibandeh,J Shah,MM Mansour,Malik,S Davis,F Trew,SK Bandyopadhyay,K Dart,MJ Connor,S Guru‐Naidu,R Callan,MK Nair,M Alani,E Sezen,S Salim,Fahmy,J Shurlock,K Siddique,A Forouzanfar,R Brews,WS Ngu,A Acharya,A Jain,SO Adegbola,K Sahnan,PJ Tozer,J Warusavitarne,KM Emslie,O Collier‐Wakefield,P Sivaloganathan,C Dobson,M Elseedawy,EM Vaughan,W Stupalkowska,L McNally,M Williams,FH Motiwala,S Choi,A Ahmad Asmadi,D Burnside,A Everden,S Suriyakumar,L Sandu,DA Kent,J Bowen,LFC Simmonds,P Long,A Khair,A Malik,K Shah,L Phelan,R Pierre,AA Dhari,A Hussein,M Hoff,MJ Karim,S Nickson,T Setshwaelo,A Chalk,MJ Parkola,A Harlinska,TCW Chan,JG Dudek,R Rolph,M Allen,H Pollard,R Ormiston,R Gormely,H Finlayson,G Ljungqvist,C Peponis,JC Glasbey,R Tyler,MMA Rahman,S Dhesi,Noor Mohamed,F Arshad,RJW Wilkin,AR Faris,T Sooriyamoorthy,VWS Kung,EL Springate,W Barnieh,AS Patel,ZA Siddiqui,IA Chishti,J Ayube‐Brown,Rabie,L Blake,E Yardimci,S Nagendram,JH Park,GI Neophytou,L Henderson,MMH Farhan‐Alanie,CY Kong,R Ghazala,N Lal,J Evans,N Hussain,M Kabir,D Worku,I Hraishawi,M D'Auria,M Cox,JA Bailey,N Muhibullah,F Yanni,A Ang,M Orizu,R Stevenson,A Nair,C Murphy,O Mcgucken,E Gammeri,R Pandya,H Bowerman,G Lafaurie,GI Van Boxel,K Shanmugarajah,D Maragouthakis,Z Hanif,JD Evans,S Yoganathan,TD Richardson,CH Choy,V Cook,GL Clark,B Rigney,E O'Neill,J Guliani,PJJ Herrod,D Chan,F Harper,T Sian,C Boereboom,JEM Blackwell,E Hardy,H Boyd‐Carson,DG Couch,CA Barter,Thoukididou,Hatt,CS Jones,S Dean,N Rajaretnam,S Lawday,M Masood,N Thakral,D Griffith,C Doherty,A Longshaw,D Peprah,G Mathew,AJ Hann,A Hook,D Robinson,J Vance‐Daniel,YMS Ibrahim,Wardle,KJ Walters,HE Whewell,MA Sherif,M Mckenna,JCH Pearce,D O'Sullivan,C Woodrow,S Gill,A Johnstone,R Gentry,R Irwin,A Forgie,S Welsh,LM Hickey,P Ivey,JK Bullivant,WJ English,A Osterberg,A Morowala,Z Al‐Faham,S Islam,E Tan,AG Garg,S Sadek,N Sihra,D Shrestha,B Chong,A Nadeem,JA Fasuyi,MM Patel,R Daureeawoo,B Okekunle,M Cheruvu,E Mazumdar,F Mahmood,A Hussain,C Patel,M Mcquaid,A Banks,A Robinson,Khan,W Riaz,M Verroiotou,JA Cohen,E Kouroumpas,S Rehman,G Donaldson,I Ghaffari,J Moradzadeh,A Peleki,M Kamal,M Gulamhussein,L Pearce,E Gaines,S Ghatorae,S Clark,OL Sharp,A Savill,B Hutchinson,J Chapman,F Wu,W Creasy,M Raymond,S Grosvenor,A Odeh,Y Malik,H Bansal,C Grant,A Raofi,B Ahmed,D Mai,DB Thompson,JEH Souter,RN Hamelmann,S Ikram,O El‐Tayar,A De‐Manzoni‐Garberini,M Hollyman,M Durbacz,N Gilliland,A Salem,D Chudek,Rupasinghe,N Ladwa,R Storey,C Fontaine,D Toomey,B Miller,A Robinson,M Oakey,H Smoker,N Amtul,SJ Chapman,SC O'Hagan,W Tahir,GJA Wilcox,A Ahmad,F Akram,TS Baddams,PR Boshier,M Fehervari,S Easdon,RJ Mersh,T Ilozue,ME Adam,RC Newton,S Jokhan,A Foster,K Nambiar,P Bohra,S Janardanan,V Shanmuganathan,F Maqboul,C Ettles,SD Wardle,E Martinou,GF Stephens,A Khasria,R Bagga,D Motter,N Mundkur,Y Pan,SH Abbas,K Akbari,SM Farrell,A Rahim,A Gummaraju,Iqbal,A Mahmoud,O Akinsola,N Smallcombe,M Tarazi,C Hanley,CE Brown,UM Campbell,NC Mckinley,S Renshaw,D Franklin,Davidson,KA Hureibi,SS Raza,A Krishnamoorthy,Y Rajjoub,M Ali,TC Seddon,RE Payne,A Das,LM Martin,KN Naismith,UP Pullabatla Venkata,VM Manda,N O Donohoe,KM Burns,J Huang,M Samuel,JA Docherty,WL Cheah,R Ooi,M Nyeko‐Lacek,L Marsh,A Prideaux,CH Li,A Poacher,M Lee,M Muzaffar,RJ Egan,A Kara,E Walsh,A Kara,H Sunter,NPG Roth,C Roy,D Mcmorran,A Turnbull,M Trail,GR Layton,JE Archer,P Yang,NFT Engall,L Henderson,E Douka,V Amin,K Borghol,P Marriott,DC Townsend,OD Blackford,S Bond,B Baker,WO Mohamed,R Williams,J Garnham,BY Patel,HD Robb,J Allington,L Cloney,A Tamborska,K Kalia,EJM Fung,Z Johnston,L Lynch,A Christides,HL Tan,G Cynthia,B Tsang,C Rossi,M Kaubrys,N Al‐Khafaji,M Jenkins,JH Choong,SM Chok,GB Peiris,TM Mohamed,S Gunning,E Nimako,D Pandya,P Hever,A Amayo,C Bull,NJ Hudson‐Peacock,C Clements,M Al‐Sheikh,F Savioli,M Long,E Horsfield,C Robertson,S Ogboru,AC Mcilwrath,S Bhanderi,S Bailey,J Bell,KRM Hebbar,C Limb,N Obeid,JE Rich,A Balasubramaniam,BS Mothe,R Mashar,M Taylor,Schuster Bruce,CR Weegenaar,G Dennison,NJ Curtis,M Saad,E Ezerska,B Ellis,M Brown,S Wiggill,A Tee,S Ng,CFW Carder,A Abdelwahed,CR Bowman,SB Chandler,BJ Tinsley,G Savino,E Finotti,F Serventi,G Occhioni,F Cossu,I Vulcano,F Viscosi,G Pata,G Baronio,M Michelini,B Compagnoni,C Sepe,SM Isolani,G Regina,D Pertile,A Lucchi,V Alagna,G Martorelli,C Gabbianelli,P Moroni,M Zuin,S Conci,T Campagnaro,G Lazzari,D Costamagna,JH Choong,TZ Zurleni,MA Altomare,EGJ Gjoni,J Desiderio,A Sagnotta,A Di Cintio,A Gemini,S Trastulli,FM Carrano,CE Brown,E Viviani,M Inama,F Coccolini,M Tomasoni,G Montori,A Sgrò,G Harder,F Argenti,S Malabarba,P Checcacci,P Montanelli,F Guerra,I Skalamera,F Staderini,S Grandi,T Nelli,F Coratti,L Sorrentino,A Maffioli,F Colombo,D Cavallo,A Bondurri,G Groppo,R Curti,L Solaini,A Xidas,S Aresu,T Manias,D Delogu,A Vacca,L Solinas,A De‐Manzoni‐Garberini,C Corbellini,L Fiore,A Nigro,L Santurro,M Angrisani,N Tamini,S Mulas,C Sparta,A Lorettu,FA Mura,GV Ruggiu,PF Pirari,R Pau,M Melis,F Piu,S Patti,A Deserra,N Cillara,D Coletta,D Angelieri,C Del Basso,D Rossi,I Iannone,C De Padua,C Giubilo,F Falaschi,B Cirillo,L Gordini,F Podda,S Sanna,E Erdas,A Saba,G Poillucci,E Pinna,A Messina,G Sena,G Sammarco,R Cardona,G Gallo,E De Luca,R Sacco,G Vescio,M Ammendola,R Romano,A Bianco,P Bonfante,L D'Ambra,C Feleppa,E Francone,A Gennai,V Lizzi,E Moggia,M Imperatore,S Bolzon,N Assaf,M Chatzikonstantinou,A Birindelli,A Belvedere,E Amaducci,MC Ripoli,E Segalini,M Cervellera,S Vaccari,CO Eretta,R O'Neill,O Llewelyn,NFT Engall,N Jones,F Clerici,M Ballabio,F Ferrara,E Andolfi,M Angelini,A Biancafarina,A Fontani,E Miranda,M Scricciolo,G Provenza,GA Pellicanò,F Pulighe,M Podda,G Argenio,A Melis,F Balestra,M Anania,A Cruccu,C Massaiu,ML Murru,A Martino,AP Luzzi,G La Valle,S Scabini,CI Zapana Chillitupa,A Bartoli,D Conti,L Marano,A Spaziani,R Bellochi,C Listorti,G Castagnoli,MC Salandini,A Miegge,P De Nardi,M Carlucci,F Pata,SM Tenconi,M Cannavò,D Sasia,A Marano,MC Giuffrida,G Cannata,L Pellegrino,G Giraudo,M Baraghini,A Garzi,R Giudicissi,T Zalla,L Romoli,A Vannucchi,I Giani,F Feroci,M Calussi,M Ribaudo,A Fiorot,T Stecca,FE D'Amico,C Nistri,C Fornasier,GA Arcuri,SV Valiani,DB Brunelli,LE Evoli,NG Giuliani,AC Contine,CR Renzi,CV Feo,G Anania,L Gavagna,P Carcoforo,F Aisoni,G Salamone,L Licari,R Tutino,G Cocorullo,V Silvestri,P De Marco,T Fontana,G Orlando,N Falco,M Baseggio,S Napetti,A Mella,GM Rossi,A Chimetto,E Goldin,M Cosci,M Bonomo,G Scialandrone,N Chetta,ML Matos,LC Carvalho,JS Magalhães,AM Pereira,C Fernandes,A Fareleira,D Gonçalves,M Pais,A Pereira,FM Resende,D Correia,D Cardoso,AFS Tojal,S Catarino Santos,LCS Barbosa,HC Louro,F Bairos,FM Martins,FM Messias,Ferreira,FC Borges,P Botelho,MJRT Lima,PM Valente,AA João,JM Guimarães,AS Soares,R Rocha,ST Nogueira,U Kabir,CLL Wong,LS Rahmani,S Tan,S Chng,B Jasinski,Cheng,S Mardhiah,K McGlynn,E Hannan,J Burke,ND Kennedy,Z Haveliwala,M O'Neill,M Boland,C Hayes,AMW Fox,A Zaborowski,RM Mitru,JA De‐Marchi,A Mc‐Dermott,D Coyle,I Stoica,SV McMahon,BR O'Connor,D Mc Laughlin,M Kannegieser‐Bailey,R Murphy,A Muntean,S Shet,L Thomas,S De Freitas,S Quill,A Aljorfi,NM Foley,BWT Soh,JJ Law,J Hartnett,T Jansen,JET Gilgan,J Jung,K Scanlon,A Szucs,J Wong,DP Ahern,AE Redmond,A Szucs,Edwards,LA Tiedt,P Manoharan,S Brennan,JC Bolger,AM Abdelgadir,KL Mckevitt,MA Zarog,G Ahmed,W Bukhari,A Ahad,OS Ahmed,M Paniagua,C Samartin,JC Primo,L Garrido,M Lopez,E Rufo,I Trostchansky,L Rodriguez,H Infante,A Acosta,P Cremades,A Cidoncha,V Olmos,I Oliva,C Santamaria,A Cavero,H Calvo,CA Suero,VM Maderuelo,P Galvez,A Hernando,I Eguaras,AC Recreo,M García‐Carrero,R Moreda,M García,U De Andres,E Del Pozo,M Calvo,C Navarro Moratalla,R Núñez Ronda,R Gómez Contreras,C Báez De Burgos,GF Valderas Cortés,C Cifre Martínez,A Rios Agudo,J Tárraga Soriano,XM Hernández Ramos,E Echazarreta,M Elia,A Hernaez,L Sanchez,C Vallejo‐Bernad,Oliver,M Sánchez‐Rubio,HK Kälviäinen,S Genzor,T González‐Nicolás,E Puerta,E Laviano,T Gimenez,C Cerdán‐Santacruz,A Fermiñán,P Muriel‐Álvarez,JE Sierra‐Grañón,J Escoll‐Rufino,E Cuello‐Guzmán,N Mestres‐Petit,M Merichal‐Resina,A Pinillos‐Somalo,Z Gomez‐Carmona,AP Vazquez‐Fernandez,JJ Trujillo‐Diaz,JLRC Rodríguez Couso,MIDR Darriba Fernández,E Riera,J Espinosa,A García‐Novoa,M Carral‐Freire,R Martínez‐Almeida,S Santarrufina‐Martínez,JC Sebastián‐Tomás,P Gonzálvez‐Guardiola,E Corral Fernández,A Sánchez Mozo,T Ivanov Stoyanov,P Casado Santamaría,E García Grimaldo,L García‐Catalá,A Fernández‐Candela,C Curtis‐Martínez,Del‐Valle‐Ruiz,A Sánchez‐Cifuentes,M Ramírez‐Faraco,AJ Fernández López,C Leon,S Kumar,M Fornell‐Ariza,S Ayllón‐Gámez,C Peña‐Barturen,L Ojea‐Ruiz‐Yherla,M Saavedra‐Chacón,JA Navas‐Cuéllar,J Perez‐Calvo,H Gomez‐Facundo,L Riba‐Combatti,O Crusellas Manas,B De‐Soto‐Cardenal,P De‐La‐Herranz‐Guerrero,C Dominguez‐Sanchez,JC Gamero‐Huaman,A Suarez‐Cabrera,AA Ramirez‐Redondo,Y Lara‐Fernandez,B Bascuas‐Rodrigo,BL Lopez‐Duran,C Caula,A Pigem,J Gil,H Salvador,P Planellas,R Farrés,ER Sanchez,A Caballero,M Arnau,R Blanco‐Colino,I Tapiolas,N Ridaura,L Sobrino Roncero,F Collado‐Roura,L Martinez Fijo,M Serrano Navidad,O Barrios Cormenzana,N Lluís Viñas,M Sorribas Grifell,M Alberich Prats,A Alvarez Torrado,S Sanz‐Navarro,E Contreras‐Saiz,L Solar‐García,M Moreno‐Gijón,A Suárez‐Sánchez,T Díaz‐Vico,D Fernández‐Martínez,JL Rodicio‐Miravalles,C García‐Gutierrez,U Pila,S Melone,L Martin‐Prieto,JA Rojo,M Gonzalez,L Zorrilla,V Soria‐Aledo,JA Garcia‐Marin,M Baeza‐Murcia,E Pellicer‐Franco,MA Jimenez‐Ballester,L Asensio‐Gomez,S Gortazar‐De‐Las‐Casas,J Guevara‐Martinez,M Lopez,L Ramirez,S Verea,F Anguita,G Navarro,A Del Castillo Criado,M Cañon Lara,E Toledo Martinez,A Sanchez‐Martinez,L Hernandez‐Gimenez,M Galofre‐Recasens,I Ferrer‐Vilela,LE Pérez‐Sanchez,M Burneo Esteves,A Menéndez‐Moreno,C Baz‐Figueroa,A Rosat,M Savoie Hontoria,N Alonso García,R Gracia‐Roman,M Pascua‐Sole,O Pino‐Perez,JM García‐Pérez,C Pineño‐Flores,D Ambrona‐Zafra,L Sanchez‐Guillen,J Sancho‐Muriel,E Alvarez,A García‐Granero,R Jiménez‐Rosellón,O Daga,A Alberca‐Paramo,S Sanchez‐Garcia,E García‐Santos,F Pareja‐Ciuró,C Olivares‐Oliver,L Navarro‐Morales,MJ Tamayo‐López,J Tinoco‐González,CO García‐Rivera,I Alarcón‐Del Agua,F Moreno‐Suero,E Pereira‐Mosquera,C Zerpa,E Llacer,A Diaz,A Caro,F Feliu,M Franco,J Escuder,M Abellan,E Padilla,M Rodriguez‐Lopez,S Mambrilla‐Herrero,KT Plua‐Muniz,M Bailon‐Cuadrado,FJ Tejero‐Pintor,E Choolani‐Bhojwani,C Vila‐Zarate,LJ Delgado‐Plasencia,L Ponchietti,G Pata,L Cousins,A Busuttil,C Baird,N Drye,OD Brown,S Mansour,O Anderson,B Woodward,R Mahapatra,JA Clements,N D'Souza,R Thompson,DJ Littlehales,AM Tang,BE Byrne,CY Tan,P Cunha,C Ogbuokiri,T Alhammali,P Eiben,F Chowdhury,G Gravante,H Kho,S Lodhia,S Dobbs,T Doulias,JCK Ng,MSJ Wilson,R Venugopal,N Panda,J Wolff,K Akhtar,HD Walji,JM Tognarelli,KA Knight,A Ansari,Hussaini,E Wright,E Gammeri,H Brewer,S Rinkoff,RL Harries,CJ Fairfield,LM Hickey,TEF Abbott,A Jackson,HL Wright,U Walters,K Carney,PC Logan,Z Mughal,E Strachan,M Boland,SM Andreani,B Chasty,A Sharma,JKY Ma,C Mazzeo,B Badii,A Armellini,M Grassia,A Perin,A Ruzzenente,F Roscio,M Magnoli,A Avanzolini,S Mulas,N Cillara,N Depalma,A Longheu,M Papandrea,L Dova,M De Prizio,GP Gusai,L Di Zitti,P Geretto,A Azabdaftari,G Chianese,C Elbetti,C Ruffolo,S Giaccari,G Salamone,V Devezas,JS Ferreira,RSA Peixoto,AD Hill,A Alshafei,G Ais,V Simo,H San José,B Ugarte‐Sierra,A De Andrés Gómez,C Cerdán‐Santacruz,J Beltran‐De‐Heredia,MC Bazán‐Hinojo,JA Navas‐Cuéllar,JC Gomez‐Rosado,A Bravo Salva,N Gómez,F Marinello,V Medina‐Arana,C Payá‐Llorente,L Vega,M Mengual Ballester,B Espina,MI Prieto‐Nieto,M Lopez,E Caballero Rodríguez,M Rodriguez‐Lopez,M Frasson,D Padilla‐Valverde,VM Duran‐Muñoz‐Cruzado,
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/bjs.11440
2019-12-03
Abstract:BackgroundAppendicitis is the most common general surgical emergency worldwide, but its diagnosis remains challenging. The aim of this study was to determine whether existing risk prediction models can reliably identify patients presenting to hospital in the UK with acute right iliac fossa (RIF) pain who are at low risk of appendicitis. MethodsA systematic search was completed to identify all existing appendicitis risk prediction models. Models were validated using UK data from an international prospective cohort study that captured consecutive patients aged 16–45 years presenting to hospital with acute RIF in March to June 2017. The main outcome was best achievable model specificity (proportion of patients who did not have appendicitis correctly classified as low risk) whilst maintaining a failure rate below 5 per cent (proportion of patients identified as low risk who actually had appendicitis). ResultsSome 5345 patients across 154 UK hospitals were identified, of which two‐thirds (3613 of 5345, 67·6 per cent) were women. Women were more than twice as likely to undergo surgery with removal of a histologically normal appendix (272 of 964, 28·2 per cent) than men (120 of 993, 12·1 per cent) (relative risk 2·33, 95 per cent c.i. 1·92 to 2·84; P < 0·001). Of 15 validated risk prediction models, the Adult Appendicitis Score performed best (cut‐off score 8 or less, specificity 63·1 per cent, failure rate 3·7 per cent). The Appendicitis Inflammatory Response Score performed best for men (cut‐off score 2 or less, specificity 24·7 per cent, failure rate 2·4 per cent). ConclusionWomen in the UK had a disproportionate risk of admission without surgical intervention and had high rates of normal appendicectomy. Risk prediction models to support shared decision‐making by identifying adults in the UK at low risk of appendicitis were identified.
surgery
What problem does this paper attempt to address?