The Topological Approach to Perceptual Organization and the Formation of Space Conception—A Review of Topological Perception Theory and Topological Primacy Thesis
Deng Xiaofeng,Yuan Ying,Li Hong
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.2013.03.001
2013-01-01
Abstract:Topological perception theory(TPET) explains perception with geometrical properties,as well as emphasizing the priority of topological perception,which is the basis that other geometrical perception depends on.The topological perception also first occurs among all of the geometrical perceptions.When the target is presented for only 5ms,the difference among topological properties can be distinguished.The visual system perceives firstly the topological properties,secondly the projective properties,thirdly the affine properties,and finally Euclidean properties.The topological primacy theory(TPRT) claims that the developmental sequence of children's space conception is topological,projective and Euclidean.Before 4 years old,children's space conception is topological,and they do not have shape and size constancy(shape and size are Euclidean properties).Although both of the two theories explain psychological phenomena topologically,there are some differences in their objects and methods.We will compare these two theories in research contents,methods and theoretical structures.In research contents,there are three main comparisons.Firstly,in geometrical properties,both of the two theories are about topological,projective and Euclidean properties;otherwise,TPET is about affine properties.They define geometrical properties in different ways.Secondly,the psychological phenomena they are concerned with are different;TPRT researches space conception,emphasizes mental representation of space instead of perception,while TPET researches visual phenomena,such as apparent motion,illusory conjunctions and global precedence,Although the two theories are different in objects and methods,their theoretical structures are highly consistent.Last but not least,the research participants are different;TPRT used children,while TPET used adults and animals,which sheds light on geometry via psychology.Comparatively speaking,the methods of TPET are more objective and rigorous,and have higher reliability and internal validity;other researchers have found the same results using the TPET methods.As the experimental scenes of TPRT are similar to real life situations,the results of TPRT have higher external validity.However,irrelevant factors are not controlled stricdy,which leads to lower internal validity.These two theories have similar theoretical structures.The theoretical structures are in line with the stability of geometric properties.Topological properties are most stable,projective properties are less stable than topological properties and more stable than affine properties,and Euclidean properties are the most unstable.