Abstract:When investing in corporate social responsibility (CSR), managers may strive for a win-win scenario where all stakeholders end up better off, but they may not always be able to avoid trading off stakeholders' interests. To provide guidance to managers who have to make tradeoffs, this study used a vignette-based experiment to explore stakeholders' intention to associate with a firm (i.e., buy from or become an employee) that trades off CSR directed at the stakeholders' own group (self-directed CSR) and CSR directed at another stakeholder group (other-directed CSR). Results show that stakeholders were not systematically more attracted to a firm that favors their own group over another stakeholder group. Specifically, stakeholders' other-orientation moderated their reaction to tradeoffs: stakeholders higher on other-orientation were willing to forego some material benefits to associate with a firm that treated suppliers in developing countries significantly better than its competitors, whereas stakeholders lower on other-orientation were more attracted to a firm favoring their own stakeholder group. Other-orientation also moderated reactions to tradeoffs involving the environment, although high CSR directed at the environment did not compensate for low self-directed CSR even for stakeholders higher on other-orientation. Second, the vignette study showed that trust mediated the relationship between tradeoffs and stakeholders' reactions. The study contributes first and foremost to the burgeoning literature on CSR tradeoffs and to the multimotive approach to CSR, which claims that other motives can drive stakeholders' reactions to CSR in addition to self-interest. First, it provides further evidence that studying CSR tradeoffs is important to understand both (prospective) employees' and customers' reactions to CSR-related activities. Second, it identifies other-orientation as a motive-related individual difference that explains heterogeneity in stakeholders' reactions to CSR. These findings suggest several avenues for future research for organizational psychologists interested in organizational justice. Third, it investigates trust as a mediating mechanism. Fourth, it reveals differences in stakeholders' reactions depending on which other stakeholder group is involved in the tradeoff. For practice, the findings suggest that tradeoffs are important because they influence which stakeholders are attracted to the firm.

Golden Geese or Black Sheep: Are Stakeholders the Saviors or Saboteurs of Financial Distress?

Stock Market Reaction To Data Breaches: The Moderating Role Of Corporate Social Responsibility

Does corporate social responsibility reduce financial distress risk?

Can Corporate Social Responsibility Decrease the Negative Influence of Financial Distress on Accounting Quality?

Corporate social responsibility dimensions and stock price crash risk: Evidence from the management's self-interest perspective

Unravelling the CSR-financial distress link: The mediating role of capital structure in Jordan’s financial sector

The impact of corporate social responsibility on investment recommendations: Analysts' perceptions and shifting institutional logics

Profit or Legitimacy? What Drives Firms to Prioritize Social Stakeholders?

Does CSR reduce financial distress? Moderating effect of firm characteristics, auditor characteristics, and covid-19

Social Capital, Trust, and Corporate Performance: How CSR Helped Companies During the Financial Crisis (and Why It Can Keep Helping Them)

Unveiling the Connection among ESG, Earnings Management, and Financial Distress: Insights from an Emerging Market

Stakeholders' Responses to CSR Tradeoffs: When Other-Orientation and Trust Trump Material Self-Interest

Corporate social responsibility: opportunistic behavior under earnings management?

Does Corporate Social Responsibility Impact on Corporate Risk-Taking? Evidence from Emerging Economy

Sustainable Strategies: Navigating Corporate Social Responsibility and Irresponsibility for Enlightened Self-Interest

Meeting Stakeholder Needs: Who Should Managers Pay Close Attention To? Evidence from Listed Chinese Manufacturing Companies

Determinants of engagement with and of stakeholders in CSR decision-making: a stakeholder perspective

Social Capital, Trust, and Firm Performance: The Value of Corporate Social Responsibility during the Financial Crisis

Shareholder Activism and Dividend Policy of the Firms: The Moderating Role of Financial Distress

The Role of Stakeholders in Corporate Governance: A View from Accounting Research

ESG peer effects and corporate financial distress: An executive social network perspective